Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Astrum Ampang Jelatek

views
     
Chady
post Apr 23 2024, 06:25 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
373 posts

Joined: Oct 2021
When u buy a property, always think of the exit strategy.

Can u sell this property eventually while competing with other 5,000 units?

Idaman Kwasa Damansara is a better option for family stay as the size is bigger and it’s freehold. Astrum only for long term rental (12 months) or airbnb.

I doubt u want to raise a family in Astrum.

Always buy something u will foresee yourself in the next few years … ie getting married or having kids etc.

QUOTE(x3Kai @ Apr 23 2024, 06:10 PM)
Hey guys, I got offered a unit from PR1MA, 450 sq ft + 1 carpark. I did my homework and visited the area last month and felt pretty good about it as I initially plan on buying it for own stay. But while waiting for bank loans, I managed to calm down and relook at this project and listed down some of the cons of the project, wanted some second opinion about those.

First up is the LRT, I see people complaining about Jelatek station being difficult to board as it is already full by the time it reaches Setiawangsa, can anyone confirm this? Would be awkward if I have to wait an hour to board the bloody LRT.

Another thing is there’s some history about riots as Datum Jelatek was built on land that previously housed PKNS low-cost flats. The developer bought the land under market value on top of locals being worried about influx of Chinese buyers. But this happened like 2 decades ago, do you think there’s still resentment in the area?

Lastly, the density of this project, 5000+ units. Thoughts on how this will affect the rental market and property value? M Vertica and RC doesn’t seem to be doing too bad right now, maybe there’s hope for this project too?

I’m just worried that I’ll be out of KL by the time the project completes, and got no choice but to rent out (PR1MA holding period is 5 years, but grey market maybe?) So I looked into an alternative, a Rumah Idaman in Kwasa Damansara, 1000 sq ft for the same price but downside is that the completion is like 2 years ++ after Astrum. MRT is within walkable distance, unlikely to have covered walkway, but the commute is around 1 hour to city centre.
*
chuanyou
post Apr 23 2024, 10:11 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
40 posts

Joined: Jan 2023
QUOTE(x3Kai @ Apr 23 2024, 06:10 PM)
Hey guys, I got offered a unit from PR1MA, 450 sq ft + 1 carpark. I did my homework and visited the area last month and felt pretty good about it as I initially plan on buying it for own stay. But while waiting for bank loans, I managed to calm down and relook at this project and listed down some of the cons of the project, wanted some second opinion about those.

First up is the LRT, I see people complaining about Jelatek station being difficult to board as it is already full by the time it reaches Setiawangsa, can anyone confirm this? Would be awkward if I have to wait an hour to board the bloody LRT.

Another thing is there’s some history about riots as Datum Jelatek was built on land that previously housed PKNS low-cost flats. The developer bought the land under market value on top of locals being worried about influx of Chinese buyers. But this happened like 2 decades ago, do you think there’s still resentment in the area?

Lastly, the density of this project, 5000+ units. Thoughts on how this will affect the rental market and property value? M Vertica and RC doesn’t seem to be doing too bad right now, maybe there’s hope for this project too?

I’m just worried that I’ll be out of KL by the time the project completes, and got no choice but to rent out (PR1MA holding period is 5 years, but grey market maybe?) So I looked into an alternative, a Rumah Idaman in Kwasa Damansara, 1000 sq ft for the same price but downside is that the completion is like 2 years ++ after Astrum. MRT is within walkable distance, unlikely to have covered walkway, but the commute is around 1 hour to city centre.
*
This post has been edited by chuanyou: Apr 28 2024, 12:45 AM
15cm
post Nov 3 2024, 01:45 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
422 posts

Joined: Apr 2022
setia awan, anyone knows the reputation of this developer?
gashout
post Nov 3 2024, 05:01 AM

⭐ My stars are growing ⭐
*******
Senior Member
5,741 posts

Joined: Apr 2019
QUOTE(Chady @ Apr 23 2024, 06:25 PM)
When u buy a property, always think of the exit strategy.

Can u sell this property eventually while competing with other 5,000 units?

Idaman Kwasa Damansara is a better option for family stay as the size is bigger and it’s freehold. Astrum only for long term rental (12 months) or airbnb.

I doubt u want to raise a family in Astrum.

Always buy something u will foresee yourself in the next few years … ie getting married or having kids etc.
*
kwasa damansara is good if you live around there. as they are the last station, try see how far it travels.

if you live in the city, best stay in the city, but true too, that space, how do you have a family.

it's a mater of distance and size, where most property concerns are.
warrenbuffett
post Dec 24 2024, 10:43 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
567 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


QUOTE(x3Kai @ Apr 23 2024, 06:10 PM)
Hey guys, I got offered a unit from PR1MA, 450 sq ft + 1 carpark. I did my homework and visited the area last month and felt pretty good about it as I initially plan on buying it for own stay. But while waiting for bank loans, I managed to calm down and relook at this project and listed down some of the cons of the project, wanted some second opinion about those.

