Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

Anime Tengen Toppa Gurren-lagann, From Gainax

views
     
wolfx
post Mar 11 2008, 03:42 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



QUOTE(RangerRed @ Mar 11 2008, 02:16 PM)
Nia was a spiral being that at birth was modified by the anti spirals to be their messanger and spy.

Since they modified/'created' her at birth means that when they die she dies. This is link to the alternative universe creation (and destruction at the end of the last battle) part too.

I dont know why he can smile and she can to either at the last moment. Maybe because he knows there is an after life?

But that's not true for those of you that think that. His bro and friends only appeared in the alter universe dream because his drill (soul) knows something was wrong and was seeking an answer.

And the answers that he doesn't know he bro knows. So in effect the alter universe brought them to life for that moment.

Like how the mole rat wanted to evolve to a powerful being (it's intelligence evolved enough for Boota to realise it needed that) that the alter universe created a human body for it. Thus the same for Lord Genome's body.

I know its a long winded explaination but all things in the alter universe can be made real by the will of spiral beings (anti spirals are still spiral beings).

So maybe in the end they are smiling at each other is that they know how much they love each other so much that the sadness of Nia dying doesn't matter.

But it is still sad for us.
*
sweat.gif

1st part is true, 2nd part uhhhh rclxub.gif

The answer is very simple. She is happy that she did not give up the fight with the anti spirals and suffered the fate of other spiral beings. After defeating the anti spirals, she still had time to spend with Simon before she disappeared and that was enough happiness for her. Her life to her is a small price to pay to save the universe.

All those "alter universe" that you talk is actually the anti spirals tricking them to give up the fight and live in fake "matrix-dream-like happy life" controlled by them so that they can become like the anti-spirals later. Since the anti spirals profess that spiral beings have "unlimited wants" and will always fight to have more and more, they want to stop the Simon and gang to attain that. They want them to be like anti-spirals, devoid of emotions and desires. Simon and gang almost got tricked too but they wake up from the dream, and say "WHO THE !*(@&(!*@ YOU THINK WE ARE??? GIGA DRILL BREAKAAA!!!" Anti-spiral's ass.

The only alternate universe is the one seen in the beginning of episode 1 of Gurren Lagann where Simon continued to fight other Spiral beings and became the Spiral Nemesis after Nia's death.
wolfx
post Mar 11 2008, 05:19 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



QUOTE(RangerRed @ Mar 11 2008, 04:56 PM)
Maxtrix happy life part I am in arguement with for 2 reasons.

1. The subs for the anime are very specific about concepts. They don't beat around the bush about it. So if they were really in a dream state they would have said so. Instead they specifically use alternate universe. This is because the Anti Spirals are actually 1 step away from being the Spirel Nemesis. Their powers has come to a point that they have create an alternate universe which is where they are at. And at the same time create universes for all the heroes so they can explore to their 'hearts' content'. Now Anti Spirals are not "devoid of emotions and desires" and aren't trying to make the heroes like that too. Want they did was try a reverse of their current tactics since their 'fear and despair' tactics don't work. They their try to give the heroes is complacency. Each heroes' desires or needs fulfilled. One of Simon's needs is to let his bro direct his life for him so all he needs to do is follow. The casket which Simon sees then his bro bends his head is Simon's true desire (Nia) but he is conflict. Be complacent or venture forward and face whatever he meets. Which then the real Kamina pop's up.

You explaineded the same thing I said better than me, but i don't see why you are calling it "alternate universe". I disagree that they can create universes and stuff though cause if that's the case they might as well re-write the whole dem universe so they haxx0red and win everybody and no need be defeated by Simon.

Being devoid of emotions and desires is a by-product for for stopping their evolution. As you know anti-spirals have stopped their evolution because if the evolve further they fear they will become the spiral nemesis. Throughout the show, spiral power has been depicted as something like "Will Power", GARness, courage, greed (always want more) and perhaps manliness which translates to various things within the world of Gurren Lagann. Example, reproduction. The beastmen are cloned and can't reproduce normally hence they lack the "will power" as well as the spiral energy. BEastman live and work by the will of Lord Genome and now without him, by Simon's will. Whether Viral develops spiral energy later is debatable but that's another story.

So anyway, their main aim is to stop the use of Spiral Energy. 1st is Despair and Fear so the "courage" factor of spiral energy will be stopped. That failed. Then as you said they tried to induce complacency which failed as well. But i don't agree its through altered universes. More like dream-like state so they can remove their spiral energy and kill them off once and for all.

