The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
David Fincher is really building a strong reputation with his latest movie, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, by far 2008's most ambitious film. In this movie, we follow the life of Benjamin Button (Brad Pitt), who was born old, ages backwards and died as an infant. While the ultimate premise is fantasized, the theme and plot of the movie isn't. Throughout Benjamin's life, we see him growing up (or rather getting younger), meeting people, experiencing great adventures, and of course fell in love, with Daisy (Cate Blanchett). If this reminds you of Forrest Gump, you're spot on, as Eric Roth was one of the screenwriters.
This is where David Fincher comes in, the man behind the cameras. With more than a decade of experience behind him, he directs this movie with perfection, so much so I regard this as his best work to date, even surpassing cult classics Se7en and Fight Club. He brings together a tough screenplay, churns it into something magical and tops it off with brilliant performances from Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett. The Fincher-Pitt partnership is sure to be the next Scorsese-DeNiro, especially after this movie.
Though this film succeeds in all aspects - technically, visually and emotionally, you'll start to wonder, how different can this movie be without the idea of Benjamin aging backwards? Yes, we see a different perspective of love and life from his point of view but really, what can be learned from this movie? It makes us think, it makes us wonder, but it's surely isn't something that can be grasped and reflected on reality, because no one ages backwards. This is my only gripe from this film and personally a real big one.
That aside, like I said, it's a truly magical and beautiful film. Spellbinding in all areas. And athough I wouldn't want to see this movie bagging the Best Picture award, I wouldn't be all pissed if it really wins it come February. However, I would really want to see David Fincher winning Best Director, his statue is way overdue, give it to him already! Brad and Cate for nominations that's for sure. Highly recommended.
3.5/5
Revolutionary Road.
Mendes is back at his depressing sub-urban family breakdown thing again, and while Revolutionary Road might not compare favorably to his breakthrough American Beauty, it still is a movie of great merit that demands at least a viewing; a chronicle of shattered dreams and "hopeless emptiness".
Of course, if you don't like melodrama this is one movie you will not enjoy sitting through. Lots of shouting, crying, cheating, screaming and what have you. Yet somehow the movie does not rely solely on theatrics and it is the simple moments that stand out the most. Although I have to say, DiCaprio and Winslet sure can argue with each other quite well.
Personally I think all 3 of Mendes' previous works are great, but as opposed to most people I like Road to Perdition slightly more than American Beauty.