https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1Xu8cZfQPj/

10 pages?

Weld joint failure?

That part is supposed to be cast single piece. And it is mounted to some bush and allows pivot moving up and down. It looks like the metal broke at the pivot point. Thats crazy!!

X90.

i predict 20 pages

habislah proton ini kali

This one proton lah , tanjung malim mari

x90 saja

rare to find 1 on the road

Wow China quality

Don’t think this part is cast.

It more on forming and bending.

Semua salah jkr y so many pothole. Road suppose to be in pristine so it won't break car suspension. Sue kau JKR for negligence

I did know Tanjung Malin is on China. Which part of China may I ask?

Malaysia roads designed for small cars not big cars

Besi ciplak ?

Sekali it link to the same steel company that supplied problematic steel to Thailand.

Quality ctrl 404

wow first time seeing this break...

Are the specific parts from china?

CCP engineering, form over function

assembled locally, not made locally because CCP brand wanted to save as much cost as possible

the irony part is china is the leading country in steel production and they can't produce top quality parts for their cars

China car 404 unless Tanjung Malim is in CCP

Salah malaysia road too much pothole make it broke, never got this problem in china

Just kidding, when will the wumao assemble?

Steel production in numbers, not in quality. Their steel factory like to do bait and switch. Just ask thailand

Local or china parts that break.

Even if it was pressed & bent and was sleeved, it should not break in that manner!!!

Chinese companies are definitely capable of producing quality parts for the cars. But whether car manufactures are paying them enough to manufacture quality parts is another question.
With the prices they are selling and to top it up with massive discounts raises a big question mark on where they are skimping at.

The urony is most consumers onlu care about the price tag and nothing else.

This post has been edited by TOMEI-R: May 25 2025, 09:32 PM

Typical CCP junk

The famous tofu steel strikes again ?

You want cheap what do you expect? 😂

Should have a truly free market let every car compete on even ground then they don't dare to disrespect your market. Pun intended 😂

In the electronics industry, an example of a part made in China is said to be rated to deliver 1A output current. But 90% of the time, designer would use maybe just 10-30% of this maximum capability. So, when you try to use closer to the "maximum rating or even just like 80% of it", this is when the parts failed. A friend of mine that owns a shop in Psar Road has plenty of this sort of purchases from China. I believe this is the same happening in any industry for parts design and made in China. The German like to build to the limit they said and the Japanese beyond the limit and CCP products are made to sekadar tahan untuk kegunaan biasa. Push it further nearer to the "maximum specification", that's when you see the real specification.

This is the most important question. Designed by Geely or Proton? Made by Geely or Proton?

Inb4 Wolf Warriors say Geely only minority 49.9% shareholder in Proton so they not responsible.

Ew ccp car

X90, ha ha,
Fast fast dispose

Not ev. Doesn't matter

last time my wira after 15 years the spring break.

the rest ok

Salah jalan lettew

CCP Proton models won't outlast even the original Saga. After 5 years or so, full of problems like Euro.

actually need to buy two, owner cheapskate, buy one now complain part broke

In be4 part supplied by local part supplier aka bumiputra company that cry mother and father just before geely take over

Ccp will be like fuck these local baggage give them chance they fuck it up like this

support our local made in china product

leftover material from sky steel? THE BRIDGE BETWEEN YOUR DREAMS AND THE SKY

Wow this is bad

sound like torsion beam

Only the old series parts are coming from local supplier while the X series a big majority of it still are from China. Proton has no volume and hence the local supplier are unable to commit. That is why the stock issues is still there and never solved because barang semua dekat China.

China made parts la. You know lar kan...

china car
interior design macam veli best
but the car itself sini patah sana patah

why not custom yourself ?

plotong what expect

trash company trash quality thanks to trash tongkat

no parts of anything geely is made here...they deemed it too expensive for them
which is why every parts had to be shipped in from china

that's why whatever that's broken in a geely nowadays or any china cars need 2 months to replace...with or without warranty

That is the surprising part. I was under the impression that the Proton Saga was STILL made locally when I accompanied my client to do Pre-Delivery Inspection. Manatau was told that everything now comes from China. Terkejut sial.