QUOTE

2. When the real Kamina pop's up he has invaded Simon's universe, Kamina can do this because Simon's a special case in terms of being a Spiral being or that Simon's statement that some form of Kamina and all his friends lives instead him (memories?) and because in the Anti Spirals' alternate universes your hopes and desires can manifest themselves. He asks Simon if that want he really wants? A world where life is easy (he just follows Kamina orders) and his big bro isn't as nearly as reckless that they are never in a life and death situation or the world where Simon is unsure of but never let's his fear stop him from going forward.

As for the others, they would have never realise they are in an alternate universe without Simon 'lighting' the way. After all, their are here for him and his 'drill' that pieces the heavens.

Oh last thing, the anime never mentions an after life ever. Or death and creation. Which at the end was mention that Simon is not god and he will not reincarnate anyone (unlike the Anti Spirals that can create, destroy and bring back to life whatever they want, just look at their alternate universe as an example).

"The answer is very simple. She is happy that she did not give up the fight with the anti spirals and suffered the fate of other spiral beings. After defeating the anti spirals, she still had time to spend with Simon before she disappeared and that was enough happiness for her. Her life to her is a small price to pay to save the universe."

I think it's more of she is happy that Simon did not give up on her and that he will come for her no matter what. But yes she will give up her life for the safety of her friends and the people of Earth and Simon.

The universe actually doesn't depend on her life. Simon's will is what the universe depends on or actually Earth. Remember that all the characters in this show are supports for Simon to win. But as you can see they are easily expandable. Even her, he would have driven the Drill through her to activate Cathedral Terra.
*
Indirectly her fate was what determined the outcome of that battle. If Nia died before gattai with Simon, i think Simon will be all emo and become Captain Garlock from episode 1 and wage wars with all Spiral Beings instead of longkang digger in the final episode. sweat.gif

It was implied that Simon can use spiral energy to bring Nia back to life but he knows he's only tricking himself by eating the blue pill and live in a false happy world, so he chose with the red pill, the harder decision and decide to live life as is.
wolfx
post Mar 12 2008, 12:11 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



QUOTE(RangerRed @ Mar 11 2008, 09:26 PM)
Not really, remember anyone with long term exposure to Simon evolve, mostly they become Spiral users if they have enough will. She may have evolved enough to sustain herself for her last wish... marrying Simon which I think became her last wish since she was taken from him just as she accepted his proposal and release (edit:realise) that she (edit: her) end is very near.
Nia is not a beastman. She's a spiral being, one of Lord Genome's daughters (planted by Anti-Spiral) so she has spiral energy regardless of with Simon or not. The reason she disappeared is because her creators, the anti-spirals, are destroyed. Not because she no more spiral power. I know its cliche where "if kill master, everything related to him will disappear too" but this is what is happening. The answer very senang only one lar.

QUOTE

Actually, they needed her for only one thing.. yes i am gonna be cold about it... they needed her to locate the Anti Spiral homeworld. Since they so conviently took her as Simon figure out his Spiral Warp skill.
So can u imagine if Nia died before Simon reached her? Even if he located the homeworld in time but was too late to save her, do you think Simon will go back to earth, and give the Core Drill to the the kid, and go live a life as a hermit? Hell no. He will want revenge, and his motivations for continuing the war would've been heightened.

Compared to what happened in the anime, Nia was still alive and supported/gattai with Simon and also let him know she doesn't have long to live. (compared to die killed by Anti Spirals) She talk to Simon about it, Simon understands and to fight on to avenge Nia will be pointless....thus the ending of the anime and why he never became captain KILL EM ALL WITH BIG SPIRAL CANNON Garlock.

Very important phrase....ep 1 , Boota says "All this stars....are our enemies...."

But final episode, Simon looks into the night sky after opening coconut for little boy and says... "All this stars....are our comrades"

See how Nia has changed what would probably be a worse outcome? She definately played a pivotal and important role in Simon's decision IMHO. nod.gif

QUOTE
As for emo? Not really, i think he overcomed loss of a close one after Kamina's death (not sacrifice).
*
This was talking about the alternate universe depicted in episode 1. It didn't happen in the end so no point arguing about it.
wolfx
post Mar 12 2008, 08:59 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



QUOTE(RangerRed @ Mar 12 2008, 08:15 AM)

