Any confirmation plan from government to extend the MRT to Cyberjaya?

pls check this domain website.

http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.p...315795&page=114


http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.p...102128&page=215

This post has been edited by tikaram: Apr 8 2013, 03:16 PM

maybe putrajaya also?

in the realier plan, there is none.

As I mentioned there, there is a plan. Still study.

Because Subang/Shah Alam ppl shud be given priority or not? Go there or go Cyber?

As of i now, there is no concrete confirmation on Cyber MRT..

However Map Guru HCS speculate that line to Putra/Cyber will be line 3, but line 3 only ends at Putrajaya ERL station.. He speculated that feeder bus will be used to ferry passengers from station to the rest of destination.. Maybe no MRT station at door step of some commercial area in Cyber..

although i dont like it...but i still dont think it will have MRT in Cyber within the first 3 lines , by the way, expect at least 6-8 years for that to be realized.

+1

Why want to build MRT instead of LRT to increase the cost of construction? Not necessary to do that..

bro, how much different between building MRT and LRT?

Yeah, i think that is not much difference for the construction cost compare in between LRT and MRT.....unless they goes underground, which i don't think is possible and feasible to have underground MRT/LRT project in cyberjaya....

Construction cost for floor carpark or basement carpark which one more costly?

Construction cost of MRT such as drilling, retaining wall..more costly than LRT

This post has been edited by 37 Exposures: Apr 10 2013, 06:04 PM

We need MRT more than LRT. MRT higher Capacity compare to LRT.
you can see almost everything from here:

http://www.spad.gov.my/sites/default/files...110913-v1.0.pdf

page 45 and page 46

mrt to cyberjaya/putrajaya is after 2020....still long long way to go.

fyi, some people always try to compare the cost of MRT with bullet train..totally different thing...1 of the different is MRT need many many stations.
bullet train need a few stations. example from penang to singapore in-between maybe only 4 to 5 stops/stations.

This post has been edited by HELLO HELLO: Apr 10 2013, 02:22 PM

Personally think that next MRT project will be in Penang Island or JB instead of CBJ..these two places need MRT more than CBJ

MRT is needed... Malaysia is now regretting that it built the Kelana Jaya Line on a LRT instead of MRT.

In the future traffic growth, KJ Line cannot be expanded anymore. Sad. Short sighted.

Wau, after 2020? in this case, since I was working in Pee Jay, then i think is a bit hard for me to travel from Cyberjaya to Pee Jay, as too tiring and quite jam LDP....

Yeah, in fact, i think MRT is more feasible to be implemented in Penang, instead of constructing Monorail in Penang, which is not feasible at all, due to a numbers of factors too....

What to do bro? this is how our government working now...They are short-sighted and incapable, and yet, they will never admit for their mistake.....

Hope this time all Malaysians can use their rights to cast a better formation of government for the sake of Malaysian brilliant future....

i agree with Accetera,, we should hav MRT in the 1st place,,,
The LRT extension for Ampang n Kelana line is just the next best solution,,
for new line, MRT is the way to go, n glad they took the step

Cyber already has erl....st to kl sentral..why need mrt? Within ciber u hav dedicated shuttle bus or feeder bus system..no jam whoa

This post has been edited by propertybbb: Apr 10 2013, 08:15 PM

It make no sense to build MRT for a city with total population of less than 10k.

Maybe such an idea will be proposed by the Pakatan Rakyat, given they are going to spend RM8billion to solve traffic issue in Penang.

You will soon to understand that they can't govern this country any better. Vote wisely.

As for Greater KL, MRT is definitely the way to go regardless who rules the Govt. As of now, SPAD is already focusing on MRT planning.

Any lines more than 30km would have sufficient capacity required by a MRT system. Bear in mind, we can have 3 or 4 cars on a MRT before extending it further, but the idea is that the girder, the guideway, the stations and planning of infrastructure must be built for future.

Similar problems we now encouter with KL Monorail where the extension is being done because the Monorail has reached overcapacity. But the extension is facing difficulties now. If it was me, the line could be a LRT in the first place if we foresaw the traffic today.

LRT should be put as communal rail such as connecting Kelana Jaya to Bandar Utama and to Bandar Sri Damansara.

OK maybe you can follow @Kampung on public transportation issues.

This post has been edited by accetera: Apr 10 2013, 09:49 PM

What I mean is not to implement an independent MRT system solely for Cyberjaya and Putrajaya, only the madness will implement it....What I mean is if there is any possibility for the MRT line 3 to connect their last station to Serdang up tp Cyberjaya / Putrajaya, which I am personally think it is feasible to do so....

For any government wish to develop Cyberjaya, the connectivity from CYberjaya to KL and PJ area is really important in order to boast up the surrounding area property value. It won't be necessary to have standalone MRT system just for Cyberjaya, but it is good to connect Cyberjaya through MRT line via Serdang / Puchong to other places, this is definitely feasible to do so if you refer to the MRT model in Singapore and MTR model in Hong Kong.

However, this is just my 2 cents opinion....

