Hi all

just wanted to make a comprehensive review on M1 MBP 16/512 from a
student perspective after a month of full use. Short info of me, I’m a final year EE engineering undergrad that uses basic office suite, several programming softwares, light graphic design/video editing and also extensive use of electrical engineering related softwares. Previously, I used 13” 2015 MBP 8/256 with current M1 MBP runs mostly as desktop with clamshell mode and moderate portable use.
Click to open lengthy pros/cons >>
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
Pros :
- It runs extremely smooth with literally EVERYTHING thrown at it, and nope no exaggerating added.
- Heaviest portable multitasking I’ve ever done was opening 2 Word docs, 3 Excels, 3 PPTs, 5 large PDFs, 6 tabs Safari (with 2 of them are Youtube), 2 tabs Chrome, 3 complex SketchUp drawing, MATLAB with 7 graph Figures, WhatsApp, Notes and all while sharing my screen using MSTeams for 2.5 hours (All were spread evenly across 6 desktops). The M1 didn’t even flinched and everything loaded up quickly even when switching back and forth vigorously (coz my crazy lecturer wanted to see all the files).
- Battery life with heavy multitasking as above was okay, it dropped 35% while using it for 2.5 hours with 50% brightness (also partially due to USB-C hub connected). Battery life with basic usage was excellent and on-par with Apple’s claim.
- Programming stuffs like AnacondaNav, Visual Code, PyCharm IDE, OpenCV 3.4.2/4.5.1 and TensorFlow 2.0/2.4 are able to run on M1 chips (older versions via Rosetta, latest version with native support).
- MATLAB r2020b, AutoDesk EAGLE and System Advisor Model (SAM) 2020 runs fairly smooth too (via Rosetta)
- Lastly, it didn’t get warm as much as on 2015 MBP even at its heaviest multitasking. It was smartphone-like warm and the fan kicked in moderately. At most times, it was cool to touch with 0 fan use.
Cons :
- I’ve had 1 kernel panic when completing my FYP report and luckily I saved the doc 5 minutes before the panic happened. Not much writing lost. But its still a lost :’)
- Memory Swapping use is okay-ish. At max multitasking, it was as high as 3GB and the lowest to be a constant 50-200MB. (Do take note this is 16GB RAM variant)
- Microsoft Office Suite runs natively on M1 but more complex macros on Excel forces it to run via Rosetta. Quite the risk if it suddenly crashes by itself.
- No Bootcamp. Most EE software are x86 W10 based anyway, so better off having a separate Windows machines altogether.
- macOS-supported EE softwares runs only via Rosetta, hence there are still rare instances of MATLAB crashing or EAGLE software just froze altogether.
- Fan doesn’t kick up as often (no official Macs Fan Control app available yet), hence when exporting/converting long videos it does get hot and thats not good for the battery especially for us living in hot and humid beloved Malaysia :’D

Overall experience was smooth and pleasant. However there are some rare app crashes/kernel panic. Multitasking and battery life is excellent and a serious upgrade from previous-gen MBPs. App support for M1 chips are generally good but more EE-niche softwares tend to run not as consistent as on W10 machines.
TLDR; An extremely good buy for heavy multitasking use and portability especially for homebound final year undergrad students with 3 major projects and 10 assignments due