Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 FI/RE - Financial Independence / Retire Early, Share your experience

views
     
sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 10:25 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Timberwolf83 @ Sep 12 2018, 10:10 AM)
I'm thinking of taking out rm150k to invest, seeking 2-3% monthly returns ( I don't know, if it is plausible to find a investment that have a stable returns of 2-3% on a monthly basis).
This will boost up my savings to 50-55% from 29%.

Any advise?
*
Perhaps your question should post here.... more relevant.. https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/4381936/+520

Btw, if you looking for stable return 2-3% on monthly == 24-36% yearly, let me know if you found one rclxs0.gif devil.gif
sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 11:56 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
Showtime747

What's your defination on RE. "Makan, tidur dan main" only once step out from primary job, or one opt out from his profession on other side gig, or take on fulltime/partime non profit charity work, other?

I sense there are gaps on "jobs" == "way to be productive member and benefit society"

Btw, we all had to thank to someone "RE" from his primary job as early as 42 way back at 18th century, and still doing a enormous contribution to the world. smile.gif
https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2018/01/ben...and-reinvention

Another point probably good to contemplate about is official retirement age is vary among country. Is such yeardstick really sound to every single ppl within that country? Or, isn't it sound a bit like personal inflation and country wide CPI inflation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retirement_age

Edit: fix the link

This post has been edited by sky18: Sep 12 2018, 12:07 PM
sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 06:07 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 04:14 PM)
According to my hypothesis,

1. The person who does not contribute to the production of GDP, and become a net consumer of scarce resources of the society

2. The person who does not contribute to tax revenue of the country

3. The person who does not contribute to science progression / production efficiency by passing down his acquired knowledge from previous education and professional experience

4. In addition to that, I would go on to expand on the above 3 criteria to include the person contribute lesser to the production of GDP than before RE, pay lesser tax than before RE and contribute lesser to science progression/production efficiency than before RE

It is not only "makan, tidur dan main"
For Benjamin Franklin, the "retirement at age 42" actually refers to "retirement from his printing business". In today's business term, we would say "exit from printing business and embark on another career". For the next 40 years, he went on to contribute to the field of science and invention, made remarkable contribution to his country for many important role/jobs, and eventually earned his picture on the US$100 bill. A great man in USA history

Should he really have the mindset of RE, the history would have lost such an important figure, and the history would be different.

For the young readers who have the mindset of RE, Benjamin Franklin is yet another example after Jack Ma that you could make great contribution to the society/country if you are not selfish
*
IMHO, selfishness is dependent on the reason for retiring and what one retiring to. RE is neutral and the retirement age is just a relative figure. For example, mr money mustache who RE in early 30+, he managed to inspire many ppl start FI journey and many of them in better financial position today. He actually make more impact and good for society in general compared to stick in 9-5 office job. Isn't it such opputunity occur due to his RE?

Criteria 4 sound odd to me, my interpretation is prior RE, one is contribute tax via both active + passive income, once letting go active income, taxable income definately lesser. Thus, for those who forey into other fields that his/her passionated with much lesser / without additional income, or fulltime charity work, I dont see these group of ppl should marked as selfish.

Again, isn't it Benjamin Franklin retired on his printing (primary job) and working on his own passion at 42. If he failed, he probably just a normal early retiree. If we see from another perspective, isn't it RE is actually a positive move where create opputunity for one maximize their potential? For sure, when he attempt forey into his scientific research, he meet your criteria 4. tongue.gif
The same Benjamin Franklin story, it can have different interpretion is view from another angle.

Probably you could see more interesting discussion from here too... https://www.financialsamurai.com/the-dark-s...-risks-dangers/

sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 09:06 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:26 PM)
Yes, Mr Money Mustache maybe made more impact after he retired, and he maybe earns more after he retired than his old 9-5 job  biggrin.gif
He is actually using his new "title" (retired and successful) to make more money. Very clever guy !

