you dont know majority lose in Serbadk and sapura patuh syariah? gambling or what.. that up to them la. their money..

like BNM and SC can protect retail from operator and jerung?

if got ball open foreign broker la like Saxo or IKBR or IG market come here.

no ball because want to protect useless bursa broker right?

who want trade bursa? only operator and jerung will waiting for you.

i am also lose rm40k at Serbadk. even i post my unrealize loss here.

HOW YOU CAN GAMBLING WITH FOREX WITH 1:30 LEVERAGE WITH SAXO BANK?

WITH 0.01 LOT ALSO.

NOW TELL ME?

That is why bnm or sc come to protect people. We cannot afford all ppl to lose money. Maybe you are experience trader and can make profit out of it but the same not applied to everyone. In stock market, everyone have their own game, investment, dividend or trade its up to them. If you have strong technical analysis in forex then stock market is a child play for you.

Protect people with regulation. not with blanket ban. like bring oanda.. saxo bank Ikbr like that. so people will have chance to trade with reputable broker..

yes forex more easier than stock market. use low risk 0.01 with rm10k usd.even biden nuke by nuclear bomb also i can tank the currency spike.

currency = mean reversion.. it will coming back.

stock like serbadk and sapura patuh syariah = pukimak reversion .

Ban like this people will find the way to trade with bucket shop like octafx. then lose money blame who?

that bodo panel syariah just ignore. haram haram but living in fiat money. bodo.

Stock market? you mean Bursa? if Bursa only operator and jerung will waiting for you intraday..

want to trade global stock? well idiot SC still not allowed Saxo bank ikbr etc come here.. just to protect useless bursa broker . dont ask me about rakuten. i know. but that only good if you invest. try trading..fee will eat you for good.

From my understanding, first, edict/fatwa will be issued after muzakarah.

It will decide halal or haram in sharia. Not a law.

Then some will be gazetted by (in case of sharia) each state assembly. Then signed by ruler as patron of state religious council.
Turned into enactment/law.
Then only can enforced.

Most edicts/fatwa wont survive state assembly.

Rokok (smoking) is one of the example.

will anyone know if someone trade forex?

just do it bro, like smoking, rempit etc, all haram but people still do them, even going to pubs and drink alcohol also got people do, no got caught also

not easy. it like if oren kito. trading forex. like we do big crime.. even ur family also they said makan duit haram. .

because of this bodo panel syariah .. when so much haram in malaysia.. no ball. but forex trading have ball..

cannot "hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil"?

Because Malaysia bodo

When winning, its "investment". When losing, its "gambling"

Malaysia religion logic.