Now for those of you that really want to know what Spiral Nemesis really means it means to be god. If they, the Anti Spirals was just rewrote the Universe to the way they want they will become the Spiral Nemesis. Which in a sense is a step a spiral being must pass as they evolve. That is to say, they will have to learn to control any ultimate power gainned, 'responsibility', quote Spidy. But the Anti Spirals fear that all Spiral beings will succumb to temptation and play god. Hence, why they stop themselves from evolving and in the end, ended up being a Spiral Nemesis (not the one they feared but a weaker version* hence they can live themselves with what decissions they choose for the Spiral beings*) by stopping other Spirals from evolving.
I think you're putting too much guesswork in here and not according to official canon of the story. The spiral nemesis is exactly what the word says it is. Nemesis means "enemy" hence a spiral nemesis is the enemy of all spiral beings. Don't think too far as God or whatever. As far as we know in the anime, we know if Spiral Nemesis happens, its the end of the world. That's all. How it happens, is based on fan theory only.

QUOTE

Ok the last paragraph of the 1st quote and the last paragraphs of 2nd quote are the same topic so I'll cover that now.

I didn't say Nia is a beastman. I said Nia being around Simon may have evolved her hence why the Anti Spirals was scanning her for a long time which gave Simon enough time to come get her. Yes, she has Spiral energy but like all Spiral beings it evolves slowly. Simon is an catalyst to accelerate that. Like for instance, the gay mentions before Simon met him he can't or can just barely read much less build, design and work with complexe technologies. But being around Simon accelerate his personal evolution. The others became exceptional combatants. And Kittan who has a lot of will/desire actually became a Spiral User/Warrior like Simon and Genome. So, yes Nia was born to Lord Genome and the Anti Spirals planted what we can call a control chip in her (that's a simpler way to look at it but they did it with energy).
I just considered that he inspires people to fight, not so much as "evolve" them. But they may mean the same thing in the anime....so that can be true since Boota gained some over 9000 spiral energy.

QUOTE
They observed the battles between Simon and Lord Genome and earlier monitor 1st hand the progress of Lord Genome's plan to control the Spiral population. Remember that Lord Genome is not a human.

He happened to land on Earth after surrandering to the Anti Spirals and found out the humans are a low level Spiral race so to prevent them from being wiped out like his race (not sure how many of his people are left) he culled and controlled the humans like the mandate the Anti Spirals used.
He is human. He just ran back to the planet he came from and ruled them.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lord_Genome

QUOTE
Jumping back to Nia, when they took control of her, they really took control of her. They merged their energy/matter that they implanted in her at birth with every fibre of her being thus making her their's in body but apparently not in heart. So once they we destroyed their energy/matter depleted from her body and once it is all gone it was only a matter of time before her damaged body will be unstable and tastefully disintegrate.
Fan conjecture at best. But it doesn't matter how u explain it, because the end result is the same. She is dying because her masters, the Anti-Spirals, are destroyed.

QUOTE
So now to the 1st section of the 2nd quote. Simon really won't go emo. Just like when Kamina died you don't see him screaming they will pay for his death. The emo thing he did when Kamina died is become withdrawn from the others and wanted to finish battles himself because he was afraid if they let them do it they would die and leave him alone. As you can see in his speech to Lord Genome he didn't say 'die you bastich for killing my bro and all my friends and the other innocents'. He only said that is he stood in Simon's way (evolution) he will bust through him everytime.

Yes, Nia is very important because without her living through the scanning and without the ring which she kept instead of throwing away (when she was controlled) Simon would have never located the Anti Spiral planet. But Simon will never fight a war of revenge just for her against the Anti Spirals. He will fight a war of survival against them though. Which he did. And destroyed them completely.
Hey....if I kill your best friend and kill your girlfriend, I don't think I expect two same reactions. I kill your best friend/big brother when you are a little kid, do you expect the little kid to go berserk and kill ppl? If I kill your girlfriend in your adult years in cold blood (because i like it) will you just sit down quietly and cry especially when you know I'm still alive laughing at you? I don't think you can compare Nia and Kamina to Simon's reaction.

Although the series never explicitly stated what was episode 1 is about, its quite clear that Simon has become the Spiral Nemesis and is enemies with the entire universe, and no one in the Gurren Brigade is seen including Nia. I can only conclude that Nia is dead.

NOTE: There is a rumour that the Gurren Lagann movie will follow this route, so if it really happens, we'll see it there. No point talking here since we just 2 fans interpreting it differently.

