Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Working in Australia, Experiences working in Australia.

views
     
tester
post Dec 31 2011, 12:08 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
379 posts

Joined: Sep 2004


The bottom line is, if you are really good at what you're doing, and those skills are in demand, then it will be relatively easy for you to survive in Australia, for there will be tough competition from other highly skilled, local or international workers.

Having said that, there are a few aspects that are way better than in Malaysia:
- education: rest assured, your children will be getting quality education and better access to world-leading universities.

- safety: it is much much safer to walk on the streets here at night (of course there are still places one should avoid) than in many major cities in Malaysia. Unlike Malaysia, police actually respond to calls and protect the people.

- people's mentality: in large cities, people are generally more 'civilised' in manner. The younger generations actually abhor racial prejudice, a problem still rampant among many Malaysians. Racial harmony is way better than Malaysia anyday.

- equality: No more discrimination from your own government, no more second-class citizen treatment. If you have PR then you basically get the same rights as the Australians.

This post has been edited by tester: Dec 31 2011, 12:11 AM
tester
post Jan 12 2012, 12:18 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
379 posts

Joined: Sep 2004


Replies in blue smile.gif
QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 11 2012, 10:50 PM)
The bottom line is, if you are really good at what you're doing, and those skills are in demand, then it will be relatively easy for you to survive in Australia, for there will be tough competition from other highly skilled, local or international workers.
Wouldn't it be tougher to survive instead? Since there is tough competition from other highly skilled local or international workers, some willing to work for less?
Don't really get you there... if you are really good at what you're doing, then you stand a chance to compete with other skilled workers there, compared to those that aren't. Also for those graduated from Australian institutions or on temporary visas, if they perform well then it's relatively common for the employer to want to sponsor them PR visas.

Having said that, there are a few aspects that are way better than in Malaysia:
- education: rest assured, your children will be getting quality education and better access to world-leading universities.
Yes better education i agree. But I find that 2nd generation Australian immigrant are rather lazy unlike the first generation. Maybe it's because of the laid back culture. I don't like my kids to be lazy or laid back like the aussies
What does laziness has to do with education here? Yes I agree the culture is rather laid back, but to say that there are no hard working Aussies is simply not true. After all, there are certain fields that Australia is extremely competitive at, together with world-leading institutions spearheading these efforts. Laziness has more to do with personal motivation rather than the education system.

On the other hand, speaking of education quality, it is unfortunate that in Malaysia we are still resorting to rote learning (myself a victim of it) but doing my degree and postgrad in Australia really changed the way I approach problem-solving, a very useful skill in the real world. Also, getting access to prestigious institutions can open up so much more opportunities, and I mean not just the qualifications, but opportunities to build networks and form connections with well-known people in your field (or people who have connection with those big shots), simply for the fact that they are much more likely to be in/visit Australia than Malaysia/know someone in Australia (personal experience here). And these can be of tremendous advantage for one to advance their career. Now this is the kind of environment that I want my children to grow up in.


- safety: it is much much safer to walk on the streets here at night (of course there are still places one should avoid) than in many major cities in Malaysia. Unlike Malaysia, police actually respond to calls and protect the people.
Generally agree. However there are also very dangerous place for anyone, let alone asians to be walking in the night
No argument there, some places are very dangerous even for the locals themselves.

- people's mentality: in large cities, people are generally more 'civilised' in manner. The younger generations actually abhor racial prejudice, a problem still rampant among many Malaysians. Racial harmony is way better than Malaysia anyday.
This one disagree. They don't do racial discrimination outright i.e. in your face but they do it subtlely like rejecting CV with any form of asian names, asian being overlooked for promotion, etc.

Yes, discrimination happens everywhere, you probably won't get a job just because the employer doesn't like the way you look, doesn't like your hair colour, doesn't like your less-than-perfect English, doesn't like that typo mistake on your resume, doesn't like the way you speak etc.. These discriminations are down to the employer's personal preference. More often than not, your ability to communicate in English and your qualifications play the decisive factor. (Funny enough I heard that someone claimed to have been rejected because of his "weird" name and he's a white guy.)

However, so often you hear from Asians that play the victim mentality whenever they get rejected from a job, and this is getting old really. "They must have rejected me cos I'm Asian!" Yes, the greatest cop out, the easiest excuse for one NOT to up their own game, and blame the race instead. If so, we would've seen the locals all holding senior positions while the immigrants all do the lowly jobs. Unfortunately this is not true, I have seen many Asians holding top-tier positions in respectable companies, and many international students getting employed by well-known corporations and consulting firms (some even without a PR, which makes your life way harder in landing a job!)

However, my original point was about racial harmony in Australia, which I have to say is far better than in Malaysia. I highly doubt people who make that kind of statement have actually put in the effort and live with the Aussies. Go out with an open mind and actually mingle with them, respect their values, make friends with them, live with them, and you will find many of them very accepting and tolerant.

