Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Big 4 Recruitment Drive_v3

views
     
dasecret
post Apr 3 2017, 11:55 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(limeuu @ Apr 3 2017, 11:19 AM)
the pyramid structure acts as an invisible glass ceiling...
*
Have you worked in Big 4 before?
dasecret
post Apr 4 2017, 08:31 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(rtxinai @ Apr 3 2017, 04:46 PM)
Is it hard to get into big 4 if I have a professional qualification like acca?
*
Not that difficult, full ACCA qualification is actually the preferred credentials. But one still needs to be able to communicate effectively in interviews to seal the deal.

QUOTE(calvinmax @ Apr 4 2017, 06:22 AM)
Thanks for the info bro!
4. Regarding to this. I thought promotion is almost every year from AA1 to AA2 and then SA1 to SA2? Will that be a 25% increase in increment? Or just from AA2 to SA1 only? 
Wow! 7 months bonus is a lot! But it is for top management only and not for audit associate?

I do agreed with what you said. There are a lot of successful people out there (be it CFO, financial controller, finance manager) have big 4 experience. At the same time there are a lot who actually quit after a year or two and they are not getting to anywhere too.

My friend is seeking for my advice recently. He is currently working in one of the mnc (which offered him pretty good salary, benefits, location is good as he do not need to jam to office, working hour is pretty flexible, good working culture) and was given the opportunity to join the finance department and at the same time he got an offer from one of the big 4.
He is not sure whether to accept that offer or not because he afraid that the downpart might happen (as in leaving after one or two year) and forego his current job which is pretty good in terms of all perspective but definitely the future are not as bright as big 4. Kindly advise.
*
My info might be outdated but AFAIK AA1 to AA2 is not considered promotion, just natural progression; only when associate become senior associate is considered a promotion; and then to assistant manager and to manager. So AA1 to AA2 increment won't be as much as from AA2 to SA1

on bonus, that was top performer bonus; applies to the top 10% rated staffs across all levels. Like I say I was rather lucky. But AFAIK only 1 firm in Big4 differentiate bonus payout for top performer significantly. The other firms usually just add 1 or 2 months on average bonus for the top performers

From the story you told me, if he's really happy in that MnC and the boss is the type who would give him opportunity to grow within the company, then I'd stay put. Because not all companies are like that. There are many that when you join as executive, it takes years before you could move up to say assistant manager; whereas in Big 4 the progression is very defined and relatively fast. But sometimes it's also luck, if you end up working with a nightmare manager & partner in a nightmare engagement, then you are stuck in that sh*thole and it's really depressing. But in the end, it really depends on what your friend wants. No one can decide for him

Anyway, an even more important advice is, once you found a boss who would give you opportunity to grow and shine, stick to that boss! Good boss doesn't come by often

This post has been edited by dasecret: Apr 4 2017, 09:51 AM
dasecret
post Apr 6 2017, 09:33 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(calvinmax @ Apr 6 2017, 08:09 AM)
I believe that bro u r from one of the big 4 and hence I think that your advice is very valuable to my friend. Btw, thanks for the info.

Would u mind to share what is the average rate of increment, I mean for normal progression from AA1 to AA2?

If my friend were to join big 4 he would experience a pay cut of 700 exclude the allowance from big4. If with allowance would be a pay cut of 500. And there will be additional parking fees which is quite exp. Bcos his commitment is quite high. He is wandering will there be an increment after confirmation in big4?

He really afraid of making the wrong move. Bcos he is yet to change his department to finance. He is currently in other department in his current com and he is waiting for vacancy (whereby he do not know how long he have to wait).

His main concern is that, he is afraid that when he move to big4, he has to forego his current salary and if he doesn't like big4 and quit maybe one or two yr later then he might stuck half way. Then he is sort of afraid that in his current com the future is not as bright as those in big4 and what will happen if he is unable to change his department. He feels insecure. Hope you can provide some valuable advise from ur point of view.
*
I'm a bit too distant to comment on associate salary; but year 1 to year 2 increment is not much la; maybe 5-10%?

