Mariah's gonna win. Madonna is just a copycat and a whore who wants to intimidate Mariah as the leader of female artist. Mariah's been working R&B or hip hop songs for almost like a decade. She has her own formula to write songs while Madonna was just an artist who doesn't know what she wants. She just want to try to get statistics on selling chart. She even couldn't put her first single in solo. Not to say "4 minutes" is a bad song, but im gonna give credit to Justin rather than Madonna. Well, she might be the best selling female artist of all time but hey she's even more than 10 years senior than Mariah. She should be selling better than Mariah. The issue of "best selling" shouldn't be bring up unless Madonna fans feel intimidated about the real truth of the selling charts. FYI, Mariah already has about 18 #1 songs in Billboard US Chart. Take note, Madonna

i'll hit both of them

are her boobs for real?

I'll vote for Mariah Carey.
I like her pitch.
She can go damn high pitch.
Very powerful.. =D

oh come on, who cares about whether her boobies are real or not. It sounds like an old issue about her fake boobs. I could care less about it. She aint gonna use her boob to sing,plus ppl are more care about her thighs or arms, they are significantly slimmer.

true. Mariah Carey really has a good vocal..hardly can see female singers have those high pitch nowadays, her high pitch is where I like to listen to her songs, especially her ballads. Really brilliant

Madonna has better showmanship. She performs better and she's a more influential artist. Hail Ma'donut!

madonna rulezzzzzz

MC's vocals are great but her songs these days are really lousy. I love the good'ol days where songs like Vision of Love, Emotions, DreamLover, Love Takes Time and whatever else those days.......

Madonna on the other hand has been releasing many catchy tunes throughout the years. Vocally I've never thought of her as one that's close to being impressive.

Mariah wins in vocals.

Madonna wins in stage performances.

Mariah Carey wins... because of Ken Lee

Mariah Carey

i prefer MC, her vocal is nice and Madonna's 4 minutes is awesome too.

FYI, Our Madonna almost 50 and still she look like 35. Ohh, I kinda impressed with that.
P/S: Ken Lee just a Song of the Year.

As expected, Mariah Carey moves past Elvis Presley and into sole possession of second place for most No. 1s in the rock era, as "Touch My Body" soars 15-1 on the Billboard Hot 100 to become her 18th chart-topper. With her album "E=MC2" yet to hit retail, Carey might equal the Beatles' record of 20 No. 1s before her set runs its course.

"Body's" blast to No. 1 is fueled by a record-setting debut week digital tally of 286,000 downloads. That sum, good enough for the No. 1 slot on Hot Digital Songs, surpasses the 277,000 downloads labelmate Rihanna opened with in the June 9, 2007, issue with her summer smash "Umbrella."

FYI, Madonna just behind Mariah 2 spots which is #3, Not bad.
The battle of the divas had just begun

Personally i like Mariah latest song more than Madonna's.

This post has been edited by edmund87: Apr 2 2008, 10:47 PM

Hey do u know when the Billboard's chart renewed?
I think 4 minutes can be easily to be another no.1 hit with the combination of Madonna and JT.

This post has been edited by voditoleons: Apr 2 2008, 11:04 PM

It's renewed every Thursday! 4 minutes could be another #1, thanks to JT

KEN LEE FTW!!!!

Yeah, Ken Lee all the way

my vote goes to madonna, hail the queen of pop.