Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

Chat Question to atheist

views
     
Archmage Warlic
post May 3 2015, 10:43 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
117 posts

Joined: Apr 2012


QUOTE(lshsl @ May 2 2015, 01:15 PM)
Some  people don't  bother what will happen when the time comes. They just adhere  to simple life  principle - do good, don't  do bad, be responsible  for own mistakes. They can have no fear when the time comes.

Some people are given two choices. They do a lot of things day and night, and still feel doing not enough (until overdo it I think). They are still in fear when the time comes. (afraid of 50/50%, go up or go down)

The salvation /mercies is meaningless, if too many strict terms and conditions apply.
*
This perfectly narrates my "religion". I wish there is a single word I can use to describe this whenever people relentlessly ask about my religion.

This also explains why I find some religions ridiculous. I have been bought to a Christian Methodist church several times and in their sermons (or whatever they were doing - a priest / group representative leading everyone to chant out verses and sentences projected in Powerpoint slides), they repeatedly chant "I am aware I cannot obtain salvation by doing good deeds, I can only be saved by believing in Him".

I took an immediate dislike towards the entire sermon / session. The entire session seems to be like "You WANT to be saved -> Believe in me to be saved! -> Oh, by the way, good deeds are pointless."

What is the point in discrediting good deeds? Is the religion suggesting going good deeds are of no importance, and worthless? Is this why many people seem to be focusing too much into their afterlife to the point that they are unaware of what they are doing to the people around them? Is this why people talk and talk about being saved in church but treats people like pieces of trash out of the church?

Perhaps that is why I find many of the most religious people around me to be unbelievable hypocrites. The most horrifying thing is the fact that they can continue their lives comfortably while justifying to themselves for being a huge hypocrites.

Religious F***tards.

(P/s: Oh, and even if you bring this out for discussion in the most civil way possible, such as in academic debates, there will CERTAINLY some people who would either secretly or overtly get batshit offended and start getting defensive, and if you are unlucky, probably mark you for assassination)
Archmage Warlic
post May 6 2015, 12:54 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
117 posts

Joined: Apr 2012


QUOTE(Cryptic @ May 5 2015, 07:15 PM)
Erm I think you got the message of the sermon wrong. You are saved by believing in Him, you aren't justified by your own deeds. You don't earn grace but it was given freely to you when you believe in the Son if I am right as contrast to the Pharasies. See Luke 18:9-14. if I am right that is. The bible never said to not do good deeds see Mathew 6 and Hebrews 13:6 nor did it said it was pointless. I think (new believer here) good deeds isn't your ticket to salvation, but believing in Him, and when you believe in Him (and/or love Him), you will do good to others because his last commandment was for us to love others like He loved us.

Just asking were you a non believer when you attended the sermon?
*
QUOTE
You are saved by believing in Him, you aren't justified by your own deeds. You don't earn grace but it was given freely to you when you believe in the Son if I am right as contrast to the Pharasies.

What are you even trying to say? How is "saved", "justified" and "earn grace" different from one another? It seems like plenty of new words have been thrown in and is making everything unclear. Also, while the Bible never explicitly said to NOT do good deeds (I never claimed that anyway), and the Bible never explicitly said that good deeds are pointless, but given how the importance of good deeds and noble, charitable acts has been downplayed, isn't the same thing being implicitly implied? If good deeds are not the ticket to salvation, why bother going out of our way to aid others? Believe that He exists, and believe that He is God - isn't that all you need?

Saved... from what? Damnation? Hellfire? Hellfire which he created to shove non-believers into?
Compare "U tak suka, u tak ikut cara kami, u pergi India, u balik China" with "You don't follow my ways, you don't believe in me, to Hell you go, in Hell you stay".
The God is a feudal lord who creates the world, owns the world and demands everyone to worship him? *jawdrops*
"Bow, and kneel to me, or stay in prison, FOREVER!"

QUOTE
...and when you believe in Him (and/or love Him), you will do good to others...

False. Do all people who believe in Him automatically do good to others? If you believe in Him, you will surely do good to others? People do believe in Him, go out of church, break as many commandments as you can think of, do malicious things for personal gain, justify their actions to themselves for a while, go to church, express their remorse and ask for forgiveness, rinse and repeat. At the end of the day, they still think they can hope for a chance to be sent to Heaven - they are believers, after all.

I apologize if my replies above are a mess. I'm not in my best state today.

To the theists: I have many classmates/colleagues/teachers/friends/acquaintances/strangers convincing me to believe in their God, and join their brotherhood. Islam, various branches of Christianity, Buddhism, Sikhism, Hinduism, Taoism, you name it. They have shown me countless long, long anti-atheistic arguments, mainly to prove God really exists. However, my concern is not whether God exists or not, but the question which I have asked many of them:
QUOTE
Me: Okay, say, God exists. Why have you followed <religion> then? How do you know if the god is Allah, Jesus, Buddha, Flying Spaghetti Monster, or a pantheon of Hindu, Greek or Roman gods? How do you know if there is just one God, or a pantheon of Gods, constantly bickering at one another?
What if the God is actually, say, Allah? For being a Christian and not a Muslim, you are going to Hell. The same way goes the other way round. How do you know what religion to believe in?

Reply: I dunno. I just believe. I just believe my religion is the true religion, and pray that my choice is right.

Me: Believe? Based on what? Ignorance? Why believe your religion is the correct one, not the others? Pray? Pray to whom? Say, you are a Christian praying to Jesus that you are correct to be a Christian, but if the God is Flying Spaghetti Monster instead... how do you even know who to pray to? You need to pray to some deity that you are praying to the correct deity, but how do you choose?


This post has been edited by Archmage Warlic: May 6 2015, 12:54 AM

Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0221sec    0.37    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 27th November 2025 - 01:15 PM