This post has been edited by Roman Catholic: May 26 2025, 08:24 AM

Really? Even that campro engine is produce in China and assembled here?

I thought they need a minimum local content to get tax preferential treatment

This post has been edited by fongsk: May 26 2025, 08:26 AM

That was what I was told by the Head Technician at the SC when I requested tests to be performed. Lets just say at this juncture, as a buyer, I wouldn't touch the current model based on what I have a seen.

Hopefully this way of doing business does not spread to other manufacturers too especially the reliable ones.

This post has been edited by Roman Catholic: May 26 2025, 08:32 AM

Campro is made partly by Perodua in Sg Chua. But seeing that parts like the gearbox and interior lights are direct Geely parts bin not surprised if certain parts made in china by Geely supplier

I happened to take a grab taxi from KLIA 2 weeks ago.
S70 model. Have to agree the interior feel luxurious but somehow, I get the floating feeling even at 70-80 km/hour. And I was sitting at the front pax seat. Both my wife and dotter also feels the same when I asked them later. So it was not my own feeling as well.

Secondly, there seems to be a huge vibration coming from the engine when the car was moving from stationary. It is like the whole front portion shakes/vibrates badly from 0-50 km/hr or thereabouts. The feel is like your wheel alignment is out and the car wobbles. It could be also the wheel are not aligned properly etc. I did not ask or speak to the driver about this as it is not nice to comment negatively to a stranger about his car.

I made these comments coming from a 3-cylinder SUV Ativa, by comparison.

China cars

Sells u leather seats, electric seats, lcd screens, ambient lighting

However, The rest of the car is shit

Listen to the experts next time. There is a reason why Japanese cars are still the best

U all haters, 5k years history is numba one in everything.

U all west lover and red eye rise of red flag ch1n@

Ahaahhaahhah

Dam. This is bad man.... Hope other owners beware and check

certain parts are still produced locally which is why u don't see part shortage for local models compared to geely cars

but 1 thing that i know is now from china is their power window regulator
they already resolved that problem 17 years ago but now problem came back meaning they switched supplier again, this time is china

gearbox is from aisin bro

U have totally misunderstood the whole concept of made in Malaysia cars.

U see the parts all come from China and assembled in Malaysia. Even if the parts were made in Malaysia, it would have still followed instruction manuals from China on how to manafacture the part according to their specs.

So since the car is already poorly engineered in China, it doesnt matter where the part is made , as long as its following a poorly engineered instruction manual, its gonna produce lousy products

Thats China for u. They simply dont have the engineering expertise to make cars. All they know how to do is put leather onto seats, put leds lights into the cabin, put wheels onto tyres , and thats why they are good in making EVs because its the easiest car to make with the least amount of engineering required.

Atas and glamor car wo
Impossible

U syukur la...people X90 patah kaki, yours just wiper

maybe after this proton will use this as an excuse to change all supplier to china.. claiming the local one quality tak boleh pakai.

Doesn't necessarily mean it need to be made in china

Just that the quality is similar or same as that

Adalah. Vendor slot in 2~3 pcs NG besi masa delivery ke Assembly line. Kalau tak mcm mn nak cover NG material cost , Aduhai.

This post has been edited by giftfre: May 26 2025, 08:53 AM

they already did...like for 2 years already if not wrong

local quality is better but CCP too cheapskate

Aisin? I read they moved to Korean one already. 4-speed automatic gearbox

Yup. Same feeling when i drove my friends S70. I dont understand how ppl can say S70 is a good car.

Plenty of other cars never have this problem many 10 year old cars and never break suspension

This post has been edited by Raddus: May 26 2025, 09:05 AM

Because they dont have the engineering expertise. Just because u have a good raw material doesnt mean u can turn it into a high quality product.

