Wow, thanks for the long reply and clearing up my doubts. I did not know that there was so much information that i need to know even for an upscaler. OK, from ur explanation below, i guess it is advisable to get an AVR and DVD player that has an upscaling capability. As for my AVR i'm alraedy intereted to get an Onkyo 606 or 706 which has the capability.
However for the DVD player, how much will an Oppo player cost? Last week when i was searching around for some players, the sales man told me that just get a Toshiba or Pionner DVD player will be good enough as it has upscaling capability. Not sure how true is that.
And my last question would be, if i use an AVR which has upscaling but a China made DVD player, will there be any improvement?
Thanks
QUOTE(anfieldude @ Apr 29 2009, 12:06 PM)
1st question, I am not the best person for this, since I am in Penang! Check with htkaki and maybe he can help you.
Good question. The quality of the the upscaler and deinterlacer in a AVR vs a DVD player is always asked. This really depends on the quality of the chip that they use inside. The well known upscale chips are HQV Reon, HQV Realta, Anchor Bay VRS, Faroudja DCDI, Mediatek 1389. Of these I believe the HQV ones and the Anchor Bay is one of the best. If u r a person who views a lot of DVDs then I would advise you to get an AVR or a DVD player that has this. The AVRs that use HQV chips are the Onkyo 876, 875 (there are some problems with the implementation of the Reon here), 906. Denon 5series I believe uses Realta. DVD players, I guess only Oppo uses Anchor Bay. Will u see a difference, yes if you look. If you are not a fussy person, the Faroudja should be more than enough. Remember that all HDTV have scalar and deinterlacing chips as well. The chips that reside in the Pioneer, Sony and higher end Samsungs will most probably be better that the Faroudja and Mediatek solutions.
Do not expect miracles from these chips. It all depends on the source. If your source is badly mastered DVD (pirated), of course the higher quality chips will do a better job.
The choice of getting a high end DVD player or a AVR with high end chip or leaving the job to the display to do the job is something that you must since you are the one watching the movies.
In my opinion, the Reon is a pretty good upscaler. I have not seen a Faroudja (7xx and 6xx shd be using this) in action in detail. Comparing the Mediatek 1389 (found in Pioneer DVDs players) with the Reon, there are clear differences in my eyes that the Reon is better. The toss up between the quality of the Reon and the in built scalar/deinterlacer in a Pioneer Plasma is very close. Both have its pros and cons.
If you want something better, get the Oppo DVD player or better yet the upcoming Oppo Blu Ray player.
I know it sounds confusing but it is not. Buy whatever soothes your eyes and your pocket.