Was having a conversation with a friend who supports Manchester United (I'm a Liverpool supporter), and we got into the topic of Vidic vs Agger.

Both comparatively new to the English game and their respective clubs.

Both plays the same position.

Both doing effectively well on their own level.

Vidic is more of a no-nonsense tough tackling defender.

Agger is more of a technical and creative defender.

So, who is it going to be?

p/s I hope Manchester United and Liverpool fans will be able to participate in this conversation without biasness. It takes a bigger man to admit that a player from your rival team is indeed a better one, if he really is in your own opinion.

Have fun

This post has been edited by blinky: Sep 20 2007, 03:33 AM

Though I'm a Liverpool supporter, I have to say Vidic. One of the most solid defenders in EPL for the last season.

However, I can see that Agger has plenty of potential left to develop compared to Vidic.