my hyundai lcd is also the same packaging...lcd is held by 2 blocks of foam at the side with some other foam to hold the wire...the lcd screen is also unprotected , got empty space in the middle, so anything that pierce through the box will go directly to the screen if deep enough..the lcd is wrap with plastic bag only, not even bubble wrap or something..bought from shop none the less

got experience also from poslaju, both packages are pierce with some stuff but luckily no damage, just a heatsink and fan controller, didnt notice the damage until i open it only saw the hole as the pierce is at bottom of the boxes

for this topic: my vote goes to the seller as he did mention he is not responsible for the posting damage, he even return the profit he made..cant say much but that practice i had seen alot from online trading, usually either the seller force you to buy shipping insurance or the buyer request better shipping /insurance policy by paying more