Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Help! Honda City Hatchback RS e:HEV or Toyota?, What's your verdict!

views
     
Quazacolt
post Nov 27 2022, 07:26 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 26 2022, 01:50 PM)
I have been lookiing at Honda City Hatchback RS e:HEV. Is this worth it?

My main usage:
1. Drive to work, to and fro.
2. Don't really need to fetch anybody in the car.
3. City driving only; sometimes long distance (RARE)
Main Considerations:
1. Hybrid - probably saves some fuel? I know changing battery is expensive but this model comes with 8 years unlimited warranty, no mileage limits.
2. Toyota/Honda because of cheaper maintenance and generally these brands are very reputable and reliable.
3. My current very well-maintained Honda City is about 16 years old, and still works like a charm.
4. Hybrid cars are generally quieter. And most likely still will even if it goes up to 10 years old?

I did consider C-Segment cars - Honda Civic and Toyota Altis (Especially Altis cause i really really love the look). Should I look into these upgrade? Cause Honda City Hybrid costs about RM110K on the road.....
*
Any hybrid isn't worth it. Period.
Whatever fuel saving is fucked over by shit pricing and bad RV and it's likely to stay the same at least another 3-5 years unless there's huge government tax incentives and/or sharp increase in fuel prices.
Either which isn't likely to happen at least not drastically and not in the short term considering political instability and the crazy wealth gap we are experiencing post pandemic.

If you want a hybrid, you're only getting it because you can afford the luxury and/or electric instant torque.
Every other reason is just not valid/bullshit.

If your budget is 110k, you can rule out c segments.

QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 26 2022, 03:07 PM)
These are the cars within my budget la.
*
What list of cars exactly you're looking at?
What exactly is your budget?

QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 26 2022, 07:07 PM)
Mazda 3 is definitely out cause I don’t wanna have high maintenance. I always sit my colleague’s car Mazda 3, doesn’t seem to impress me much.
*
Within 5 years free service Mazda 3 isn't any much higher maintenance then other c segments.

In general, any c segments will be higher than your city petrol or hybrid.
They are all on similar levels of higher price and the maintenance will reflect that price.

Good you're not impressed as logically Mazda 3 is a driver centric car. It make sense at you're only a passenger.

If you prefer smaller cars, just forget any c segments.

QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 26 2022, 07:08 PM)
I don’t know if I will change car after 5 years? I plan to use longer than that. Car is not something that I change like changing clothes like some people. I don’t need it to show off, I just need it to last, and doesn’t give me much problems with proper maintenance and all. In the long run it should save money?
*
Then i personally recommend you either:
1) keep your current city
2) change Proton Iriz, a spec below the active if you do hate SUV like me.
3) hybrid won't save you money. It's a luxury item for the rich. If you're rich, sure why not.

QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 26 2022, 07:59 PM)
I’m not really impressed of the car though. Lol.
And I know down the line it won’t be worth it.
HRV is so expensive, and like I mentioned SUV is not my thing. I generally think that MY should follow Europe example and put high taxes for SUV and pick up trucks especially, less pollution.
*
Yeah i personally also think Mazda 3 is over hyped. But my opinions aside, you could perhaps test drive it and have a more objective judgement towards that car.

That said, you could make it clearer that you absolutely hate SUV and will reject any SUV suggestions. It'll be easier for everyone. (Can't blame them, the market is highly in favour of SUV over sedan and small hatchbacks)
Quazacolt
post Nov 27 2022, 09:29 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 27 2022, 01:42 AM)
I saw the YouTube, from real Thailand footage. The interior looks so cheap? I always think between Honda city and Vios, City always has better interior.
*
If even the new 2023 Vios doesn't entice you, then no to Toyota Vios/Yaris/Altis, no Toyota basically.

QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 27 2022, 10:14 AM)
The plastic/vinyl finishing looks really cheap. That’s how I ended up with Honda City as my current car as well last time cause the vios finishing was really bad.
*
New city hatchback is pretty much plastic everywhere. Imho worse than current Yaris and new Vios will pull ahead on interior. So with this i take it you're bias in favour of Honda. (And that's very fine. My in law side exclusively only buy Honda cars and also happens to have a city hatchback)

QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 27 2022, 01:36 PM)
See the quality, the interior quality is so much difference between the 2022 and 2023.
The 2023 one reminds me of Proton Saga interior quality.  doh.gif
*
Yeah you're no to Proton and no to 2023 Toyota Vios, make it easier for yourself : no Toyota. (Unless you're still open on that, then go test drive Toyota, and i HIGHLY encourage you to test drive the Proton Iriz)

QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 27 2022, 06:52 PM)
Cause hand itchy, so I’m just scouting around. But like you said my car can easily outlast me. Cause it’s very well maintained, exterior interior and engines. No big or major repairs needed except parts that need to be changed due to wear and tear.

SUV is a nope for me. Hybrid or not.

The only reason I consider hybrid is whether or not it will save me money monthly.
*
Almost everything, except the bare metal chassis, is wear and tear. including the entire drive train and yes that includes engine and transmission.

Ok no hybrid it is
You can almost close topic already considering last part topic name

QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 27 2022, 07:32 PM)
Yeah I heard that Mazda is a driver centric car. But the prices are way too steep, in terms of value for money, Honda and Toyota win hands down.

These days SUVs are way too popular. Lol. Don’t know what’s the hype with it except that it’s big and tall. And more emissions.

By the way what’s the instant electric torque that you mentioned?

No to Proton cars. Like you recommended, I either keep my current car. Or it’s back to Vios, City, City Hatchback or Yaris.

The only car that I might consider to upgrade from what I have is Altis.

I will have to go there personally to test them all out to see if I wanna upgrade or not.
*
Yes Mazda 3 expensive cuz CBU. Your observation is correct and i also agree it isn't worth it.

Correction a bit, strictly In terms of value, only Proton and Perodua will win hands down because of our NAP. that isn't changing any time soon.

world is trending to SUV because ingress and egress of vehicle is easier, generally more spacious, higher position gets better view ahead and its more resistant to terrain issues such as floods.
I personally hate SUV (too) but it is what it is.

Explained by Ivan, hybrid and EV, their electric motors can produce 100% Rated torque (depending how powerful the motors are) instantly as opposed to waiting RPM to climb on internal combustion engines (ICE)

so let's sum it up:
1) (assumption) budget under 100k
2) no c segment
3) no Toyota
4) no city sedan
5) no Proton
6) no hybrid
7) no SUV
8) considering reliability, conti are out
9) Koreans also out as they no longer selling hatchbacks

so you only got maybe... City hatchback full spec
Process of elimination thumbup.gif

Or keep your current car, see what the future holds after 1-3 years later.
Quazacolt
post Nov 28 2022, 12:29 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 28 2022, 11:36 AM)
Just curious, how come MYVi is not under your recommendation list? Vs Iriz.
*
I have absolutely zero interest in anything Perodua offer.

They move people, that's just about it. Anything to do with driving enjoyment is completely out the window

And all the driver assist (filling spec sheets) to me are mere gimmicks when even the basic braking systems leave a lot to be desired. (Very poor compared to their Proton counterparts)

Their newer DNGA based vehicles may be a lot better, however they are all huge SUV and MPV which again, zero interest.

This post has been edited by Quazacolt: Nov 28 2022, 12:29 PM
Quazacolt
post Nov 29 2022, 12:21 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 29 2022, 10:59 AM)
since my Honda is already 16 years old, even if I get city or vios now , it’s considered an Upgrade, let alone segment-c Altis!

Yeah I think I should look into the Hybrid options, which leave me with City, City Hatchback, HR-V & Cross only at the moment.

it’s a waste of money for me since I most likely just buy and leave it in the parking, cause I don’t drive much. And all the expenses will definitely increase with SUV. It would be a splurge car just for the sake of splurging money.
*
considering this ya:
QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 27 2022, 06:52 PM)
Cause hand itchy, so I’m just scouting around.
*
they aren't much of an upgrade
UMWT Altis is really short changed without dynamic force engine and there is simply a Civic sitting around that offers much better drive train and value as an all rounder car.

