How much do you wanna pay?
The edifier s530d is good

You won't be getting 100% same bass as vs4621 but it is better sounding as it is more responsive.

You can consider edifier r2800 for loose bass or r2700 for tighter bass

for an 8" woofer heavy slow cone it's considered tight among competitors of similar woofer size but if you compare it with a vs4621 with a 6.5"  light and responsive loose cone it's somewhat comparable.

I find my S530D is soft and gentle to be considered well blend for smooth jazz and not aggressive type for EDM

You might want to test it with your ears to double confirm as reading will only get your imagination this far.

I was told they are bad in quality but I don't really get any real news in failures. (you can try it. they are not my cup of tea though. they sounded weird)

But vinnfier and eacan speakers are lightweight. Not something I would like in speakers.

sound is produced by vibration. heavvy weight has advantage so that the enclosure dont shake itself when u play loud.
wood is not called a shield, but can reduce internal reflection wave by a little.

Hi, looking for a speaker set for a small living room under RM600. Please recommend.
Currently looking at Edifier R1900TV 2.0, Edifier C3X 2.1, and Edifier R501TIII 5.1.

Btw only listening to music/movies in stereo.
Which of these can go the loudest and are best for vocals? Cause my previous speaker set have very flabby bass and can't hear vocals/conversations clearly.

And I'm guessing the R1900TV 2.0 has the weakest bass compared to the other 2, but are they really that weak?

That's a bold move and I do not know the answer to this.
I only know that the S350DB trebles are way louder and smoother than the R1850DB slight crunchy trebles

Hmm..... I think the setup and condition when you demo is giving you wrong impression of the speaker. R1700BT bass is far from achieving the bass that S1000DB able to create. S1000DB bass have more impact, wider and it goes lower hz than R1700BT. Using bluetooth is also not ideal since R1700BT only support SBC while S1000DB support the better APTX.

Have you seen this video? R1850DB is basically the R1700BT just with additional sub output. S1000DB bass are clearly louder and more impact than R1850DB. Use heaadphone to listen.


S1000DB would be better if for music while R1850DB with sub-woofer is better for movie.

I seen that video. Although can hear slight difference but Digital Stereophony said the different is negligible. As he hear the 2 speakers himself I believe what he said.