Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Anyone with PHEV Cars? Best & better than EV only?

views
     
Quazacolt
post Oct 21 2023, 10:49 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,365 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(constant_weight @ Oct 13 2023, 07:37 AM)
Experience is a lot better traffic jam, engine remain off longer then HEV at "0%" state. Unless one get stuck at Bukit Bintang friday evening jam, car don't move for 20-30min straight, other normal occation engine never turn on at stop even when battery show 0%.

Even when engine charging the battery at idle, PHEV is a lot quieter than HEV due to much much power engine. HEV tiny engine need to rev high rpm to charge.
HEV noise when charging battery when car is stop is enough to interrupt the conversation people sitting in the car. Kinda pause for few seconds, here come the noise, before continue.

I get below 7L/100km or above 14.3km/l over 760km distance day trip, with no change to charge. This is from actual refuel of 53L, not trip computer. Although my trip computer is accurate and true to refuel amount.

Can HEV more fuel economy than PHEV? In some case, sure. However HEV has only 25% of horsepower vs PHEV on average, and the result is on average 10-20% better fuel economy versus PHEV that don't charge at all.
Of course price also 30% of PHEV, but being said that if one can afford PHEV, there is no reason to settle for HEV.
*
I've now co owning a HRV RS hybrid, HEV.
overall experience is not as bad as you said, but yes hybrid car not very fuel saving after all

Especially highways and even more so long distance
I'm getting 15-16 KM/L Melaka to KL then KL to Ipoh. (90-120km/h)

Civic FE on highways can go between 16-20 KM/L, at slightly higher speeds. (110-140km/h)

Yes the engine stays in a ton longer on highways, EV light comes on very less compared to stop go traffic lights /traffic jams. (Generally urban driving)
That's where HEV/ hybrids/EV shines.

The puny 1.5L Atkinson engine screams are there, but not loud enough to interrupt conversations.

But yes, like you said, PHEV comes at a premium, it "should" be a given being better, and whatever you saving will never ROI your money spent on the car.

Similarly to buying HEV vs ICE variants
Quazacolt
post Oct 22 2023, 12:11 AM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,365 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(constant_weight @ Oct 21 2023, 11:32 PM)
Or maybe Honday HEV manage the charging hell a lot better the Prius  tongue.gif I haven't have change to sit in HEV in that kind of traffic.

My philosophy - The ROI from car are the experiences, the time spent, the place visited, the people sat in together, the freedom, non of it is about the money.
RV is nonsense, sooner or later even property RV will down the drain with world aging population, unless the property is in India.
*
Well, Honda's latest HEV is all new and entirely new design philosophy vs Toyota tried and true. Reliability is definitely a question mark only eased by its 8 years and unlimited mileage warranty

Basically, it's an EV, with a Honda petrol power generator to charge it lol.
Someone in Honda took that meme really literally lol
But of course not exactly that as both EV and ICE can run together and Honda used a ton of its peak combined torque figures for marketing.

Not just RV, more towards fuel saving where electrification is harped to reduce usage of Dino juice.
But yes as mentioned, the reality is you've spent so much on the car, it takes damn long usage, mileage and duration (many many years, and even making the assumption that government took away the RON95 subsidies and fuel price doubled) of ownership to get back the fuel savings ROI to the additional premium you've spent for the HEV. (As compared to if you've just bought the regular Dino juice guzzler l.

RV, probably a thing for my wife(since very loyal Honda fans/owner), to me, considering the car i personally own, it's obvious i don't really care about RV at all.

Side tracking to properties, the forever Illusive properties Bubble bursting is still being talked upon

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0123sec    0.43    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 25th November 2025 - 02:21 PM