Looks like Estrella? D VS1 bro. It should be marginally better than the E VS2 on terms of brilliance. The depth for E VS2 is slightly deeper but ntg too major there. Also, check the fire too, the crown angle for D VS1 is steeper at 35 degrees and may actual return more fire. However, E VS2 has a smaller table and this may help to increase its fire as well. So I supposed it is more or less the same for both. Anyway, when you have the chance to see both rings, look carefully and see which one you prefer more. Another reason is that IGI may be a bit lenient in terms of grading colour. So for a D colour, even if really down 1 to 2 grades whem graded by GIA, it is still within colourless range. Some more, no need to resize! Resizing sometimes can be not so nice to be honest. At least that is my experience. Hope this helps.

p.s. Mind sharing me the final price? You can PM me if you don't wish to disclose publicly. I am pretty curious about it. Thanks.

Recently another bro just asked about Estrella so I know lor. Some more this kind of proportions usually belong to Hearts and Arrows diamond. And Estrella is one of them. Ok, so for this stone... It is pretty good. In fact, it may have the best fire because of the steep crown angle and the smaller table. If size is your main criteria then it is fine, but as mentioned before, some said IGI is more lenient in terms of colour (not sure about clarity though). However IGI Hong Kong seems to be quite reputable and according to what I read on PriceScope (a popular diamond forum), it is quite on par with AGS. But then, Estrella should be graded by IGI Antwerp, and colour may be a bit lenient. Heck, even AGS can be more lenient compared to GIA by a grade or two in terms of colour(according to some people, but to me it is still on par to me, some GIA stones even goes a colour grade lower when graded by AGS), but they are better in terms of cut and clarity. I have to emphasize this is what I have read online, not looking at the diamonds myself. I am just sharing what I know and what I find makes sense to me, but for whatever we read online, do take it with a pinch of salt.

So, my view is - Get the D colour diamond. So even if there is really a colour difference compared to GIA, it may still be quite colourless. Also, you won't have to worry about resizing. As for size, it should be noticeable but then I think D colour is more tempting. Have you checked with them whether they can cast you a new platinum ring? In case you want the F VS1? I seriously won't recommend resizing a ring. It is like car bumper kena hit and then go to the workshop and reshape it. It will most likely won't look or feel the same.

As for size, it may be noticeable, maybe slightly. Just get the 3 rings snd view yourself bro.

Lastly, the price is not cheap. You can get AGS graded stones online at a better price. But then, Diamond & Platinum can provide you one-stop service, so is give and take. If you set your eyes on Estrella and need further help, I am all ears. Good luck!

p.s. You bring your gf along?

If resize like half size or one size then OK. Resize sampai 4 sizes better not man. Cuz someone posted on this thread a few months ago about a terribly done resizing job by a local jeweller. Totally ruined his ring design and on top of that, his ring became like an egg shape.

If they sell as loose diamond, one may be able to see the hearts and there might be a chance that the hearts are not as good to that person who view it, and this may make it harder to sell. Anyway, I still think if the H&A is that good, they should either photograph it or display it on the report. Hearts is the hardest thing to get correctly IMO, don’t be fool by the statement that perfect arrows equals perfect hearts, that is quite bullshit. I have heard that from some other brand.

Are their Hearts & Arrows consistent? Or just showing a pattern of Hearts & Arrows? What is their definition of ideal cut?

Btw, can't see the photobucket that you uploaded. Perhaps you may want to attach straight away right here or share the GIA number.

Hi guys. I am interested in buying a proposal ring right now. Need it by mid-December before I head to US. Therefore, all the inputs here by sifu will be very useful to me.

To start it off, before coming here, I have go around in MV-Gardens to survey for the diamond rings. Tomei, Goldheart, Love&co, Wah Chan, Poh Kong and Le Lumiere. From the 1st 2 shops, I still wasn't sure want I wanted in a diamond. Luckily, I met some good sales person who willing to explain to me all the 4C and also their products. At first, I set my minimum diamond as colour E, clarity VVS2, 3Ex cut and 0.4 carat; budget RM6k. But after going through the few initial shops, I realised that with that budget, I am unable to achieve that kind of diamond spec I wanted.  Then I went on to do my own 'homework' by researching and reading about diamonds. I learned that with limited budget, you can't always get the best of all 4C. Also putting Cut > Carat > Colour > Clarity as my priority. I have friends that disagree that cut should not be the most important of all 4C. Some said carat, some said colour and clarity. After all the readings and surveying, I still believe Cut is the most important factor for a good diamond. I remembered someone mentioned that "Cut is King", and I totally agree with that. No matter how big or how clear your diamond is, if it don't sparkle or shine brilliantly, it is not a perfect diamond for me.

Now, after all the above, I have now set my new minimum for a diamond; Cut has to be perfect, around 0.4 carat (+/-), clarity SI1 and colour G with budget >RM7k (including the ring). I am not sure if I can be getting this with this kind of budget. So far, I know Le Lumiere has the closest but with lesser carat (GIA 5256615959) and color (GIA 7261392761). Both are RM6688 and RM6388 respectively. Love&co, the specs might be lower if not mistaken but compared with Le Lumiere I saw, the diamond performance are better than Love&co; sparkles more brightly. Another option is to go for diamond and ring separately (like in Wah Chan). I looked for JannPaul and Brian Gavin; I have to say their diamond looks amazing (thou by picture and videos only) and it fulfill my requirements of good cut (Hearts and Arrows).

Here begins my headache moments. Although my gf once told me to decide on the diamond ring, I am unsure if I should go for those ready made well-known diamond ring brand (like Love&co, Hemera, Le Lumiere and etc) or should I go for those customize diamond and ring (like Brian Gavin, Audrey, Wah Chan, JannPaul and etc). Ladies and guys thinking may be a bit different you see... guys are more to technical stuff than just looking at brand (specs, performance, etc) while ladies usually go for brand (Tiff&co, Love&co, etc).

Any opinion or suggestion based on the above? If I were to order those diamonds from Brian Gavin for example, you think it can fit my budget and enough time to do the setting as well? Thought of JannPaul too but I don't know if can fit my budget as well. Worry if I go SG then end up with failure. Hope all the sifu here can give me some guidance.   
**Sorry to keep this one so long. I just hope my scenario here can help others as well when comes to decide on the proposal ring** 

Aww thanks for the great detail recommendations. Will look into all these beauty...

However, jsut now went to Wah Chan. Found out their price is better compare with Goldheart and D&P. But then I see few pcs of arrows not really clear. eg. 0.31ct, E, SI1 with ring about 5k+.

Pic lehhh