About 2 months ago I noticed that the SMART status for the hdd was 'warning' on speccy, apparently there were 28 reallocated sectors, next day it went up to 29, then for 20++ days it was fine, no increase, then it went up a bit, and two days ago it was completely toast, windows ran like crap, I could not type anything without causing the computer to freeze up, disk activity pegged at 100%, tried to clone the C partition, DiskGenius said it'd take 333 hours

The internet seems to be divided over this; some say a few reallocated sectors are fine, some say it's sure sign that your hdd is about to be completely effed.

Moral of the story, check your SMART status, pay attention to critical parameters, backup your data. Sekian.

This post has been edited by smallgiant: May 25 2025, 08:25 PM

welcum to the club, one of my hdd also bad sector 3 weeks ago

my laptop SATA HDD .. shows SMART failure since 5 years ago in 3rd party apps, but not in CMOS/BIOS

was going to tag you lol

no need remind me of the sadness lol

How long already u used the drive? If still got warranty just claim la. SSD now cheap2 only.

Thanks for reminding me to check my s.m.a.r.t status. I learned years ago, as soon as it's sluggish to access a disk, and/or starts reallocating sectors. It's time to find a replacement. Also robocopy is your friend if you're on windows, rsync on linux, to copy stuff to the new disk.

Time to make a disk copy of that failling HDD.

To perform disk copy you will need new same size HDD or SSD.

This post has been edited by GOPI56: May 25 2025, 08:41 PM

format c:

quite old, from 2018; but I've had a maxtor that lasted longer than that, actually it was still working when the mobo crapped out, and it was a maxtor.

Same bero.
Mine also just died yesterday after being in service for 13 years.
Same few months also notice torrent report bad file.
Didnt pay attention, yesterday completely unaccessible.

RIP lonely auntie contact list

I imaged the c partition after I first saw the reallocated sector.

No need lor, as long as the data in the original disk is less than the capacity of the new one, you can clone, I use DiskGenius to do that. Cloning programs that come with ssds tend to be more restrictive.

notice any sluggishness? high disk activity?

Thats why i spend $$$ get NAS.

Now i lega got backup. My experience HDD confirm will fail. Cannot predict when but will happen for sure.

I can recommend you this WD blue HDD , cheap and good, from reputable seller

cheap Western Digital WD Blue HDD Desktop Internal Hard Drive



This post has been edited by JimbeamofNRT: May 25 2025, 09:13 PM

why not get 4TB SSD terus?

cheap 4TB SP SSD

used to claim faulty NASx 2 units before… sent to supplier with the necessary documents… they returned similar NAS but with sticker showing replacement ( or to that effect)… but both didn’t last too long.. died within 2 years… the other 2 still running after 5 years..
lesson, even if it’s an exchanged unit, always backup

I have an old wd black, using that in the mean time, already installed an ssd for the boot drive. I'm a bit wary of ordering 3.5" hdd online though, malaysian sellers don't pack them correctly; bubble wrap is not acceptable for hdd, esp desktop hdd.

Silicon Power?
Avoid this brand lower end like a plague.

Famous for bait and switch on NAND + controller.

Bought two SiliconPower A55 SSDs and out of nowhere drives can't be powered on and taking all the data with it within 1 and 2 years respectively.

big fat leopard

did you claim the 3year warranty?
what mean "bait and switch on NAND + controller."?


mapren also had 3 SP drives fail within 1-2years of daily use. but he also had another SP drive which still in-use after 4years+.

So did you manage to copy out your udang collections lol?

All good data loss scares me, so have backups.

Change to SSD/NVME for boot disc. HDD is for backup only these days.

mine just completely fark my pc..cannot load into windows then press reset show check disk then know gone case lol

after that i take out put into external dock reformat try put some files in it also cannot

Mine got red warning from from CrystalDisk. Luckily still can read for backup.

how many TB prawn collection lost?

worse than mine, i could still clone the D partition. C partition was farked, I tried to clone that disk genius said it'd take 300 hours

all safe

My laptop from 2016 has bad sectors but SMART still says OK and the Seatools Self-Test says Passed. On the other hand, from my experience with WD external HDD, SMART might say OK but if the Self-Test says Failed then it's only a matter of time before it bricks. Sometimes it passes the test but a few weeks later bricked. So I bought 2 Seagate external HDD instead. Fingers crossed, hopefully they don't brick. So far I haven't had any desktop HDD bricked. A few bad sectors maybe.

in that case better get Samsung 870 EVO ssd

cheap Samsung 870 EVO SSD