Give your point why S70/MG5 is better than the other one

really?

after you have witnessed the safety test that /k have posted?

Na I know nothing. So I wanna see everyone opinion

s70 and its not even close

MG5 ncap 0 star

MG brand reliability sucks more than Proton.

Heard from my colleague in UK, when I randomly asked about MG car brand. Said MG reliability and quality gone down the drain after China company takeover MG.

MG5 probably DOA.

power kalah same pricepoint car (s70)
reputation/reliability kalah the b segment jap competitor (shitty and perodua vios)

DOA =?

Ancap for mg5 is zero. Kosong. Telur ayam. It does have air bag. But not enough to protect u during the test level accident.

Dead on arrival

No point to compare rubbish ccp car as in the end, both are still rubbish.

Whichever having a nearer serv center. Currently it's S70. I don't want to drive far far to service my MG5.

This post has been edited by Capt. Marble: Oct 7 2024, 02:34 PM

S70 best Chinese car, rest I no trust

S70 need to buy 2

MG5 need to buy 1 and throw away

didn't know about the MG sold to China. no wonder all of a sudden this year MG appear like goreng pisang. i was wondering about the sudden sales of the brand. now it makes sense. to be honest the design is quite nice, dunno about the ride quality but I've heard of the shit safety issues and wondered why this euro car can lepas this kind of safety.

Yup, MG brand is currently owned by the Chinese state-owned SAIC Motor Corporation

/k opinion is the car has 0 star safety.

lol 0 star rating. As usual, Malaysia dumping ground for cars CCP dont want. From 3 cylinders to toy car EVs.



This post has been edited by jcheong: Oct 7 2024, 02:46 PM

topkek dua dua pun cina.

so dua dua pun dua kali lima.


This post has been edited by Similanjau: Oct 7 2024, 02:46 PM

I saw demo car on road yesterday. The back looks like Peugeot. The car is much bigger than vios city.

Malaysia lacks smart consumers who can do research before purchasing a car.

MG brand now owned by SAIC Motor.

You would know SAIC sub-brand Maxus here.

Seriously, Geely way better than SAIC group, IMO

One is c segment, another one is B segment. U go see s50 in front of eyes straight away know this is a B segment car size.

Not only these.
Rakyat allow their master aka Politikus crony to provide expensive 'cheap car' in the market with low safety requirement for new car sold in this country.

This country, after develop for few decades, in year 2024, we still able to buy tin kosong car from perodua. Sad or not...

Inb4, Rakyat tak kisah....ada gaya and tongkat cukup

0 ANCAP MG5

dare to die ke?

S50 is what car?

even axia got 4 stars....

ASEAN NCAP's assessment of the Perodua Axia model 2023 was carried out in February of the same year and it successfully achieved a 4-star rating

Dunno him. Maybe he come from 2026

They dare bring thai base specs to Malaysia ???

Toyota Vios. Proven reliability and RV.

Don't let me see you open thread here in 5 years butthurt your junk car break down and cannot find parts. When you try to sell is only worth RM10k.

Side track..

Seldom drive below 64 kmh unless traffic jam, hence NCAP ratings done at those speeds are pretty much irrelevant to me. Also impact test are not done with commercial vehicles

Here's the 5 star rated Ativa

Only p1 and p2 can get away with that…

For their budget range models…

MG
Masuk Garage

ancap is aussie. omp puteh

even 64km/j also 0 star ..so your speed punya 5% survival rate will become 0.1%

Safest is just go with 5 star Euro ncap…

The most stringent there is…

If only this 2 i take MG 5.

"So, why is it zero-star? In a world of five-star becoming standard, what actually makes the MG5 a zero-star car is down to tech as much as crash protection. ANCAP publishes a detailed report on the base model it tested, noting MG5’s lack of driver monitoring, lane support, speed limit information and child presence detection, among others. While it does have autonomous emergency braking, it doesn’t work at junctions, crossings, potential head-on collision or reversing. All this meant it earned just 2.48 points from 18 (13 per cent) in the Safety Assist section. It also scored low (37 per cent) in Adult Occupant Protection crash testing, a result of things like lack of seat-belt pre-tensioners, while the results were average/reasonable in the two other evaluated areas: 58 per cent for child occupants, and 42 per cent for pedestrian/external people protection. "

Geely is better lo

This post has been edited by kelvinfixx: Oct 7 2024, 03:42 PM

mana TS Bodo option?

Why MG5 sold so many in thailand, but Proton no dare to enter market to sell S70 there?

This is also a celup c segment la, when compare acceleration or what liao, ngeh ngeh compare with B segment, don’t wanna compare with ketam Altist equivalent.

+1 bravery for them to even report it honestly.

i might not like S70 but i will never recommend buying a petrol china car

MG5 best car for suicider

1.5NA vs 1.5 turbo
Cvt vs 7 speed dct
0 star ncap vs 5 star ncap

This MG 5 use GM based engine. So no go. If this car off warranty period already prepare to dump the car la

I pakai alza only ,😕
I think better get S70
Mg5 0 star crash ancap

U try open the door see which one heavier take that one

5 star ancap vs 0 star ancap

Lol pretty easy actually

both are rubbish
but MG is worse...no one will buy over from u if u plan to sell it

buy MG, better marry tow truck driver dotter first

MG5 - Meet God Fast

MG4 passed euro ncap and other global ncap with high rating.

While this MG5 performed so bad in the AUS ncap to the point you don’t need to see other regions liao.

So if you want buy MG, get a MG4 or upcoming Cyberst.

Thailand don’t have RON95 subsidies, owai they can smuggle from Kelate.

u mistaken ANCAP and Asean NCAP

asean ncap is purely bullshit thats why even junk so many junk can score 5 stars

Of course s70 is everything value

But still got people don't want PROTON BAGDE, will goes for MG5 because it looks cool. lel.

I jsut browsed in TH only 2 air bags but in MY got 6 air bags ?

No wonder price is cheap in TH

aus doesnt give a rat ass about china, infact there was high level 'fighting' last time

This post has been edited by Selectt: Oct 7 2024, 06:00 PM

https://www.wapcar.my/news/review-proton-s7...f-factors-82018

Review: Proton S70 in Malaysia - Comfy, spacious, powerful; but let down by a couple of factors 22

9.56 L/100 km (10.45 km/litre).

A figure like this puts the S70 below its nearest-priced B-segment rivals (the Toyota Vios does 6.1 L/100 km, while the Honda City musters 6.3 L/100 km). If we compare it to the Honda Civic - fair game, given the S70's size and power - the Japanese competition is still better, coming up to 8.7 L/100 km.

s70 fuel consumption higher even than Civic
vs
MG5 a claimed fuel efficiency of 17.5km per litre

https://soyacincau.com/2024/10/03/mg5-malay...-vios-city-s70/

This post has been edited by kel32: Oct 7 2024, 11:14 PM

I wonder what is the additional cost of travel for 100,000km Vs city/Vios/civic?

Any pro can calculate?

Got, check the Pro X variant at MG Thai website

Thai controlled it probably with gov

no way they gonna let MY snatch their monies one

saw lots of this at Phuket

looks damn normal there

Topkek

Got ccp butthurt until lipot this, topkekkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk