‘Beli Rumah, Tapi Macam Masuk Gym’ – Reka Bentuk Pangsapuri Dikritik Netizen

Baru-baru ini, sebuah projek pangsapuri yang dikenali sebagai Pangsapuri Idaman BSP di Bandar Saujana Putra menjadi tular di media sosial.

Dengan harga mampu milik bermula RM234,000 untuk unit seluas 1022 kaki persegi, projek ini kelihatan menarik pada awalnya.

Tetapi, rupa bentuk rekaannya yang unik – panjang melintang seperti “barisan kereta api” – telah mencetuskan pelbagai persoalan di kalangan netizen.

Salah satu keluhan utama yang muncul dalam komen adalah isu tempat letak kereta yang jauh daripada unit penghuni, terutamanya untuk penghuni yang berada di hujung blok.

Ada yang bergurau, tinggal di Pangsapuri Idaman BSP boleh “kurus dalam sebulan” kerana jarak berjalan kaki dari tempat letak kereta ke unit kediaman boleh jadi jauh.

Namun, ada yang menangkis dakwaan ini dengan menjelaskan bahawa setiap unit disediakan dua tempat letak kereta: satu di tempat letak kereta bertingkat, dan satu lagi di luar bangunan.

Seorang pengguna Facebook turut mempersoalkan rasional di sebalik reka bentuk bangunan ini. Antara spekulasinya termasuk:

Adakah ini disebabkan syarat tanah yang panjang tetapi sempit? Adakah ia rekaan paling menjimatkan untuk pemaju? Adakah pembeli tidak sedar mengenai isu rekaan ini semasa membuat tempahan?

Persoalan-persoalan ini menimbulkan perbincangan di kalangan orang ramai, yang mana ada yang menyalahkan pemaju kerana tidak mengambil kira keselesaan pembeli.

Menariknya, pangsapuri ini dijual dengan nilai pasaran sekitar RM300,000 walaupun harga asalnya hanya RM234,000.

Bagaimanapun, terdapat laporan bahawa projek ini sudah mula dilelong, walaupun ia baru siap.

Hal ini menimbulkan tanda tanya besar: Adakah projek ini terlalu “viral” sehingga pembeli tidak melakukan kajian terperinci sebelum membeli?

Pelbagai komen di media sosial, ada yang menyokong dan menganggap harga mampu milik ini sesuai untuk keluarga muda yang baru ingin memiliki rumah sendiri.

Namun, ramai yang menyuarakan rasa tidak puas hati terhadap isu jarak dan kemudahan.

Seorang pengguna menulis, “Parking bertingkat pun jauh. Kalau macam ni, lebih baik beli rumah landed yang dekat dengan kereta.”

Yang lain pula menyatakan, “Kalau untuk harga macam ni, berbaloi asalkan tahu cabaran sebelum pindah.”







From google map to the very edge is 440m. The occupant needs to exercise daily to walk back.

This post has been edited by Jazted: Jan 9 2025, 11:01 AM

Confirm gonna have motorcycle in lift later.

I don't mind walking.
What I hate is parking that must go round and round to get to your floor.

There should be a straight ramp to the top floor with exits for each level.

where the playground?

Dengan harga mampu milik bermula RM234,000 untuk unit seluas 1022 kaki persegi, projek ini kelihatan menarik pada awalnya.

I read in FB last night for this price, owner gets 2 parking lots each. One in multi storey and another at open car park.

Ape lagi mau?

In fb comments, many owners posted, owners pon tak bising, yg bising org luar pulak. Yg complain dipercayai belum tentu yg dah beli rumah sendiri pon kan

This post has been edited by jojolicia: Jan 9 2025, 10:52 AM

Too far to walk back home

Normally in private condo, the more expensive your unit (literally higher floors) the nearer your car park to the lift

Imagine this one is at open field how they going to allocate the car park?

This is the condo that the playground is located at the end of the compound. U need to drive there coz walking is too far lolol

Bandar Saujana Putra

Can exercise

Read my post 7

Klu ko tasuka, ko jangan la beli.