*
Yup. He smart and make ton of money via his blog. Like it or not, it's a something not anticipated during he opt for RE.
Isn't it sometime letting go is open up a new opportunity.

QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:26 PM)
Again, selfish as defined in my hypothesis. They could have contributed more to the economy/society/countries should they decided not to RE. As stated in the hypothesis, if enough people RE, the economy would collapse

Many here do not agree with the hypothesis though.
*
LOL. As I always believe, there is absolute black and white; we can't simply mark RE as selfish act without looking at other context. And to me, it's just neutral anywhere and it might open up a new door / opportunity for better.

Btw, if we talk about "what if" enough ppl RE, our discussion will never end. tongue.gif devil.gif

As I stated early, it ain't going to happened as mentioned in earlier post.

QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 06:26 PM)
I don't see Benjamin Franklin as "retiring" at all. He moved on after selling his printing business and eventually his achievement is huge

Maybe I only see the history. If we talk about "what if", our discussion will never end.

So, I stick to history, so happen the history supports my hypothesis
*
sky18
post Sep 12 2018, 10:52 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 12 2018, 09:57 PM)
Yes. That is what an unanticipated career change means.

Look at it another way, he jumped out of the rat race, and found another mountain of cheese (ie. from working --> retirement --> working again). Just that this time he found an ideal job !

I do hope everybody who RE can be as successful as him ! But that is a tall hope I must admit 
A hypothesis remains a hypothesis. With the arguments as set out in the hypothesis, I still think selfishness is a reasonable conclusion for those who RE.

Many may have forgotten the content of the hypothesis. As a refresher, here it is again :

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

Yes, the same holds true when you bring out Mr Money Moustache. How many more Mr Money Moustache can you quote ?  biggrin.gif
*
ez peasy...

Mr Money Mustache
madFIentist
Frugalwoods
Physician on Fire
Early Retirement Extreme
jlcollinsnh
Root of Good
Go Curry Cracker!
1500 Days to Freedom
Our Next Life
Early Retirement Now
Millennial Revolution
Millennial Boss
The Escape Artist
OTHALAFEHU
sky18
post Sep 13 2018, 09:32 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 13 2018, 06:24 AM)
I have only heard of mr money moustache  biggrin.gif He has a lot of traffic.

If it is that easy to be more successful after retirement than before, why not start immediately ? Don’t waste any more time on the current job...RE and become a blogger everybody !  thumbup.gif

This has begun to sound like MLM recruitment. Come join us the RE MLM to turn over a new life. See our platinum diamond leader Mr Moustache. He makes RM100k per month sitting at home after joining RE MLM. If he can do it, so can everyone of you....
*
I guess this is a sign the end of fruitful discussion on FI/RE=selfish.

The list above is the site with Alexa rank (500k min) complied by reddit. Just hit https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence/wiki/faq for more valueable info.

Among of them including JL Collins, JD Roth which contribute a lots of valuable knowledge in this space.

sky18
post Sep 14 2018, 04:19 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(aspartame @ Sep 14 2018, 04:09 PM)
Just enjoy your remaining years in Malaysia lah.
*
Bro... He still healthy n below Aus official retirement age. Still many years ahead. Lol
sky18
post Sep 14 2018, 05:02 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(mrdude @ Sep 14 2018, 11:50 AM)
my only worry about FI/RE is that my kids may not have a good role model at home.

How do I get the kids to learn to work hard to be successful, if everyday they see their parents laze around at home with no career?
*
How are u going to tackle this? One of my concern too aside on sequence risk.
sky18
post Sep 16 2018, 09:23 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(mrdude @ Sep 14 2018, 10:52 PM)
I dont know, thats why im asking. Wondering if anyone has this experience
*
Perhaps just tell that you are the business owner which run a small investment management firm. (where the only source fund is ur own $$).

Afterall, its important to foster kids doing well in personal finance and positive attitude & values. If these passive streams work well till end of our life, they're the one to keep to ball rolling afterall.

