Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Volkswagen Cars Discussion : Powered by V6!, Das Auto!

views
     
K5WHITE
post Aug 30 2012, 07:04 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
92 posts

Joined: Mar 2012
QUOTE(zweimmk @ Aug 30 2012, 03:23 PM)
Yeah I agree. But hey, at least the price is pretty damn good for what I had to pay for my car. Easy choice between a Japu marque or Conti car at the same price point. Doubtful I would ever go back Japu again after this.
*
im happy for u so far had such good experience on ur new passat. I used to be strictly jap only, and specifically honda. From old bullet civic to city, to civic fd2, crv, and recently looking for d-segment, and chose K5 instead. Planning to change my wife fd2, thinking abt wanna try conti feel. tried few times passat, jetta, polo. but no doubt, the car handling tops jap/korean anytime, but my biggest worry is the overall ownership experience.

service wise, parts reliability. How is it? Heard such as ECU burnt, but what's the percentage like?

FC from wat i hear from u guys, is at the good side. no concern there. I even have a close fren who own a jetta, and i tried many times already. He got somewhere 11c/km shah alam sg buloh everyday ~150km/hr
I know, no car is perfect, and im not looking for one. Just need to get the balance.

my immediate choice will be golf, but wife dont like hatch, but actually i wanted to tell her, im choosing, not her.
Jetta, she hates the interior. Passat she likes. I Tot abt mondeo too.

Wat u guys think abt overall ownership of VW in msia?

K5WHITE
post Sep 1 2012, 10:16 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
92 posts

Joined: Mar 2012
QUOTE(zweimmk @ Sep 1 2012, 09:39 AM)
I dunno if I'm the best person to ask in regards to servicing a VW as I haven't done my first service yet. But so far, there's no hitches with our other Typ 6R Polo TSI which my family owns for the past year or so. Then again that car has less than 15k mileage on it even after 1 year+ of ownership so again, not your typical VW owner.

FC can range from very good to bad depending on how ridiculously you try to drive the car. LOL! Heavy footers and torque lovers will no doubt kill the FC of these cars quite easily.

So far I'm happy with my car and to be frank, when I drove my wife's new Civic for the past 2 days, the immediate thought was.... damn this car is slow. At the same time, the suspension also feels softer and more comfortable over bumps compared to continentals. But at the end of the day though, it is very highly unlikely I will ever buy another Japu or Kimchi car ever again. Once you tasted the power and torque of turbocharged cars, there's no going back  drool.gif

So if you do buy your wife a Passat or Golf etc, my advise is don't drive them too much or you might not want to go back to your K5 again. The driving pleasure is just miles and miles ahead of the Jap/Kor cars
*
earlier, was looking for d-segment when passat was still cbu germany, and have torrid time selecting it. Then decided to NOT overspend on car hence the 140k K5 (48k difference). Needed the d-segment for space to have comfortable cabin room to ferry 4 adults and a baby seat. Now that my house fd2 has clocked over 100k km odo, and 5 years old, thinking of replacing it with something agile, and conti, hence the golf. But now that passat ckd has got the price slashed 15k, had me thinking again. Golf and passat not much difference, rite?
K5WHITE
post Sep 1 2012, 11:34 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
92 posts

Joined: Mar 2012
QUOTE(zweimmk @ Sep 1 2012, 10:47 AM)
Actually, we had a bit of a loan issue with our new FB Civic and the car was delayed for well over a month because of it. The reason was so stupid that I seriously contemplated switching over to the new Beetle instead. Had it been delayed for another week or 2, I would have just cancelled and bought the new Beetle instead.

1. It's the new beetle, it looks chic and stylish. Even guy driving it won't look funny this time round.
2. It's turbocharged, the 1.2 TSI will be good enough for daily commuting purposes
3. My family and baby will use the Passat for shopping or outstation, so the Beetle will be the fun car a quick weekend get away.

Anyway, wife decided not to change and the new Civic did arrive just before Merdeka. But actually, our case is exactly the same. So if I were you, the golf or beetle would be good choices but ultimately, it's up to your wife. Right now, we have 2 sedans and the feeling is somewhat... meh! The only good thing about it is I can save on mileage for the Passat and drive the Civic every now and then.
*
exactly ! tot of golf for quick trip to gym, and k5 for family trip to cameron

although i know k5/jap 2.0 NA will be seriously underpower to climb cameron with full load of passengers and who knows what at the trunk, but during family trip will be 110km/hr kinda travel

This post has been edited by K5WHITE: Sep 1 2012, 12:38 PM
K5WHITE
post Oct 23 2012, 05:17 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
92 posts

Joined: Mar 2012
QUOTE(IluvProton @ Oct 21 2012, 02:16 PM)
test drive Passat CKD. Driving seat everything quite tighter than camry. Which I like. Confirm more silent than K5 (hope no K5 ppl see this)

Impressive
- pick up is the best among K5, Camry, Accord and etc
- sound proof is good110km/h speed at highway still like 60km/h
- HUGE boot, yes.... I think can fit 2 of me inside. CM98 was quote he see not that diff with K5.... is OBVIOUS BIG BIG ! even bigger than camry 2006
- Air cond circulation are much better in conti.

