QUOTE(dreamer101 @ Jul 26 2009, 12:52 PM)
Dreamer
2) Before we even start, what is YOUR DEFINITION of investment?? For me, anything that you cannot go to sleep for 5 years and do not even look at is NOT investment.3) So, in my opinion, other than ASB, the rest of PNB's products do not fit under my definition.
(Unit trust is not investment???? strange, which school r u from?)
4) Given that EPF is managed by GLIC too. I do not trust them either. Comparison between ASx and EPF is irrelevant. They behave the same.
(they are not the same. EPF is mandatory contribution if u r an employee, for ASX u have a choice, they are managed by different entities and they have different portfolios too)
5) It is NOT low risk to put money into hand of people that you do not trust,
(seems that u r very anti umno/bn government, you shdn't put your dislike sentiments from the existing government into the products that they managed. Even Pakatan win the next election, the government will be headed by Malay/Bumi (be it from PKR or PAS), so Bumi interst will still be protected. Be it PKR or UMNO headed the country in the future, PNB will still be strong, PNB was set up to take care of the biggest ethnic in the country)
<< the dividen is at downward trends, in the same way as our BLR, FD Rate and corporates' earning. Unit trust earning are mainly derive from the coroprate earning, when economy doing badly, business world will be badly affected.>>
7) Read your OWN post carefully and check your assumption. We had a bull market and KLSE went up at least 30% over the last few years. But, what is the dividend trend over the last few years?? This is YOUR MONEY. Your choice. But, please do not give out wrong information.
(You are the one that giving worng info and mislead others, i didn not compare ASW with share market, i am comparing ASW return with EPF and FD, when economy doing bad, FD rate is dropped to 2%, so that's why i said ASNB products is better than FD and EPF. ASW is a safe investment it doesnt go up to 30% when market is good, but it never go negative 30% when the market is bad, rm1/unit is still rm1/unit no matter how market performs + minimun 6% return for the past 15 years-> track records).
<< I have studied the ASW portfolio, it is in fact investing in the govenrment linked company (GLC) the top 5 share holding are Maybank, TNB, CIMB, Sime Darby, PNB Structured Fund,>>
8) I would not invest in any of the those 4 counters. Would you?? If not, why are you buying ASW??
( u seems have zero knowledge on mutual fund. If you have RM100 only can u buy any of these 4 counters? but thru mutual fund, u can, it also help u to diversifying your porfolios. Pls read the concept of mutual fund before barking here, dont waste my time explaining to you)
9) Do you know what happened to UEM during 97/98.?? If you don't, why should I waste my time with you??
( i am not that old to know this, i dont think any of the readers here want to know UEM issue from an arrogant guy like u, so u can safe your time on explaining it. Bear in mind that the topic here is talking about PNB products, not UEM)
Dreamer
Added on July 26, 2009, 2:17 pmDreamer
2) Before we even start, what is YOUR DEFINITION of investment?? For me, anything that you cannot go to sleep for 5 years and do not even look at is NOT investment.3) So, in my opinion, other than ASB, the rest of PNB's products do not fit under my definition.
(Unit trust is not investment???? strange, which school r u from?)4) Given that EPF is managed by GLIC too. I do not trust them either. Comparison between ASx and EPF is irrelevant. They behave the same.
(they are not the same. EPF is mandatory contribution if u r an employee, for ASX u have a choice, they are managed by different entities and they have different portfolios too)5) It is NOT low risk to put money into hand of people that you do not trust,
(
seems that u r very anti umno/bn government, you shdn't put your dislike sentiments from the existing government into the products that they managed. Even Pakatan win the next election, the government will be headed by Malay/Bumi (be it from PKR or PAS), so Bumi interst will still be protected. Be it PKR or UMNO headed the country in the future, PNB will still be strong, PNB was set up to take care of the biggest ethnic in the country)<< the dividen is at downward trends, in the same way as our BLR, FD Rate and corporates' earning. Unit trust earning are mainly derive from the coroprate earning, when economy doing badly, business world will be badly affected.>>
7) Read your OWN post carefully and check your assumption. We had a bull market and KLSE went up at least 30% over the last few years. But, what is the dividend trend over the last few years?? This is YOUR MONEY. Your choice. But, please do not give out wrong information.
(You are the one that giving worng info and mislead others, i didn not compare ASW with share market, i am comparing ASW return with EPF and FD, when economy doing bad, FD rate is dropped to 2%, so that's why i said ASNB products is better than FD and EPF. ASW is a safe investment it doesnt go up to 30% when market is good, but it never go negative 30% when the market is bad, rm1/unit is still rm1/unit no matter how market performs + minimun 6% return for the past 15 years-> track records). << I have studied the ASW portfolio, it is in fact investing in the govenrment linked company (GLC) the top 5 share holding are Maybank, TNB, CIMB, Sime Darby, PNB Structured Fund,>>
8) I would not invest in any of the those 4 counters. Would you?? If not, why are you buying ASW??
( u seems have zero knowledge on mutual fund. If you have RM100 only can u buy any of these 4 counters? but thru mutual fund, u can, it also help u to diversifying your porfolios. Pls read the concept of mutual fund before barking here, dont waste my time explaining to you)9) Do you know what happened to UEM during 97/98.?? If you don't, why should I waste my time with you??
( i am not that old to know this, i dont think any of the readers here want to know UEM issue from an arrogant guy like u, so u can safe your time on explaining it. Bear in mind that the topic here is talking about PNB products, not UEM)cheahcw
This post has been edited by cheahcw2003: Jul 26 2009, 02:17 PM