Projek dia, sukak hati dia la nak design camne ... kan.

lol i saw this, this is the one when otw to KLIA/Johor Elite highway right

their playground also like hundreds of meter away from the unit

i notice some ppl already got a good deal but then still complain here and there. You get what you pay for

better than those condo that provide one parking and end up all double park on the road

Jalan jer la pemalas

wah, (the 1st pic) if your unit is at the top left, and your parking space for multilevel is at the bottom right....

This post has been edited by smallbug: Jan 9 2025, 10:52 AM

B40 memang malas.

diu cb 440m also complain far
no wonder Malaysians many fat fark

good mah.. mcm gym better than mcm penjara..

but imagine when u reach home and u forgot sth in your car.. LEL gg

at the edge after the parking lot, walk there and walk back probably more than 1km.

Good exercise to and from car.

or get an electric scooter

Soon b40 won't pay maintenance cause carpark too far. Madani to intervene.
If really need to take max loan, do it rather stay with b40.

This post has been edited by JoeYoung: Jan 9 2025, 10:58 AM

While it is a strange design, WALK LA FATSO

i sudah kena

reached lift lobby, then realise, forgot to take phone/keys/bag/laptop in the car

[CODE]

Bagut lah… sihat malaysia

Anneh see those type M familly majority all badan besar2 like samoan nowadays

passed by this place last month
literally 1st thought is "why building so loooooooong?"

Sabar bos. Jangan trigger 👀

Marah sangat machem da beli rumah kat sini jew 😏😏

Start small, grow bigger later

that land must be so cheap for them to be able to do it this way

Some people have unrealistic demand, better to ignore them.

This is literally living at the edge.

Felt sorry for the elderly residents though.



I think one of the way to soften the blow is to designate a special path from on end to another, for residents to do busness/open stalls. So every 50m can sit down and rest, replenish energy.

This post has been edited by alanyuppie: Jan 9 2025, 11:12 AM

Nah, not triggered nor marah.

Just putting a point across after reading the fb comments last night. One posted, need to call grab ride to send kids to the playground. Hahaaha

I saw this new building while driving back to jb last xmas

This post has been edited by jojolicia: Jan 9 2025, 11:15 AM

Easy to solve. Just disable lift at ground floor, first floor and second floor. Then if moto wants to enter life, must push manually to 3rd floor first.

Bercukurlah.

Yo walk more.

More sihat.

Make me remember my apartment near Klang. The nicer apartment many big size. Overweight.

Meanwhile the B40 flat nearby. Most of their dwellers body sihat, slimmer. I see their wife and kids…even cross the main road go rows&rows of shoplot nearby just by walking. They walk a lot. Average all slimmer than my apartment M40 pipur

its not about walking

i have to drive many rounds up to my parking lot

Omg

Yeah thats really annoying mang…

Especially if the ramp is tight…

my big mistake for never check the existence of speed ramp

Any architect here and share why they build like that?

Why not build parking below apartment? Then that current parking area can build another block to sell even more income no?
Instead of 3 blocks now cam build 4 blocks

This post has been edited by WaCKy-Angel: Jan 9 2025, 11:21 AM

so the ones complaining are cacat or OKU?
or they are just simply cacat otak?

High cost and longer time frame to complete the whole development boz…

Mao piling deeper and gestation period longer…then once stabilize mao upah many worker and rush2 stacking2 all the pre fab wall…. Really high cost…

Wait till they need to pay for maintenance fees, most will not pay and then ask why play group no maintain / lift no maintain / corridor light spoil & Etc

it's a rumah mampu milik so of course developer don't care about the design

but some condo like the 1 in DPC also have seperate building parking lot and residential. have to walk from parking lot to the next building to access your home

1000 sqf for myr 250k

Sigh .. how come dont have at my area

200k apa lu mau?

Depend on the cost

If land cost < construction cost they design the car park outside.

If land cost > construction cost, they will design inside the building with an elevated car park.

There is also a basement carpark mostly in mall area but it need constantly fresh air ventilation running and prone to flood if didn't handle proper.

why cannot build the carpark under the condo? can save land space and be more efficient in land use.

It's 440m. Not 440km, or even 4.40km. Don't be a pussy and walk to your car. That's why we have so many fatso ppl in Malaysia.

Lemah

Already one unit up for auction.