Yeah, I do agreed in your opinion. Sometimes we have to be plan ahead for future. Perhaps when in 2020, more population in Cyberjaya, that time the government thought have a serious consideration to link MRT to cyberjaya, to promote usage of public transportation. Its a pain to implement now, but i think it is no harm to have a pre-planning for the future.

Planning ahead is always cheaper than we plan in the future.

Totally agree that there is no need for additional MRT/LRT, given the fact there is already the existing ERL, in the distant future maybe, but certainly not in the next few years. As long as they have a good feeder bus system to the ERL station, that should be more than sufficient.

Just does not make economic sense to add a MRT/LRT line now. The only recent why there is the ERL is because KLIA is the 14th busiest airport in the world and it handled almost 40,000,000 passengers last year. Yeap, that's 40 million passengers.

Even if Cyberjaya reaches the population of 100,000, I don't think so it's enough to justify the need for MRT/LRT.

Old Klang Road TODAY has a population of 270,000 and that is one of the many reasons needed for it to be included in the study and research for the proposed MRT 2. Apparently, one of our ministers made a big 'hu ha' that it won't be going through Old Klang Road but Pantai Dalam instead.

As much as I like Cyberjaya (heck, I even bought a property there!!!), really don't see the MRT/LRT coming anytime soon.

BRT will do.

Poor planning is all bcoz of our current government.

mission impossible to have mrt in ciberjaya.

This post has been edited by worgen: Apr 11 2013, 08:49 PM

If they build an MRT to Cyberjaya, The ridership of ERL will drop significantly.
By right, there should be an MRT to Cyberjaya. Afterall, I thought the govt was trying to promote it as an MSC to attract multinationals.

sg buloh - kajang havent finished now start cyberjaya MRT?

agree

Now there are talks of the 2nd and 3rd line of LRT feasibility studies that are underway, and will be done by year end. One is from East to West (Cheras to Klang) while the other is for North to South.

This just in

The Edge : Cyberjaya stakeholders lobbying for MRT connectivity

too much POWER at the Putrajaya Cyberjaya! ..everything will go ON here!

Hi, all brothers and sisters, another brand new project and brand new phase in open for register now, absolutely one of a cheapest project in Cyberjaya smile.gif PM me for more details smile.gif

still a long long way to go man...could be more than 10 years time from now and after taken into consideration of the economic cycle that recession would be around 2019..

This post has been edited by HighwayCruiser: Sep 27 2014, 07:47 PM

Too many n hard to sell mah. Need something to fire up. But nothing special to sell. Only left future mrt liao. After 3 years VP get the house. Jialat mrt need to wait another 10 years. Economy shit Liao. Macam lrt2 delay another 10 years.sibeh jialat.

How much psf? Only if anything below 500psf thn only u can claim its the cheapest. Otherwise u are spamming. Pls clarify.

it's Mutiara Ville phase 3 la.
really below 500psf.

Ya, it's really below RM 500psf, please call me Lawrence 012-6326907 for more details

No problem lah having MRT to Cyberjaya. But maybe should connect further to places like Dengkil and Banting.

Think about the London tube connection. It is like a century old now, but its connectivity is like spiderweb. Can go almost anywhere around London and its surrounding.

No harm to do that. But prioritise the densely populated areas like Shah Alam, PJ, Setia Alam and maybe Bukit Jelutong and Puncak Alam. Oh don't forget Semenyih, Beranang all the way to Seremban too!

finish up with the lrt and mrt first before going to Cyberjaya la..
most of the property buyer are investor. If nobody move in cyberjaya after majority project VP, waste of resources building MRT there. at least wait couple of years, maybe 5-10 years.

This is forever the chicken and egg situation. If the MRT were there, the chances of people moving in would definitely increase by a lot.

Forget about it first. Better dont expect anything. If it comes then jus tret it as bonus.

using your logic, places like Semenyih, Beranang, Dengkil, Kuala Selangor are highly populated. Building an MRT there are not waste of resources. No?

Dont think they will run an MRT here for next 5-10 years. yes sure u need to plan ahead but if number of people who use the facilities cant break even, how to survive?

cyberjaya mrt - Stage 2 Opening 2022

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MRT_Sungai_Bu...-Putrajaya_Line

good thinking mang

Some of my friends and I have bought few units in Cyberjaya in between 2010 - 2012 and we did not look back after that. It booms as we expected.

Back then the naysayers were telling us, having a public transportation connecting there is 10% percent chance,

Cyberjaya and Putrajaya are the intelligent city, how can the government not make it intelligent and not connecting it with public transportation is beyond our understandings. Different people see things differently i would say. At the end of the day, our positive thinkings and perception just bear fruits. some of us have laughed our money to the bank already.

Anyway, for people to make money and enjoy fresh air, the next hot spot is Dengkil further south of Cyberjaya. Come at one point, Cyberjaya/Putrajaya will be just like KL we see today. I just hope it won't happen so soon because we want enjoy the free congestion and convenience here now.

MRT start when ?

it's not only already confirmed but start building.. 2022...not one but 2 stations... so good luck for those who waited and see...

dengkil can be developed as farm city ... as infrastructure not so sophisticated and advanced...there is lack of govt effort to improve that... it all depends on individual developers