Workplace is changing drastically with all sort of automation, robotic... I'm no longer set much expection on academic which emphasis on memorizing (the fact is most of formula, history, vocabulary just a click away)... and all these unlikely guarantee them excel in their adult life.


I read an analogy lately, working is like an exam... if you given 3 hours, and you smart enough to complete it within 1.5 hours, would you still stay in exam room? Are you defining your retirement based on your age or your financial & mental readiness.
sky18
post Sep 17 2018, 06:56 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 17 2018, 05:31 PM)
Garysydney, you are lucky you are not trading in malaysia at that time. They will sue you until bankrupt. And assign your debt to debt collectors. That would be hell...I remember there were many horror stories during 1987 and 1994 in malaysia.

Nice sharing....I hope the young readers here can take away something from your experience. If a young investors only started investing for the past 10 years in stock market, they haven't experienced any major crash yet. Sun will not always shine in the sky. There will be thunderstorms in between sunny days.

To relate to this topic, how many people incorporate into their retirement plan a few years of downturn ? A plan could be seriously affected in a major crash, and he has to slowly crawl out of the hole. If a retirement plan's expected return is 7%, is this return expecting a few years of negative returns ? Or worse, what if the capital takes a 50% or even 80% hit ? RE at 40 years old would not be possible, and he may need to start all over again
*
Garysydney nice sharing... both your luck and hardwork counts for the come back.

Showtime747 angmo terms it as sequence risk.

---------------

Many "young & smart" properties flipper feel the heat nowaday.. while I guess the bitcoins exposure in Malaysia still relative low.

Wandering what's the next GFC will looks like. Many angmo reached their FI path relative easy due to a decade of bull run in their index fund (8-9% return). And yet many countries were "subsidy" the US indirectly for their mistake during subprime bubble. It could be a disaster to them if China really overtook US in future and US dollar lost their prestige.

sky18
post Sep 21 2018, 01:37 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(icemanfx @ Sep 21 2018, 01:12 PM)
Not that gen x and y don't want fire, just that some have tried and failed. Most gen z have yet to experience failure hence are gungho. Like mlm and everyday life, only a very small minority will be successful. Otherwise, there should be over 3% of adults in this country have over us$100k net worth.
*
Its archivable in Malaysia. Just don't give up n persistent in earn, save n invest. If u excel in any of 2, it can shorten ur time.
sky18
post Sep 22 2018, 12:01 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 22 2018, 10:18 AM)
Well said!!  thumbup.gif  thumbup.gif  thumbup.gif

LYN need more people like you.

I was going to write something about this when i woke up this morning but i thought i won't want to waste my time. Good on you Showtime!!
*
Same thought here. Seems like Showtime747 is most committed here. LOL.

Lowyat forum is just plain basic forum. Can't compared against n reddit which system itself is design from ground up.

Btw, I don't agreed on saying "all gen Y or Z" is like this... Or gen X n baby boomer is like that... There's always diff believe and personality ppl in ea generations.

This post has been edited by sky18: Sep 22 2018, 12:17 PM
sky18
post Sep 22 2018, 03:24 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 22 2018, 03:05 PM)
This is what is most important in life!!

Contentment is the only time you have enough. rclxms.gif
*
Absolutely agreed. Your mindset is lots more important. Gary is very good example... If he learned his contentment back in young days... He probably Fire by early 30!
sky18
post Sep 22 2018, 11:29 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
LOL.... i doubt how many managed pullback as there're saying "it is easy to go from frugality to extravagant, but difficult to go from extravagance to frugality."

Anywhere, once one established strong financial discipline, and sound money traits that help him to reach FI, these habit will be carried along for the rest of life.