B segments, you're just side grading sitting at same segment just renewing/refreshing your current vehicle.
which isn't really needed considering your statements of:
1) the car is working fine no issues
2) you don't need a vehicle to show off
3) you seem calculative and/or financially sound

and that boggles me on why hybrid when it's NOT financially sound AT ALL.

now while i personally hate SUVs, i don't find your reasoning on SUV logical at all. because SUVs are much difference when it comes to expenses or maintenance. they aren't that much heavier than regular sedans, they don't exactly consume much more petrol than regular sedans. only maybe obvious difference when it comes to expenses and maintenance are tire and absorber replacements which, you don't exactly replace them every year either. considering your under utilization statement, you're probably only replacing the tires 4-6 years later, absorbers maybe never even until after you sell car since you're probably also not sensitive to ride & handling degradations.
Quazacolt
post Nov 29 2022, 02:38 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 29 2022, 01:51 PM)
Cause I like the sound. As in the car produces no noises. I mean there are, but it’s almost silent, unlike petrol cars. Hehe!

I’m careful with my finance planning, but once in a while I splurge too just for something I really like, as long as it’s within my capability.
*
that is fair enough and sheds a lot more light on your requirement.

considering this new information, you may want to avoid small b segment hybrids such as city hatch, and consider larger hybrids such as Civic eHEV.
or potentially all out EV that does away with ICE completely.

2023 Toyota Prius has been launched and you can also hope and wait for UMWT to bring in.
Quazacolt
post Nov 29 2022, 09:44 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(lee82gx @ Nov 29 2022, 06:33 PM)
Maybe I misinterpret your indecision on which model as considering an impulse purchase. My apologies. If you are so open and wide as to what models to consider then I suggest NOT to discount the x50. In my mind, 50k - myvi. 70k Yaris, 100k x50 for small size, Alza for big size, 130k Civic or Corolla or Corolla cross hybrid.
*
Hence my subtle message not to discount Proton Iriz lol

X50 on the other hand is a bit on the risky side and the long ass wait before you can even begin your ownership process.
I guess not to mention my general hatred to SUV doesn't do the X50 any favours.

Contemplated to get another spare car hence the Proton Iriz.

i was actually open to Perodua since wife and in law side favour Perodua so we went to test drive Myvi and Axia just to be sorely disappointed.
Went to try out the new 2022 Iriz and was pleasantly surprised on how the NVH and overall ride & handling even further improved.
Same sentiments applied to both myself and wife.
Quazacolt
post Nov 29 2022, 10:17 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(lee82gx @ Nov 29 2022, 09:55 PM)
Including the dreaded punch CVT?

I’m gonna be honest, if I had to go for IRIZ I’d rather listen to Bobby Ang, get a Saga and wait for the right financial situation to get a Civic lol.
I don’t wanna pay rm40-50k for a car I’m horribly not in love with looks wise. There I said it. I also do hate fugly cars , especially at the wrong price.
*
Yeap! Punch CVT was really good post Geely and every MC update it can still improve.

So good it makes the new Myvi CVT felt like punch CVT when it first released on Saga FLX many many years back.
Utter rubbish.

Well looks are subjective and to me it isn't a priority. That said, i think the Iriz looks much better than the Myvi. Maybe again with biases of how well the car drives from very first model (yes, even with pre Geely dreaded punch CVT Vs Myvi 4AT OF ANY generations) until the latest model. I heavily prioritize in a car ride and handling above anything else.
Quazacolt
post Nov 30 2022, 01:32 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Nov 30 2022, 10:16 AM)
If I have a Rm100k budget I will definitely not stick to Proton and Peroduo, considering the two Toyota and Honda are more reliable and probably last longer.
*
Actually, not really much more reliable.
And even if you replace a Proton engine, it'll still be cheaper than T&H counterpart

