QUOTE(Volkswagen2 @ Aug 26 2018, 09:12 AM)
The problem with relying on links or an article from the internet too much is sometimes people who don't have the knowledge or experience place too much trust in them and regard them as the truth although they don't apply or compare, and the person does not consider the true or real factors. If you have lived in overseas you would notice that summer time in Europe especially in the UK cannot be considered as the same wheather in a Malaysia. I'm not sure how your friends came to the conclusion that the higher floors are hotter than lower floors and I will not assume on their part as there can be few possibilities. But as I have mentioned earlier, with the same conditions of sun exposure and surroundings ie. same area of a town between landed property and 20 or 30+ floors of an apartment, the high floors will always be cooler than the low floors due to the reasons as mentioned in my earlier post which I shall not repeat. It is the elevation that will make a difference, the higher it is the more significant.
A real life example of having winter in Malaysia with high elevation is Genting Highlands but you will need a lot of it.
Well like i said, I've not lived in a high rise and definitely have not experience living in >20floor apart from being in the office which is fully air conditioned all the time so I can't comment based on experience. However, common sense tells me that higher floor would absorb heat more than those from the lower floor. As quoted and backed by hong kong experts as wellA real life example of having winter in Malaysia with high elevation is Genting Highlands but you will need a lot of it.
QUOTE
Dr. William Yu, CEO of the World Green Organisation explains that rooftops exposed under the Sun, absorb heat throughout the morning, and subsequently release heat at dusk – explaining why the rooftops floors are hotter than ever.
Bare in mind that Hong Kong is a sub-tropical country, which is the closest you can get in terms of climate in comparison to living in highly dense tropical city like KL.
You do realize Genting Highlands is on the hill and it perched on the peak of Mount Ulu Kali at 1,800 meters high right? On top of that it is not highly dense and does not factor in gas emission living in city like KL/Subang/PJ/MK/BJ and the likes right? I do not even think that it is sensible to bring in a highland as an example against a grounded and densely populated city.
Like I said, I could be wrong since I've not lived in both high floor and lower floor but I do like to know where you get your reasoning from. Have you lived in both 30> floor and 20< floor in your life to substantiate such reasoning from experience or are you saying it because you think it works that way?
Anyway, great debate and I applaud you on at least giving your reasoning compared to some other people in the forum who would just say "HIGH FLOOR IS COOLER, BELIEVE ME - END OF STORY", would be better if you could post sources or research to back your claim up or even better use a pyrometer and measure both high floor and low floor if you actually live in a high rise to prove your point. I do know about the concept of elevation but from my point of view and what I found from the net, the effects is more towards highlands rather than highrise (need more evidence though). Of course I'm not saying you should do it but for now, your reasoning is without facts and I believe that the sources I found at least presented my argument credibility than just reasoning without any credible support.
This post has been edited by holypredator: Aug 26 2018, 12:31 PM
Aug 26 2018, 12:28 PM

Quote
0.0188sec
0.68
6 queries
GZIP Disabled