I would score it a 9 instead of a 9.5.

The current itemization means you GOT to go play the (RM)AH in order to continue. Legendaries weaker than Rares are also a bummer. (it's a legendary, something to brag about).

"Dumbed down" skill system doesn't affect me as much since one less spreadsheet to care about. Though, most of the time, we are pigeonholed to primary stat + vitality.

Storywise, it could be better, but as compelling as the previous games though. But because of the itemization, I would give it a 9 out of 10.