But yes, brand perception and if you think the additional 30-40k++ is worth it, then go for it!
For me, i definitely don't think you get 30-40k additional "worth"of car. So unless i go up c segment or other categories of vehicles (eg: actual sports cars), P1/P2 will always have an edge on pricing and value due to our NAP protecting them.
Quazacolt
post Dec 14 2022, 04:12 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(HalseyFrangipane @ Dec 14 2022, 03:46 PM)
I see a lot of people say Iriz/Proton's handling is superb, etc. But I really want to know out of genuine curiosity, is the handling really that good? And in comparison to what?
*
Yes really that good

In comparison to every competitor in B segment

Even C segment of old with the Suprima/Preve
However back then, punch CVT was indeed a very bad Achilles heel and people in prospects for the higher upmarket C market definitely cannot accept
Quazacolt
post Dec 14 2022, 11:05 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(HalseyFrangipane @ Dec 14 2022, 06:59 PM)
Dayum that's really interesting. I'd think of 208s, Minis, Swift when it comes to handling in B Segment. Gotta ask a colleague to let me test drive his Iriz then haha thanks for sharing
*
While mini is B , it is a sporty, if not outright considered a sports car/hot hatch which is definitely an unfair comparison.

Similarly 208 and swift, unless it's a 208 GTI /SSS , which are incorrect comparisons, the normal versions of these cars go toe to toe against the Iriz handling department, if not outright defeated. (Again, only in handling)

And if you factor in price, it gets even worse as you paying additional 50% car price (say, 60k > 90k) but you definitely do not get +50% handling.
Quazacolt
post Dec 14 2022, 11:17 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(minizian @ Dec 14 2022, 11:05 PM)
Found out that the preve was kitted out with full bars and braces onto the chassis from the factory.
The same type of chassis bars/braces that was sold aftermarket by Ultra Racing or Super Circuit.

Too bad iriz was not given the same treatment from the factory and I guess they had to compromise on certain handling aspect to keep the car at cost.
Iriz is one of the shittest performing in Proton in terms of sales. Even saga sold way more that this.
Wish proton just go all out with the car since it is low volume seller, by as well put more proper performance stuff and sell it at a markup.
*
Not aware of bars and braces from factory.
And personally if the chassis is good enough, it doesn't need any bars and braces (exception to the bare minimum anti roll bars are fitted to just about majority of modern day vehicles)
So to me I'm against chassis bars and braces, but that's another topic for another day.

And as for the Iriz, i think it's handling is good enough even without any additional chassis bars and braces.

It's shit sales is no thanks to the Myvi and it's own brothers the Saga/Persona.

I have no doubt as enthusiasts to have special models or even from R3. It's easy to blame Geely, however even before Geely R3 didn't do it, and Punch transmission had many shortcomings that could have been solved throughout the years since it was introduced for the first time.
Quazacolt
post Dec 14 2022, 11:19 PM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(HalseyFrangipane @ Dec 14 2022, 11:16 PM)
I see, thanks for the explanation. I think I get it now, and correct me if my understanding is wrong.

Iriz is good because the price to performance ratio in terms of handling alone is unbeatable compared to every competitor in the B segment (excluding sportier or higher end variants like Minis and 208 GTI, correct?
*
Yeap that is correct.

I think the only B segment that is close or better, is the Ford fiesta, and even that you need to ignore the price.

This post has been edited by Quazacolt: Dec 14 2022, 11:21 PM
Quazacolt
post Dec 15 2022, 08:32 AM

Riding couple
*******
Senior Member
5,369 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: KL Malaysia


QUOTE(miyakochan89 @ Dec 15 2022, 08:17 AM)
I’m actually seriously considering Toyota Cross Hybrid right now. Even though I mentioned that I don’t really want to have SUV.
*
Test drive both Toyota and Honda hybrid offerings.

They are mechanically very different

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0308sec    1.36    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 24th December 2025 - 02:31 PM