This post has been edited by JoeYoung: Jan 9 2025, 11:39 AM

Lol saw this apt once... so weird the parking lot design.

Those who's car are parked at the end of the outdoor lot, good luck getting in your car under heavy rain.

At least they can build metal shelter right...

This post has been edited by a_dot_el: Jan 9 2025, 11:42 AM

Becauae based on other low cost. They end up parking on the road because lazy and that affects traffic.

lol like my sister's condo.

parking 4 level but actually 8 level since half floor.
drive from one end to half floor to other end to get to other half floor.

in the end basically climb 8 floors. sialan.

just buy mini electric scooter..

200k++ can find landed?

few tasik/lombong sebelah. maybe soil not so good? dunno

design problem... but might as well dont give carpark...

This kind of car park design very stressful if you have small children. Imagine some kids fall asleep and you have to carry the kids up or face their tantrum throwing if have to wake them up. Or buying groceries and having to lug it all the way. If got partner around oklah but if you happened to be the one doing the kids pick up plus groceries, nightmare I tell you.

RM2XXk for 1k sqf and 2 car parks. What more can u asked for?

200k. apa lagi mau

Jual

No showroom and plan layout? when purchase? or kena deceived.

rumah selangorku are just modern day PPR. just deal with it la.
maybe in a year or two got double parking issues. tarik handbrake and your windows will pecah.

I noticed a huge huge lake just directly behind. My layman guess, soil bearing capacity & cost.

There are /k experts here may answer you better.



This post has been edited by jojolicia: Jan 9 2025, 12:20 PM

Passby before.
Inb4 harga B40 jgn complain bnyk.

Parking lot there can install individual EV charger?

Sangka baek

>Siap litar drag utk rempit

ideal way would b building underground carpark under the block but guess would b too costly

celaka punye bifoti , xde duit lagi mau complain banyak .....

not architect here, but from what i recall some similarities during the early MRT phase on why they dont just do tunnelling for all MRT, anything that involves digging costs a tonne more in terms of money and time and effort.

also reminder that PPRs arent designed to be sold on profit so they will adjust whenever possible to fit into the building budget.

land should be much cheaper too in that region compared to prime areas of Selangor/KL. thus cheaper if they just make most of the parking on the ground level

suka shj complaint, tak suka mengapa beli?

beli lah self parking car

pergi thailand

jalan , tak complaint

Sekali thunder storm gg liao basah

Looking at TS 2nd photo, can guess roughly already why. The project was built right next to a what appears to be ex-mining pond/lake?

Maybe architect/engineers figured it wasn't wise to go below the lake water level. Since this a PPR (I think) maintenance coz in the long run, it is going to be costly, in terms of pumps and other infra maintenance. Tenants in PPR aren't known to be good paymasters of maintenance fees.

**added.... From Google Map, it seems the development area may have been partially reclaimed land. Don't think natural landscape can be so straight especially at lake edge. Even more reasons to not build underground/basement carparks.



This post has been edited by speedy3210: Jan 9 2025, 01:48 PM

Last few months the pond behind collapse

Won't and cannot be, Unless you rent car park from other block

B40 is like that until after few years start got ppl throwing rubbish from above

Gang below 300k. Things to expect
1. Motor and bicycle in the lift
2. Floor corridor as cloth hanging and full of flower pot
3. Facilities pecah
4. Unit service fees outstanding can’t fit in A3 paper
5. Swimming pool macam sungai, can wear anything. Expect baby just bogel jer

oh this place.

Always see it when otw to KLIA

6. Always got pee inside lift

Tara baik bersangka negatif seperti yini

Kita kena bercukur ayam kendurilah

that's perfect length for 0-400m

Starting e-scooter rental biz there has big potential 😋

Kiter buat jer la kenduri tepi swimming pool, macam best kan… nanti ah kak boleh order khemah datang setup

When reaching home, realized left some important items in the car, there you go jogging 2 km liaw.

so far

when u buy that house ; u dunno this is what u going to get?

This post has been edited by fantasy1989: Jan 9 2025, 03:07 PM

It's not even 1KM...

Nonono im not saying underground basement parking. Just ground parking then only apartment above.

Tunngu news land beside lake collapse