QUOTE

The 1st episode is an imagining of what would happen if Simon wasn't as laid back and matured as he is in the 2nd half of the anime. Remember he is not the Spiral Nemesis. To become that he has to be at least as powerful as the Anti Spirals. Instead, it is more or less what if Simon continued trying to walk in Kamina's shadow (being reckless and arrogent) instead of being himself (which is going on with life but not letting obstacles hinder him in finding his final path in life. And what was his final path? To lead the humans to the heavens. Which he did and that's why he handed the Core Drill over to the new generation. Because the old ways (breaking through walls) don't apply anymore since there is no more enemies out to completely destroy human kind (well until the movie is released then we know if it is really a story about man's tragedy with war, that we can never leave it behind).
Why do you think there are no more enemies to fight? Because Simon didn't become the Spiral Nemesis. And why didn't he become Spiral Nemesis? Because of Nia. Hence Nia's important role in the whole thing.

Hey i don't think Simon walking in Kamina's shadow makes him reckless and arrogant . In fact he trusts his big brother so much that he doesn't trust himself and he doesn't think he was capable. Worse case scenario i see is if he continued to be emo over Kamina's death, he would just be a very depressed young man with no aim in life and can't succeed Kamina as the Gurren Dan's leader. THere's no way he can become spiral nemesis in this route.

QUOTE

Here is a quote you would thought never applied to here but main story substance is this best said by my good pal, Dr. Ian Malcolm: If there is one thing the history of evolution has taught us it's that life will not be contained. Life breaks free, expands to new territory, and crashes through barriers, painfully, maybe even dangerously.
*
I think he forgot to mention dangers of extinction. laugh.gif
But otherwise good quote.
wolfx
post Mar 12 2008, 10:42 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



There will be 2 new lagann shows apparently. The movie, which will "betray everyone's expectations in a good way"and a OVA, which will fulfill the fans of the TV series...probably a "what happened after the war" episode.

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=251381

So probably the movie will go a different route of the TV series.

And the OVA is something like an epilogue.
wolfx
post Mar 12 2008, 11:22 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



Well it would seem we have ironed more or less the facts and what's left is unconfirmable theories. I would really like to see episode 1 intergalactic battle happen and how Simon got there, to see if RangerRed or me was accurate.
wolfx
post Mar 13 2008, 08:01 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



TTGL's prime time slot doesn't necessarily mean its just for kids, but it definately means that kids can watch it too and not restricted to adults only. Not every anime can be at that time since its the most expensive time slot to be put on.

That said, TTGL can appeal to both kids and adults. It has enough depth that it will appeal to adults and at the surface level can also appeal to kids. wink.gif
wolfx
post Mar 28 2008, 08:26 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



I lol-ed.

user posted image

wolfx
post Mar 31 2009, 08:30 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



Fans of GL must watch this.

http://www.mediafire.com/?mxwygrilimo

wolfx
post Apr 24 2009, 11:44 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



Adiane vs Yoko is AWESOME!!
wolfx
post Apr 28 2009, 03:03 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



QUOTE(richard0304 @ Apr 28 2009, 02:44 PM)
well I thought the movie was supposed to end at the part when they defeated Nia's father (forgot the name) but it was actually until they defeated one of the generals only. So does this imply that there will be a third movie? hmm.gif
*
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

wolfx
post Apr 29 2009, 10:15 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



QUOTE(DeidaraGS @ Apr 29 2009, 09:46 AM)
After reading the review of the 2nd Movie,all I can say is,when the DVD comes out,prepare to die from overdose of GAR.
*
Yeah man no shit....epic final battle is + GAR x 100!!
wolfx
post Apr 29 2009, 03:34 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



http://csakuras.livejournal.com/498775.html

I hear tonnes of shat brix
wolfx
post Apr 29 2009, 04:08 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



Yes...the ZETSUBOU part la. tongue.gif

wolfx
post May 28 2009, 08:19 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
93 posts

Joined: Jun 2006



QUOTE(XIII @ May 28 2009, 01:47 AM)


Video Link

Delicious Yoko is delicious.
I can't post Youtube link it seems.  sad.gif
*
Fix'd. notworthy.gif

Apa yoko...itu wakamoto la


Added on May 28, 2009, 9:58 amIMMA fapping to yoko now. Apparently its a PV for a marina inoue single.

This post has been edited by wolfx: May 28 2009, 09:58 AM

4 Pages « < 2 3 4Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0279sec    0.53    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 28th November 2025 - 03:58 PM