Eg: I was paying myself first since start working back in early 20+ and non-stop till reached FI which took about 15 years. Thereafter, all active income go enlarging the income-generating porfolio and maintain almost same lifestyle b4 & after FI. Practically my personally spending is lesser but it goes to kid. smile.gif

I always telling myself, we had 3 income streams in the household - my spouse, myself and "passive income worker".


sky18
post Sep 23 2018, 12:42 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Showtime747 @ Sep 23 2018, 07:07 AM)
Good strategy and example !

1. Start young
2. Keep same lifestyle before and after
3. Still enjoying life while achieving the objective. Be patient, don’t need to suffer a frugal lifestyle, let time do it’s work
4. Having a working spouse makes things easier. Before you, no one here mentioned having working spouse is a good way to shorten the process, up to half the time needed !
5. Know how to invest to put money into work because after retirement, that would be the main source of income. If a. person is not good in investing, retirement is a risky option
*
Point 3... frugal is a choice and not a suffer, it just a 2nd nature (perhaps many come from poor family had such trait) but not extreme as our youngter friend. Still go aboard for holiday, buy average continental cars, eating out, etc.

Point 5... investment is like any other skill, u got to learn & practise along the way and gain confident over the time. I dont actually aim for super high return but 5% is the baseline for FI/RE estimation. Compounding works great in long run. Everyone had different situation, no need to be a expert investor (score 12% or above every years) prior retirement. Earn, save, invest... excel in any of 2 will smoothen your journey.


QUOTE(Garysydney @ Sep 23 2018, 07:46 AM)
Point 2 - Keep same lifestyle before and after. In real life it is very hard to keep the same lifestyle. I used to eat a lot at food courts but nowadays i tend to frequent restaurants (not the really expensive ones). In food court, my food bill will be around A$30 (for 2 of us) while in a restaurant it will be about A$45-$60. Very hard esp people like me who loves food. On the other hand, i don't indulge in luxury goods anymore - i used to love Rolexes and expensive clothing but that desire is all gone (probably because i don't need to prove to anyone anymore unlike when i was younger). However i prefer better accomodation when i am travelling overseas compared to younger.

Point 4 - Having a working spouse. Very true. My wife's retirement savings is very close to mine as her pay was about the same as mine even though she elected to stop working at 50. She never paid the household bills as i took care of that so she just saved whatever she made.

P/s: We are very excited now as we can start accessing part of our super as of next year (when we hit our preservation age). My wife can draw a lot more than me because she has stopped working while i can only draw a little (transition to retirement) as i am still working.
*
Point 2..perhaps had to clarify, my own personal spending is reduced compare to young time; household wise, the spending ratio vs earning is reduced due to increased earning over the time. Life is progressing like married, extra family member, kids schooling, etc and u can't avoid that unless u choose to be single or voluntary childlessness. In short, household spending is unavoidable but you may choose your car (not the car you afford to pay installment but in cash term), your primary residence (million house or normal condo), and no luxury goods (expensive watches, LV bags, 4-6K premium phones, etc).

This post has been edited by sky18: Sep 23 2018, 02:17 PM
sky18
post Sep 23 2018, 08:44 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
Networthify

firecalc

cfiresim

Safe withdrawal rate

sky18
post Sep 29 2018, 05:59 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
Pretty good read with warrior, farmer and monk analogy.
- https://www.drwealth.com/are-financial-bloggers-suffering/

Choose the path that suits to your personality.
sky18
post Oct 1 2018, 10:25 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Ramjade @ Sep 29 2018, 06:29 PM)
I prefer to be the farmer who harvest dividend and live a monk life. Can or not?  hmm.gif hmm.gif
*
That's your decision and nobody understand U (internally) & your context (externally) better than other. There's always gradient and just pilot thru to the position you feel comfortable as it goes.

You going to hit the wall by acting like warrior if you're farmer mentality. While warrior might feel monk is suffering but monk wouldn't feel so, it merely the perspective on stuff & wanting is diff.


sky18
post Jun 18 2020, 12:57 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
Wander how the FIRE folks filing their tax if they retired with no active income.

Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.1069sec    0.47    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 30th November 2025 - 08:20 PM