No one can promise him if he would like this route or not; sometimes one just need to decide and take the leap of faith

Like both of us said, maybe it makes sense to stay put given his current situation. Not everyone in Big4 turn out to have super bright future. I'd rate myself as ok ok only in terms of $$$ and prospects. But I'm happy at the work I do and that to me is enough.

p/s: there are a lot of ex-Big4 that I know who end up doing things completely irrelevant to their big4 experience. Some end up becoming entrepreneurs, air stewardess, insurance agent (there's one on lowyat), MLM agents


dasecret
post Apr 6 2017, 02:37 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(calvinmax @ Apr 6 2017, 02:24 PM)
Your comment are highly valuable. Bcos I have not work in any of the big 4 before so I'm not able to give him any comment on how's life there are or how things are.

My friend always have this thought that leads him to ask me a ques which I do not how to ans him. He is very impressed with people working in big4, he always has this perception that only by joining big4 he can go further in his career. He is also think that working is a very prestige and profession job. He is very worried about his progression now. He knew that life may not be easy too in big4. He just has too much concern. I think he is lack of confidence on himself.

Don't get me wrong. My friend is a very determine type person. He has extremely consistent good result throughout his academic life. He always the top. He can work from mon to sun those type. He aspire to have a successful career as well.

I never seen him so lost before. I never seen him so stress before. He can't even sleep. He has lost his direction. I really wanted to help him.

I hope you can share with him some of your opinion.

Thanks!
*
Then go for it; jump right in and work like there's no other option. If he decide to take the leap of faith, he musn't give up after a year or 2, otherwise it's all for nothing

Very often those who quit early was encouraged by parents or friends that tell them it's not worth working hard or sacrificing social life.

If your friend just graduated and was considering between a big 4 job offer and another MnC or GLC, I'd certainly say big4 for exposure and future prospects. But since he's already in a seemingly stable job with good people to work with, it may be better without really knowing what he's like.

Maybe what he need to realise is, there's more than 1 way to success; Big4 may be a common way, but is definitely not the only way

This post has been edited by dasecret: Apr 6 2017, 02:41 PM
dasecret
post Apr 11 2017, 10:04 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(80sNonStopYeah @ Apr 8 2017, 01:23 AM)
dear all sifus,been a looker for awhile and had read up all the posts in all 3 threads, just wondering, is there a cut off age in big 4 for fresh associate?? im 29 this year and looking forward to do a career switch into tax field. cheers for any opinion....
*
I'm not from tax. I did have a junior; who started doing audit in a big4 firm when he was 30+. He actually stayed for 10 years or so
Well, how to put this in words....
Your peers will think you are weird; you may not blend well with your peers due to your age; and to me at that phase of career, peers r very important to get you through thick or thin

But in the end it depends on you, whether you really wanted it and what do you want out of it exactly
dasecret
post Apr 11 2017, 02:03 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(80sNonStopYeah @ Apr 11 2017, 01:56 PM)
But how he got in?
*
Apply like how everyone else did. He did have ACCA and some experience in accounting and internal audit

I'm quite sure interviewer would ask the question of why would you want to join at this age and you should have a good and convincing answer for it
dasecret
post May 9 2017, 10:33 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Carbeginner @ May 9 2017, 11:43 AM)
I am currently having my degree in accounting, wanted to ask that is it necessary for audit associate to have professional qualification because I am planning to prosper my audit career in big 4? How far can a degree holder in accounting go without professional qualification in big four ? How to get MIA ? And what if I just get MIA without having professional qualification ? Looking forward for your reply
*
Why the reluctance to do professional exams?

General answer to that is, AFAIK, big4 would require you to do professional paper even if you can go the local uni route to get MIA membership with 3 years relevant experience. It's their way to ensure quality of the staff and staff retention tool through training bond.

I'm not sure if it's the case for all big 4, but I know at least 2 firms would delay your promotion to manager if you do not complete professional papers. It's very demotivating when your peers who may not even perform as well as you at work to move up faster than you.

Personally I find professional papers is a very good challenge and albeit how tough it was, it's definitely worth doing. After doing professional papers, I felt my accounting degree was such a fraud, I learn maybe not even 1/3 of what I need for my professional development in uni
dasecret
post Nov 7 2017, 04:18 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(Sasuke95 @ Nov 4 2017, 01:04 PM)
The phone and f2f interview for ey are so stressful and invasive.

It is not easy to finish all acca papers, as well as getting a 2nd upper in degree, i failed just once in acca and twice in degree.

Yet all their questions revolving around why I failed.
How am I supposed to know? The important thing is that I made it at the end despite the rocky path of my studying life.