First up is the LRT, I see people complaining about Jelatek station being difficult to board as it is already full by the time it reaches Setiawangsa, can anyone confirm this? Would be awkward if I have to wait an hour to board the bloody LRT.

Another thing is there’s some history about riots as Datum Jelatek was built on land that previously housed PKNS low-cost flats. The developer bought the land under market value on top of locals being worried about influx of Chinese buyers. But this happened like 2 decades ago, do you think there’s still resentment in the area?

Lastly, the density of this project, 5000+ units. Thoughts on how this will affect the rental market and property value? M Vertica and RC doesn’t seem to be doing too bad right now, maybe there’s hope for this project too?

I’m just worried that I’ll be out of KL by the time the project completes, and got no choice but to rent out (PR1MA holding period is 5 years, but grey market maybe?) So I looked into an alternative, a Rumah Idaman in Kwasa Damansara, 1000 sq ft for the same price but downside is that the completion is like 2 years ++ after Astrum. MRT is within walkable distance, unlikely to have covered walkway, but the commute is around 1 hour to city centre.
*
so, you bought it? happy ?
warrenbuffett
post Dec 24 2024, 10:44 AM

On my way
****
Junior Member
567 posts

Joined: Apr 2017


QUOTE(15cm @ Nov 3 2024, 01:45 AM)
setia awan, anyone knows the reputation of this developer?
*
the sale person told me the reputation is very good. best developer.
gashout
post Dec 25 2024, 07:01 AM

⭐ My stars are growing ⭐
*******
Senior Member
5,741 posts

Joined: Apr 2019
QUOTE(warrenbuffett @ Dec 24 2024, 10:44 AM)
the sale person told me the reputation is very good. best developer.
*
Sales person need commission.

You and your 30 year loan is none of their business after you've signed
ds732
post Dec 25 2024, 09:33 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
146 posts

Joined: Jul 2013


QUOTE(warrenbuffett @ Dec 24 2024, 10:44 AM)
the sale person told me the reputation is very good. best developer.
*
the sales person are usually trained to sell oil to arabs and a plot of land on mars to elon musk.

get real, the sales person are there to sell and thats all they care. they will tell you all the things you want to hear and the reality starts after inking the documents.

Azri_ryuji48
post Jun 16 2025, 04:44 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
10 posts

Joined: Sep 2012


hi, anybody here received offer for prima unit? anyone take the offer?

x3Kai
post Jul 17 2025, 06:10 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
285 posts

Joined: Jun 2012
From: Kuala Lumpur


Forgot to update after buying.

QUOTE(Chady @ Apr 23 2024, 06:25 PM)
When u buy a property, always think of the exit strategy.

Can u sell this property eventually while competing with other 5,000 units?

Idaman Kwasa Damansara is a better option for family stay as the size is bigger and it’s freehold. Astrum only for long term rental (12 months) or airbnb.

I doubt u want to raise a family in Astrum.

Always buy something u will foresee yourself in the next few years … ie getting married or having kids etc.
*
This is some pretty good insight here, knowing your exit. Based on what I researched after that, I think this is likely a hold until you die property. Cuz from what I've researched, appreciation is pretty much non-existent for units designated as “affordable” housing.

Because to even sell, you seem to require approval from LPHS, where they will probably try to cap the selling price to keep the unit “affordable”. However, I do know people who bought and sold affordable housing previously to the open market and got away with it. But that’s under an older affordable housing scheme, so it’s hard to tell what law applies.

If anyone sold their affordable housing unit (RSKU, Idaman, PR1MA, Rumah WIP, etc.) recently, would appreciate some insight on how the selling process is and whether LPHS impose any price restrictions.

For me, I don’t really foresee myself building a family anytime soon, still forever single, so no issues there. Just treat this as building equity and turning it into a source of passive income.


QUOTE(gashout @ Nov 3 2024, 05:01 AM)
kwasa damansara is good if you live around there. as they are the last station, try see how far it travels.

if you live in the city, best stay in the city, but true too, that space, how do you have a family.

it's a mater of distance and size, where most property concerns are.
*
I went over to check out Kwasa showroom and the surrounding area last year, and the MRT station wasn’t as close as I imagined it to be. I estimate it’s at least a 10-minute walk plus no guaranteed covered walkway, hence I went with Astrum instead.


QUOTE(warrenbuffett @ Dec 24 2024, 10:43 AM)
so, you bought it? happy ?
*
Bought, can’t tell if I’m happy until the unit VP. It’s a roller coaster ride, last year progress was rapid, but then since the beginning of this year till now, looks like nothing much was done.

When I bought, they estimated Q2 2027 completion. I bought thinking that since it launched during MCO, surely, they would like to avoid paying LAD and finish it earlier and the developer staff told me if all goes well, Q4 2026 will be done. But recently I asked the staff from collection, they say it’s more likely completion in Q4 2027.

