oh come on, they only fight for a movie not for real.. why u guys bother about who will win anyway... depend on the script lah who gonna win...

Jackie Chan, because he does all the dangerous stunts by himself. Look at his movies (& bloopers) during his peak.

I like Jet Li for style points. Always a pleasure to see him do his marital arts moves.

lawl.....

This post has been edited by figure8: Aug 25 2007, 10:26 PM

I'd say Jackie Chan. Here's the deal. Jet Li knows real Kung Fu. Jackie Chan knows to escape and use infinite number of objects against his opponents. As Jet Li trashes Jackie Chan, Jackie picks up a lethal object and throws/kicks/does whatever to it at Jet Li with precision. Jet Li is down and out.

Got a point there.

People tend to forget that after Bruce Lee died, Hong Kong film industry wants Jackie Chan to be the next big thing.
But he failed...because no one can replace Bruce Lee as a tough martial arts actor...the "wataaa!!!" thing.

So, Jackie try a different approach...comedy and action = success.

Jet Li - Started as a martial arts (wanna be good, started when you're 5 years old at least)
Jackie Chan - started in an acting school (martial arts, acrobatic etc.) together with Sammo Hung and Yuen Biao.

Me more of a Jackie Chan fan

Jet Li vs Donnie Yen is more interesting. Jackie Chan don't kill ppl.

WRONG!

Jet Li VS Tony Jaa would be a more interesting choice. that guy can kill using his balls! just like in Tom Yoong Goong. jackie is an old fart who makes a fool of himself in Rush Hour. i cant forgive him for making Asians look dumb..

7 years down the road and his english is still crappy......at least jet li speaks better english

finally someone has the same opinion

Tony Jaa is waaaay too small to be compare to how much epic Jackie and Jet are today (just my opinion).

Which is why I made the legendary comparison that:

Jackie Chan vs Jet Li = Asian version of Sly vs Arnold

Oh uh...I flaming detected

I enjoy both of their movies.

BTW, Donnie Yen is a cool martial artist....good looking and tough.






This post has been edited by Raikkonen: Aug 26 2007, 06:13 PM

sly vs arnold? exactly why this movie wont work. they are both aging. at least jet is still 44. jackie i think is over 50. can u imagine Sly and Ahnold making a movie together these days? it would be like watching Macho Man vs Roddy Piper. slow n dull.

the interesting part of this movie is how they would fit the style of both actor in one film. jackie likes Buster Keaton-esque action sequence while Jet is more intense and serious. it would be an interesting combination and experiment

I still think Tony Jaa can pwnd Jackie.

isk isk isk...
i cant choose at all! both are my heroes...
i will be in the primier of the movie for sure!

it just a movie

both of them uses real martial art, both great actor as well. jet li more on action movies while jackie chan attracts with comedy. ppl tend to said that jackie's martial art is not real, maybe because of he combines it with some funny tricks while fighting. hollywood, attraction is the main thing.

anyway, hands down to both of them

jet li all the way~~ he's better looking hahaha

Jet Li has real martial arts but i prefer Jackie Chan 4 his fighting & comedies movies.. nv seen Jet Li in comedies movie..

no point comparing...both from different era

anyway, The Forbidden Kingdom is not martial arts/action oriented movie....its more like a Disney-like fantasy plot targeted to family/kids.

dont put high expeectations...

Thing is, that shit is all choreographed.

i support Jet Li

Forbidden kingdom press conference report

The trailer is up..have your say

Trailer

This post has been edited by memento: Dec 31 2007, 10:24 AM

YouTube Version