It's very hard to compare if there are many "IF", past tense against future tense and all of SP Setia, Perdana Parkcity and Berjaya Land have very much different company aspects, missions and visions, corporate planning and influence and much more.
SP Setia is the property dev taikor in Msia, very much to the support from the government and they are more to big township planner in such manner.
Perdana Parkcity took a very respective risky move on a 400+ acres ex-mining land purchased back then, where the first 5 land company prospects viewed it and seem the land was not so ideal for development until Perdana Parkcity with the support of a huge group of investors and hence, the idea of parkhomes was introduced into a niche market of Kepong area with a double pricing compare to landed in Kepong or Manjalara area, people were argued you were crazy if you buy it for investment, but those older people who said this about 6-10 years back got to swallow back their words now. The concentration on Desa Parkcity alone made a fruitful journey for the developer and as well as early investors and buyers as well.
Berjaya is not a kind of SP Setia's vision definitely and not as top as them in terms of property township planning. It might due to Berjaya had much more investments and planning compare to their corporate property division which can give more reputation and profile to the company coupled with faster and bigger profit compare to township development.
They hold majority of the BJ land but if they owned 90% or majority one large plot and concentrating the property development with good and great masterplan, also would bring different story. Don't forget Ho Hup and Huatland both developed at BJ too as well as Malton is coming on this year end for it's Jalil Integrated City.
But I see the current BJ of Jalan Jalil Perkasa 1 side, is transforming well in the past 1-2 years ( we can see the commercial at The Link had started to do well after vacant for about 1-2 years and interchanged of Kesas Highway helped a lot few years back ) and I see with the addition of the latest series of medium higher end and high end condos, catalyst of mixed commercial development by WCT Mall, Ho Hup & Malton's Jalil City and Berjaya itself could transform BJ into bigger league area in the next 5 years and another wave in another 10 years.
They hold majority of the BJ land but if they owned 90% or majority one large plot and concentrating the property development with good and great masterplan...
TQVM. Agreed that it is hard to compare.