Then there’s also rumours saying the linked bridge won’t be built since there’s no signs of construction for that, instead it’ll be just a covered walkway.

Chady
post Jul 17 2025, 08:22 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
373 posts

Joined: Oct 2021
QUOTE(x3Kai @ Jul 17 2025, 06:10 PM)
Forgot to update after buying.
This is some pretty good insight here, knowing your exit. Based on what I researched after that, I think this is likely a hold until you die property. Cuz from what I've researched, appreciation is pretty much non-existent for units designated as “affordable” housing.

Because to even sell, you seem to require approval from LPHS, where they will probably try to cap the selling price to keep the unit “affordable”. However, I do know people who bought and sold affordable housing previously to the open market and got away with it. But that’s under an older affordable housing scheme, so it’s hard to tell what law applies.

If anyone sold their affordable housing unit (RSKU, Idaman, PR1MA, Rumah WIP, etc.) recently, would appreciate some insight on how the selling process is and whether LPHS impose any price restrictions.

For me, I don’t really foresee myself building a family anytime soon, still forever single, so no issues there. Just treat this as building equity and turning it into a source of passive income. 
I went over to check out Kwasa showroom and the surrounding area last year, and the MRT station wasn’t as close as I imagined it to be. I estimate it’s at least a 10-minute walk plus no guaranteed covered walkway, hence I went with Astrum instead.
Bought, can’t tell if I’m happy until the unit VP. It’s a roller coaster ride, last year progress was rapid, but then since the beginning of this year till now, looks like nothing much was done.

When I bought, they estimated Q2 2027 completion. I bought thinking that since it launched during MCO, surely, they would like to avoid paying LAD and finish it earlier and the developer staff told me if all goes well, Q4 2026 will be done. But recently I asked the staff from collection, they say it’s more likely completion in Q4 2027.

Then there’s also rumours saying the linked bridge won’t be built since there’s no signs of construction for that, instead it’ll be just a covered walkway.
*
If you haven't bought, I want to recommend you SAMM (550sq ft for RM250k) at the Lines, Mutiara Damansara. But since you have bought it, congrats on your purchase!
gashout
post Jul 18 2025, 07:49 AM

⭐ My stars are growing ⭐
*******
Senior Member
5,741 posts

Joined: Apr 2019
QUOTE(x3Kai @ Jul 17 2025, 06:10 PM)
Forgot to update after buying.
This is some pretty good insight here, knowing your exit. Based on what I researched after that, I think this is likely a hold until you die property. Cuz from what I've researched, appreciation is pretty much non-existent for units designated as “affordable” housing.

Because to even sell, you seem to require approval from LPHS, where they will probably try to cap the selling price to keep the unit “affordable”. However, I do know people who bought and sold affordable housing previously to the open market and got away with it. But that’s under an older affordable housing scheme, so it’s hard to tell what law applies.

If anyone sold their affordable housing unit (RSKU, Idaman, PR1MA, Rumah WIP, etc.) recently, would appreciate some insight on how the selling process is and whether LPHS impose any price restrictions.

For me, I don’t really foresee myself building a family anytime soon, still forever single, so no issues there. Just treat this as building equity and turning it into a source of passive income. 
I went over to check out Kwasa showroom and the surrounding area last year, and the MRT station wasn’t as close as I imagined it to be. I estimate it’s at least a 10-minute walk plus no guaranteed covered walkway, hence I went with Astrum instead.
Bought, can’t tell if I’m happy until the unit VP. It’s a roller coaster ride, last year progress was rapid, but then since the beginning of this year till now, looks like nothing much was done.

When I bought, they estimated Q2 2027 completion. I bought thinking that since it launched during MCO, surely, they would like to avoid paying LAD and finish it earlier and the developer staff told me if all goes well, Q4 2026 will be done. But recently I asked the staff from collection, they say it’s more likely completion in Q4 2027.

Then there’s also rumours saying the linked bridge won’t be built since there’s no signs of construction for that, instead it’ll be just a covered walkway.
*
congrats! remember to save some money for renovation and make sure to do your best to clear your loan asap...

All the best smile.gif
x3Kai
post Jul 18 2025, 09:52 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
285 posts

Joined: Jun 2012
From: Kuala Lumpur


QUOTE(Chady @ Jul 17 2025, 08:22 PM)
If you haven't bought, I want to recommend you SAMM (550sq ft for RM250k) at the Lines, Mutiara Damansara. But since you have bought it, congrats on your purchase!
*
Looks like an interesting project, will check it out and see if I'm still eligible hahaha
Azamat_Bagatov
post Jul 26 2025, 10:43 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
121 posts

Joined: Jul 2025
when will vp? seems like has been selling for long time

12 Pages « < 10 11 12Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0168sec    0.84    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 16th December 2025 - 11:36 AM