Hi,

I'd like to find out which phone has better speakers(without earphones) for music playback.

Better as in:

- Max volume without distortion
- Just specifically for music playback
- Equalizer effects, MEGABASS, etc doesnt matter.
- Sound quality in terms of clarity.
- Just the external speaker performance, without using earphones

[I actually have the K800 in mind,but I would really love a nice speaker so that I can share my music with others]

I'd appreciate it if you guys could give me your opinions, especially those who've had experience with either or both phones.

Thanx alot ya

This post has been edited by arcan8888: Jan 9 2007, 04:46 PM

No experience wif K800.
But w850i can play music at max volume without distortion even when megabass is ON.

As for SQ its superb

walkman phone always has advantages in sound reproduction over those k-series

yup... that's y they call Walkman series man...
if you are more into music get W850i if not you can get K800i

w850 if want music
k800 if wan photo quality
but with w850 you can take nice photo as well
no worry as i took few with nice quality and no AF
so AF actually not a big issue as long as steady hand

just my 2cent

well you are wrong... AF helps you to get sharper pic...

i know but without it if skill are good enough
without it will also can come out nice photo

to TS's question, which states more on audio over photo, I recommend Walkman phone. k800 lack of mega bass, which greatly limit it's sound quality.

It's not a limitation, just buy a HPM-70 earphones for it, remove the original earphones and use a pair of quality earphones to get more oompphh .... for a start Creative's EP630 is a good match for K800i. The lack of megabass is not an issue, you can use the EQ to fine tune the sound. By the way, I personally own a K800i so I'm not talking crap here, just an honest review on my phone, I have used a W800i before.

IMO,Mega Bass sux...sounds better withought it...

tested my fren's W810i...with Mega Bass ON the sound is too artificial...become not natural liao

tested with HPM-70 and my own KOSS Sparkplug

This post has been edited by Nightstalker1993: Jan 9 2007, 01:08 PM

luckily you edited your usual my e398 speaker is better post .lol

yea, actually mega bass don't really make the sound of the song nicer. also why do people always compare w850 and k800? it's like comparing a range rover to a ferrari....both are good cars, but for different functions

thats coz i'm commenting on the megabass feature and not the speaker lol

to me its kinda use less though .lol .

u're saying the megabass feature is useless or wad?

If you're using better earphones, then you can switch off the megabass, the original HPM-70 earphones lack of bass, that's why they used megabass to boost the bass response. For better earphones, with the megabass on, the sound will be very boomy and distorted.

Guys,

Thank you for all your comments.

I'm quite aware of the fact that the K-Series are camera biased and the W-Series are more music biased.

But my question actually concerns the speakers of both phones (without using earphones);

[I actually have the K800 in mind,but I would really love a nice speaker so that I can share my music with others]

Is there any significant difference between the two of these phones?

In terms of just the music being played using the phone speakers.


Thanx alot ya....

the w850 might have louder speakers . to me the k800i speaker seems a bit soft , but ok .

just to share...i tried and play with K800i...the quality is good...and you still can share with you friends...maybe not in a big group...
but haven't compared one on one with W850i...

When in uni computer lab, i on music on my k800i, put in on my desk as i do my report. Reasonably ok. Don't expect quality u get from a superb surround system or something. It is slightly above average. for sharing purposes, and listening, its ok. I often to it with my friends, listen to some latest songs together about 6 of us. But note, dun expect to use it for like a party!

Sure W850 coz got megabass while K800i dun hv

of course w850i!!!

w-series always has advantage in sound reproduction compared with others

personally, its up to u to decide. in terms of music functions, w850i has a slight advantage over the k800i due to its Mega Bass functions but lacks in terms of photo taking functions such as AF. Its up to u to decide. If u want a photo taking phone, get the K800i. If u want a music based phone, get the w850i. BOth phones are great. So its up to u to decide.

Final say:
Music: W850i
Camera: K800i

Good luck!

Thank you so much for your comments.

I really appreciate them.

Of course is w850i...if u got opportunity 2test both phone, try out..then u can know the difference instantly

off course w850i is the best for music ,because it was made for music , but if you compare it with k750i it might have some differences

although K800i has advantages on camera and anti-blurr.
but, think again. buying a handphone, do u need any camera that is very very high end?

think again, you might as well purchase another camera to snap photo.
The phone's camera can't replace a real camera.

think again, you might as well take W850i, because of K800i joypad just like the old ones(well, it looked like the old ones, which will spoil after almost one year)
That's my opinion...I still prefer W850i if u ask me.

w850 for me
for camera we always can get a digicam
but frankly w850 manage to produce some nice photo as well

w850 for me
for camera we always can get a digicam
but frankly w850 manage to produce some nice photo as well