It is like asking "why you're a boy?", I just answered vaguely saying I have personal problems that time, and they want me to disclose. They also want me to disclose what offers do I have currently, dig very deep.

At the end got rejected, more or less I know the outcome already as I don't really know how to answer the interview questions. Just wondering don't they need people for the peak period? Have to be really picky to choose?
*
You know what's your problem? Your sense of entitlement. Actually you should already be prepared to answer on the failing papers part. Just like next time when you job hop, a sure question is - why do you want to leave? And the answer should never be vague or complaining about current company

For fresh grads, Big4 are spoilt for choice, you need them in your CV more than they need you. Sure, they hire lots of people, but that doesn't mean they have to hire you. You need to convince them that you are worth their while, and ACCA alone is not gonna be enough

Attitude wise, those that always work is - can do mindset, adaptable and drop that sense of entitlement please. No one owe you anything, not even your parents

QUOTE(Topace111 @ Nov 6 2017, 02:56 PM)
If you find the interview question invasive, wait till you meet your audit partner and client. I know a Big4 partner that has zero qualm of grilling a staff in front of everybody at high pitch with language that even Gordon Ramsay is proud of. You may also get that a lot from client who generally viewed auditors as annoyance in Malaysia.

Yes, I think it’s better for them to filter out candidates that don’t fit their culture. It’s not a playground. Yes, they need a lot of people during peak period but they are not obliged to hire anybody. The cost of recruiting the wrong candidate is greater than having insufficient staff. At least the manager can blame lack of resources over mistakes.

Finishing your education is their lowest and minimum expectation. They don’t need to hire top graduates for the work they do (although they wanted to but they will lose these candidates to investment banks or consulting firms). Sometimes failure is justifiable and with legitimate reasons. Some of the best people I work with are not a top scorer. It requires different traits to be a good staff and a good education background (which signifies learning capabilities) is just one of them.

Another example is how well you learn in a non-controlled environment? For example, how you respond during crisis, how you multi-task, how you prioritise key deliverables, how you deal with clients that are not cooperative, how you deal with your supervisor who has a different style …. You don’t learn any of this in textbook. The closest is through interview questions. If you can’t convince them in the interview, what makes you think they are confident to hand the projects to you?

Don’t worry; no one is immune to mistakes. I have made similar ones. The important thing is to learn and improve on it.
*
So agree with this reply.
dasecret
post Nov 20 2017, 12:55 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(milk11bottle @ Nov 18 2017, 11:55 PM)
Dear all who work at Deloitte,
I'm joining Deloitte next Monday and I still can't buy a pair of black heels!!!! ( This is true.. I went to 3 parksons... and other shoe shops.. no 37/38 at all...! My budget is <rm100.. Is it weird or is it just my luck?)
Is it ok to wear black flat at work first?
*
Try ZALORA for that budget

It’s preferred that you wear black court shoes for this line of work. HR would brief the new joiners on dress code
dasecret
post Jan 23 2018, 10:25 AM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,498 posts

Joined: Nov 2012
QUOTE(ChanYip1000 @ Jan 18 2018, 12:03 AM)
Curious question - can a person be promoted to manager in 1 year?  I heard this lecturer claim she knows of a person who did that in Big 4 and then left to teach.

Is it true that PWC will not consider those that have failed 2 or 3 times before in ACCA exams?

Does the sunway college brand carry any weight in getting a job - my dad thinks so?
*
From fresh grad to manager? Not possible. If join with experience, maybe, depending on his past experience and ability to handle the responsibility as manager

The normal path from fresh grad to manager is about 5-6 years depending on firm. I did a 4.5 years; I've seen a ICAEW world prize winner did a 4 years; but the truth is, it's not sustainable, she left shortly after promotion. Ppl who fast tracked tends to be burnt out or could not handle the accelerated demand of the new role.

Multiple fails in exam is not a good sign, so it goes to bottom of the pile, but depending on how desperate they are, they may dip their hands into bottom of the pile. As long as you complete the ACCA, still got chance. If didn't complete and don't have degree, no chance, goes to the bin straight

Sunway as a brand, to be honest, even if it makes a difference, the difference is very minimal. It may get you a chance for the interview, but if you didn't do well in interview, Sunway won't land you the job. In the end it's you they are hiring. If LSE, Oxford or Cambridge grad also, if can't speak your mind, very tough.

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0915sec    0.57    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 29th November 2025 - 04:09 AM