Hi Fellow Gurus,
I am an absolute newbie in IBKR
I am a StashAway Investor, and adding IBKR into my portfolio to directly purchase some ETFs
Just want to get my numbers right.
Currently, StashAway has a 0.8%p.a charge , with 0.2% ETF expense ratio p.a. and a one-time 0.1% currrency conversion.
https://www.stashaway.my/pricingLet's use RM5000 Buy and Hold for 5years as an example,
StashAwayRM5000 x (0.8% + 0.2% + 0.1%) = RM50/per annum + RM5 conversion fee
5 years (RM55 1st year + (RM 50 x 4years) ) = RM255 in fees
IBKR + TSG
The flow : MYR Bank > Instarem > SGD in IBKR > USD in IBKR > Purchase ETF in IBKR
Instarem transfer : RM 5000 > SGD : Fees Roughly RM25
SGD.USD Pair in IBKR : Exchange Fees USD2 ~ RM8.50
Buy ETF Fees : USD 1.5 ~ RM6.5
Total Fees : RM40
5 Years (RM 40 1st Year + (RM0 x4 year) ) = RM 40
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Above scenario has not considered withdrawals, but for simplicity sake, I would just take the same RM40 fees in IBKR example.
My other variable is :
Stashaway : Converts MYR to USD directly , den reverse when withdraw
IBKR : Convertys MYR to SGD + SGD to USD , den reverse when withdraw
Summary,
short of the conversion rate risks, IBKR is the clear winner in terms of fees. Or am i missing something ?
Feel free to copy paste the calculation and fix it accordingly.
I will still remain invested in StashAway, but also exploring other options.
Any input is welcome
Thanks guys

You should be more concerned about the asset return rather than the fees.
In other words, whether Stashaway can give you higher % per year or the ETF you choose can give higher % per year.
Then, calculate the return on a net basis (return - fees). Express it as a %.
I don't use Stashaway but their portfolio is definitely different from the ETF you buy at IBKR.
They probably mix a few ETFs together with bonds. Meanwhile, you're buying just 1 ETF.