Problem
- the back trunk got sound knocking when you drive thru hard bump.
- Passanger side, cover box open lid can't open fully with you sitting on the passanger side.


Findings
- now the SA said no more 3+2 warranty. Is all 5 years unlimited coverage. Anyone can confirm this?
- Run flat tyres (which make the car noisy but ... helll this tyre cost 1.2k each) WHY NOT? please confirm if is runflat also? 1st time only I heard.
- Back seat is superb long base. I'm not a tall person but .... still got 1 1/2 ft from front seat.
- headroom behind not too good when you resting. about 2-3 inch left. I'm 5'6" only.

Summary:
If you want a D segment car. lowest are around 147k. why not fork out another 20k? not much diff for repayment but huge diff in driving.

Please comment if there any correction. Thanks you
*
haha...u dont have to generalize whole of k5 owners anyway

back to ur review, i agree that passat has better pick up from its supercharged engine and DSG tranny. K5 is lagging in this sector, same goes with all 2.0 teana, camry and akod. Usually conti cars has better insulation and passat again has proved it. Been into passat, akod, k5 and previous camry, must say passat has the solid built feel when cruising at highway. Boot size, i believe it (wat cm98 said) is true, there aint much difference between k5 and passat. Maybe passat has deeper boot, but k5 has wider storage. Overall, again, i felt both have abt same boot size.

Cabin size, i feel k5 has among the biggest rear leg room. Im 6', and while i sitting with comfy seat extension at the front, rear sitting has no constraint watsoever. But i believe passat is not far from it. Even akod can match k5 in this area. Head room, i still got abt 2~3" left, and havent experienced any head knocking while trying to estimate front bumper whilst parking (ala head protrude out parking style driving).

abt the price, currently k5 is 139k and passat at 170k both listed price non-otr. Thats 30k difference. Some can live with it, some consider it savings.

nonetheless, i think passat is a good car, a good alternative than just T&H dsegment cars.

This post has been edited by K5WHITE: Oct 23 2012, 05:18 PM
K5WHITE
post Oct 25 2012, 01:25 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
92 posts

Joined: Mar 2012
QUOTE(eddychstu @ Oct 25 2012, 11:30 AM)
If you were given a choice to choose again, which one would you go for?

Polo GTI - RM169,888
Passat Sport - RM190,967

Both having good year end promotion and i'm having a hard time to choose, hope someone can knocked me with some good senses and solve this damn dilemma.

Here's a simple scored card from myself.
Design: Polo GTI
Feature: Passat Sport
Value for $$: Polo Sport (after discount)
Space: Passat Sport
Driving experience: Polo GTI (Fun Factor)
Reliability: Passat Sport
Maintainability: Passat sport
Resell value: Polo Sport

Would like to hear it from the bros here, Many thanks!
*
gosh, dont u guys think vw pricing abit rclxub.gif

a polo gti 20k (10.5%) less than passat sports?
and wats polo gti v passat ckd difference then?

a small hatch v d segment?
K5WHITE
post Oct 26 2012, 09:23 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
92 posts

Joined: Mar 2012
QUOTE(Mavik @ Oct 26 2012, 08:03 AM)
Its a pocket rocket versus a family sedan. Both to suit different markets. Initial pricing (PGTI was less than RM140k) was spot on IMHO but thanks to the new tax revision, VW go screwed over here in Malaysia.
*
yeah, i knew of the price hike. Thats my point, they increase the price to almost same as their own d-segment car. Well, heck, they can even comapre with their own c-segment(jetta) since they use the same engine to have a closer look. I knew abt the passat cc increase last time ard, but for this polo gti, its kinda irrelevant.
K5WHITE
post Oct 27 2012, 04:21 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
92 posts

Joined: Mar 2012
QUOTE(Boy96 @ Oct 27 2012, 04:02 PM)
hmm. But my mom do prioritize Resale Value.. so passat has a plus point here.

Comparing the K5 and Passat Sport. Not the normal ones.. The sport do have auto fold side mirror (this one should be standard in all cars now).

We use the car mainly for 100% city drive.. maybe go outstation 3-4times a year..
Most importantly, want a car that has a rattle free cabin, no squeak squeak noise. etc etc...
*
i think u shud get camry. It suits ur req to the exact
1. resale value
2. no rattle or good nvh

Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0204sec    0.46    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 8th December 2025 - 09:37 PM