Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Is spaying / neutering your pet cruel?, Please read the first post before voting

views
     
Mr. Z
post Jan 15 2008, 12:08 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
601 posts

Joined: Mar 2007
From: Boleh LannD~!


If u think that spaying or neutering is bad, think about not giving your male dog to do it when the female you own is on heat. Think of their frustration and anxiety knowing that its there, but he cant do it. Males often have this kind of problem when there is a female on heat nearby. Thats mental torture if you think about it.

Are you sure that you can watch after your dog 24/7, making sure that they dun mate? what if they actually do? Do you have the financial capabilities? space? time? for another litter of dogs? Yes, you may be able to take care of their first litter, imagine half a year later another accident occur, what are you going to do with the next litter? a dog have an average lifespan of 12 years, which mean they maybe pregnant around 18 to 20 times. What are you going to do for this 18 to 20 times?

You would probably think of selling it if accidents do occur, but what if you own two different dogs? what are you going to do with their offspring? and what if you cant sell them off? Have you consider that you might be contributing to the local mixed breed population? There is enough in spca and paws and throughout the streets.

Final word, its up to the owner whether to spay or not, but the please be responsible with the them especially if you own more than one dog.
Mr. Z
post Jan 17 2008, 05:52 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
601 posts

Joined: Mar 2007
From: Boleh LannD~!


QUOTE(hamster9 @ Jan 15 2008, 11:04 AM)
Like said, if you neutered the male dog from young when he doesn't know what a female on heat means, it wouldn't be torturing. Unless it neutering a male dog who is experienced sex before.

It's like a 3 years old kid who doesn't know what sex is all about (provided he is not exposed to those information). Neutering males would like stop all these and make him forever as innocent as a 3 year old kid wink.gif
well.. for the least I placed my vote as No Comment as I feel there's both side of the story.

But neutering and spraying is not as cruel as debarking and declawing  nod.gif
*
Thats what i m trying to say. If u think it is cruel to neuter, its even crueler to not let the dog have sex even though they want to. Male dog will be a nuisance and go frustrated when a female is on heat nearby. So i think its best to neuter it if you can.

Pennywise, i dont have time to read all your replies, but from what i see, you are putting everything on god's will. I think that is very wrong. Time is different now and then. You have the power to prevent something from happening. If you have done everything you could to prevent something, and it still happens, then you can say it is god's will. If you had not done anything, please put the blame on yourself for lending a hand in making that thing happen.

Its as though a student who had not studied and fail saying that it is god's will that he fail today and suffer. I understand all of us have emotions and some really cant bear to neuter our pets. But i believe that is your ego saying. If you dun intend on breeding your pets, then just neuter them. Everything will still be functional except for reproductions. If you debark your dog, thats a different story, that i would say weigh a different sin on them.

This post has been edited by Mr. Z: Jan 17 2008, 05:57 PM
Mr. Z
post Jan 24 2008, 01:05 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
601 posts

Joined: Mar 2007
From: Boleh LannD~!


QUOTE(White Palace @ Jan 23 2008, 07:13 PM)
No doubt, adopting a stray is very nobel and should be encouraged. But sadly, there are too many, too too many dog owners out there that pick up a cute stray puppy, and when the puppy grown up so no longer cute, or the size or the temperament are not what they look for, they just dump it back to the street since they do not pay for it. This really makes stray population a never ends cycle.

I am at a position that mixed breed and purebreeds are equally lovable and yes, we might not NEED a purebreed, but it is good to have purebreeds around, isnt it? Certain people who look for a guard dog, at least they know getting a doberman will be a good choice. Those who wants a companion who stays indoor, perhaps a poodle will be a good choice.

Responsible ownership and responsible breeding is the upmost important factor if we were to talk about reducing stray population. It has nothing to do with purebreed or non purebreed. As long as the owner is irresponsible, what dog goes to it hands, he/she will just dump it to street when they face problems. Chance are higher if they do not pay for it, like what can we see around our neighbourhood. Sadly, lots of people who thought that their mongrels are not gonna get caught / stolen, they just let them roam free. Then, they mate, they deliver, then takes no responsibility to rehome the puppies, then here it goes, more strays!

Of corse, there are owners who adopted strays and view them as their precious kids, thing is, sadly, most of the people are not like that, else there wont be strays already.

If we can't educate and change people's perception, then even if we ban purebreed breedings, the stray population still wont reduce. Unless we totally ban pet ownership then, which is not we want to see. So i guess, people should really change their perception and start educating each others, purebreeds or non purebreeds really not that relevant. Humans are the culprit.
*
agreed nod.gif
I think the main emphasis here is to educate the pet's owner here, and with proper encouragement, i think we can reduce strays in the long run.
I felt that this is the main issue which is still not paid much attention to in our country. I think that seminars or promotion should be held in conjunction with dogs or cats show to promote awareness among owners who are still at the dark concerning importance of spaying and neutering.



 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0439sec    0.47    8 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 9th December 2025 - 04:13 AM