Same concept as I give u lee zi jia badminton racquet, does that mean u can play as good as him?

wonder how deep was the pothole

yup, until that hyundai gearbox plant shut down thn they changed to aisin 4AT

Relax, baru sebijik.

same as honda lah....steering rack has never been a thing that is changed every year

all my cars over 10 years also never changed steering rack or anything related
thn comes a brand/car that needs to changed every year religiously

I will not comment that S70 is not a good car etc, as it can create unhappiness to the buyers/users. But I am sharing what I felt when riding the car. Maybe 55 mins ride was too short to make a good judgement but my comments are based on personal experience, rightly or wrongly. I am not condemning S70 in any way.

Oh, that is news to me. Thanks.

Preventive maintenance kot. Honestly I was contemplating getting HRV but hearing the stories about the steering wheel rack defect, decided not to. One of my friends’s civic kena also.

CCP cannot trust

AMAZING TOFU DREG CHINA MADE STEEL !! VERY STRONKKK!!

driver go layan offroad?

you see what chinese steel did to collapse tower in Thailand?

Wolf Warriors still say Tanjung Malim lol.

Crossover SUV cannot layan offroad? Wadepak?

This post has been edited by JohnL77: May 26 2025, 10:27 AM

tanjung malim is an assembly plant....not a manufacturer plant

car manufacturer in fact don't manufacture anything...they're only designer and assembler

all the other parts are made from bosch, denso, APM, aisin, GMB...etc etc

why use good steel when you can max profit using shit steel and pass it off as good steel?

18 years ago, our company driver in middle east always remind us dont buy C**a cars , he say many cases car crash due to under carriage part cabut. That time i dont understand what he meant. but now i see what he was trying to say. (he kimchi car)

your product represent your country's image

that's why USA always use that slogan to advertise their product last time
if it's built american, it's gonna last....and they actually did that

china could've made their car tough and give middle finger to USA but they didn't and missed the opportunity

CCP steel no standard

This Chery memang... oh wait.. wrong manufacturer... this one must protek.
Protek -> Ini pasti driver issue langgar banyak pothole pada kelajuan tinggi bila kereta overloaded dengan 9 orang siap dengan bagasi.

expecting to see chery omoda tapi peloton

China just use propaganda, fake news and AI generated content to create impression everthing is good.

Baru je plan nak beli x90. Tak jadi la mcm ni....

Normally people said Perodua is the one that got 'sampan' feeling. But in your case, it is proton.

1 dalam seribu kad or cek balik rezeki awak kad sudah keluar o not?

It shows how Proton quality has fallen after becoming Baoteng.

Last time complain power window (still an issue), now metal suspension parts also break.

Ini mesti salah owner bawak SUV dia pergi offroad. SUV bukan untuk offroad.

This post has been edited by JohnL77: May 26 2025, 11:33 AM

Yes, surprisingly so. That’s why I qualify my statement to say one of my ride is Ativa, to provide a comparison. I really did feel the floating even at 70-80 km/hr. Maybe side effect of after flight as well. But I had taken flights and take bezza, vios, city, saga before. No such ‘floating’ feel.

Another point to note also is the sound when passing those speed control strips on the road. The feel is not comfortable and the sound of the blip blip invades the cabin very loudly.

Again, I must stress that I am saying all these not to belittle or try to sabotage proton or S70. This is just my feeling when taking the S70. What I commented also can be due to the maintenance of the car since it is used for Grab.

This post has been edited by fongsk: May 26 2025, 11:34 AM

Proton habis long time ago.. Now using tongkat on both sides only, that's why looks ok.

This post has been edited by Roman Catholic: May 26 2025, 12:12 PM

i got once tailgate by a s70 on highway, my car 120km/h sudah bola kecut and ke tepi let the x70 to take over, so i am thinking this s70 must be very stable

p/s i got no intention to be road hogger but ngam ngam wanna take over a car in the middle lane so x70 tu yg laju when i am overtaking