Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 What genre is DotA in?, RTS or RPG?

views
     
TSTeckPeow
post Aug 31 2007, 05:09 PM, updated 19y ago

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
113 posts

Joined: Apr 2007
hey guys... so today i had an argument with my friend... he said DotA is RPG game because it involves character building. However, i believe DotA is a strategy game because it involves resource gathering and team works...

So, what is you guys opinion on what genre is DotA belong to? Strategy or RPG?

According to Wikipedia,

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Role-playing_game
Role-playing game, in which players assume the roles of characters and collaboratively create narratives

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real-time_strategy
In computer gaming, real-time strategy (often abbreviated as RTS) is a genre of wargames which take place in real time.

Serious discussion only please. notworthy.gif notworthy.gif
TSTeckPeow
post Sep 2 2007, 03:38 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
113 posts

Joined: Apr 2007
QUOTE(H@H@ @ Aug 31 2007, 11:14 PM)
Still think DotA's an RTS?
*
Actually there is no specified definition for RTS... 10 ppl can come out with 10 different definitions. I somehow disagree that a RTS must gather resources and control large number of armies.

QUOTE(befitozi @ Aug 31 2007, 10:35 PM)
You do not gather resources , you hunt for resources. This resembles all the RPG games like Maple , FF , where you control 1 or a few characters to hunt for that resource.
*
What game genre is Maple and FF? RPG?


TSTeckPeow
post Sep 2 2007, 07:29 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
113 posts

Joined: Apr 2007
QUOTE(befitozi @ Sep 2 2007, 03:58 AM)
Contradictions

You are indeed a legendary poster .... big LOL at you

guys , TS is the guy who said west ham is invovled in match fixing and thats why sheffield united not happy .... legendary strike backs lol
*
Go read this
http://sport.scotsman.com/football.cfm?id=1301382007

and this

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/main.jhtm...ufnsheff116.xml

it really happened last season but i didn't see any discussion in the football Lounge.

QUOTE(H@H@ @ Sep 2 2007, 04:32 AM)
Then why did you quote Wikipedia then when they're definition is totally different from yours? Actually, why even have this thread if everyone is going to have their own definitions?

Hell, let's just throw away with "genres" since no one can agree on what a genre really is. Let's just keep the descriptions as detailed as possible so no one could possibly misunderstand what a game is.

So, when Starcraft 2 comes out, it'll be something like this:
Genres are there for a reason. If genres are solely based on individuals perceptions, technically speaking, ANY game could be in any genre.
Observe:
DotA
- First Person Shooter:- I mean, first person doesn't necessarily mean first person view right? I'm still controlling the character in the first person; I'm not using anyone to control them. Plus, you can shoot shit in DotA so therefore its an FPS.

- Racing :- A race is generally a contest to get to one objective faster than your competitor. Since in DotA, you have to race against your opponent to destroy their tree/throne, therefore DotA is a racing game.

- Flight Simulator :- Do the dragons in DotA not simulate flying in the game? Flight sim it is!

- Football :- Football involves two teams on opposing ends trying to score a goal in the opposition corner. Now, a goal is also known as an objective and since the objective of DotA is to destroy the the Tree/Throne at the opposition corner, therefore DotA is a football game (Come to think of it, this definition could also include Battlefield and a slew of team based MP games)

- MMORPG :- Massively Multiplayer Online Role Playing Game.
Massive : To me, massive is having more than 5 players Check
Multiplayer: Needs more than one player to play Check
Online: Can be played on B.Net Check
Role-Playing: You have a role in the game... As a hero to defeat the enemy Check
Game: Its fun Check
Conclusion: DotA = MMORPG

... and I could go on and on and I can do this for pretty much EVERY game out there. Doesn't matter that some of these definitions are full of shit right? I mean, according to you EVERYONE's definition is correct no matter how retarded or stupid they are aren't they?
If you really want to argue your point on whether DotA is an RTS or not, use proper points and not immediately dismiss the general consensus. That just makes you look like an arrogant bugger trying to piss ppl off.

The bigger question remains though; Are you intentionally doing this to rile up the RTS gamers in this forum? I know how they sort of mocked you silly in the Starcraft 2 thread and nothing irks an RTS gamer more than DotA (They're eternal enemy) being considered to be an RTS.
*
FPS, Racing, Flight Simulator, Football(what?) are definately out. There are plenty of strategy games that do not require you to build buildings and train armies.

Sacrifice - strategy game but no need to build buildings... just steal enemy souls..
http://www.gamespot.com/pc/strategy/sacrif...=result;title;0

Caesar IV - strategy game but no need to gather resources
http://www.gamespot.com/pc/strategy/caesar4/index.html

RollerCoaster Tycoon - no harvest no battle but building (yes)
http://www.gamespot.com/pc/strategy/roller...coon/index.html

SimCity 4 - no harvest no destroy... just build
http://www.gamespot.com/pc/strategy/simcity4/index.html

Wikipedia mentions that ("harvest, build, destroy") are key components for strategy game yet the games i listed above do not have all the strategy game characteristics yet. You see they are still listed as "other strategy games" at gamespot. If you click on the "other strategy games" you will find the games listed above.

http://www.gamespot.com/games.html?type=ga...owse;category;6

The definition is not always right.
TSTeckPeow
post Sep 10 2007, 05:07 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
113 posts

Joined: Apr 2007
Cheesenium, you are the most biased ppl i've ever seen. Go play Mario and never come back to this forum again.

78 hours spent on Dawn of War. you seriously need to get a life.

Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0435sec    0.55    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 28th November 2025 - 04:23 AM