- equality: No more discrimination from your own government, no more second-class citizen treatment. If you have PR then you basically get the same rights as the Australians.
PR = No Vote. The gov don't discriminate like Malaysia do agaisnt their own citizen, but they are slowly taking away benefits for PR like subsidised housing and education. PR pays more than citizen although less than foreigner
Since when do PR get to vote in any other country? (OK maybe except for NZ)

What subsidised housing? Do you mean the public housing for those low-income earners? Actually, PR are entitled to it, just that you need to wait 2 years before you can get Centrelink benefits. And if you are in so much trouble within 2 years of landing a PR, then you probably don't deserve a PR in the first place..

Education? PR get the same benefits as citizens to go to public schools, although many affordable people send their children to private schools anyway. Also, PR are entitled to HECS/CSP, just that they cannot defer the HECS loan unlike citizens, which makes perfect sense to me. And this only applies if your children have just been granted PR status. If your child is born in Australia, then he/she is already an Australian citizen.

*
This post has been edited by tester: Jan 12 2012, 12:26 PM
tester
post Jan 13 2012, 05:54 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
379 posts

Joined: Sep 2004


QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 12 2012, 10:20 PM)
Making assumptions about me eh?
Even if you have a english name and can "fool" the aussie, how are you going to "fool" him during interview?
Paint yourself white?
*
You "fool" your potential employers with your impressive qualifications, with your superior intellectual capacity, with your excellent communication skill (preferably with impeccable English), with the invaluable expertise and experience that you can bring to the company and with positive attitude and motivation.

If you think a job interview is about race then you've got it all wrong then!

The largest barrier you're going to face in Australia is perhaps the lack of a PR visa, which makes many employers hesitant to hire you. However, being really good at what you're doing (preferably with your skills in demand and having an Australian qualification and of course, excellent grades) and an excellent communicator can substantially improve your chances of getting hired.


Added on January 13, 2012, 6:15 pm
QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 12 2012, 10:59 PM)
How is Aus a better place compared to SG?
*
Let's not turn this into the Australia vs Singapore thread as I find it extremely naive for one to judge which country is "better" based on generalisations alone.

I am certain that Singapore is a great country with many career opportunities. However as others have said, these are two very different countries. Many factors go into play here, eg. career growth and prospect, the specific skill sets you have, the saturation of workforce in your field, work/life culture, long-term expectations (many people migrate to Australia primarily for the sake of their children's future) etc.

Having said that, I'm not going to compare Australia with Singapore as I have not lived in the latter, but the misconception regarding Australia here warrants some clarification.

QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 12 2012, 10:59 PM)
1) SG welcomes foreigners especially Chinese Malaysian - Aus, not really a welcome foreigner kind of place with its tight immigration law.
2) Easy to get PR/Citizen - None of that point based sh1t or "tightening of immigration laws" happening every year in Aus.
*
Tight immigration law thanks to the people who exploited the system over the years. Gone were the days where taking a hairdressing course makes you an eligible PR. Now they prefer someone who bring certain expertise and skill sets that are in demand. (Although I don't like some of the stupid rules set by policy makers who don't really know what they're doing, I'd rather it tighter than bring in people who actually can't contribute much)

QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 12 2012, 10:59 PM)
3) No discrimination. Actually most com in SG prefer to employ Malaysian since MOST can speak good English, Mandarin and Malay (3 main language of SG). - Aus prefer caucasion Australian or UK/American/European not so much Asian, unless you work in an Asian firm. Def mentioned there are lots of Asian holding high ranking position, but how many in terms of % compared to caucasion? Ans: very few if compared to Caucasion.
*
You obviously have no idea what you're talking about. I wonder which part of Australia have you been living in? My guess is that you never lived here at all.

Asian firms? You mean the Big 4 like KPMG? Engineering firms like Motorola and IBM? Seriously, in the financial sector, especially in the Big 4, Asians (both locals and immigrants) make up as many as 50% of the workforce there! So are the major engineering firms where you'd be surprised if you don't see half of them are immigrants from East Asia, India or the Middle East. And yes, many of them made it to the managerial levels, although non-native English speakers can have a hard time going further up (director and above), but that doesn't mean they are not there.

Just to pull a random example (in fact, so random that I don't know how it came to my mind), the past president of Australian Computer Society (ACS) was a Chinese, and the one before him an Indian.

If we're talking about the really high level position eg. directors/CEOs, remember that Australia is a 90% Caucasian country, and the majority of Asian immigrants have only been here since the 90s, it's more of a demographic problem rather than discrimination (although I will not deny discrimination does happen, so is everywhere else). Also at this level it's more about political ties and nepotism rather than your skills (which also happens in many other places), though you can still find some first-generation immigrants with exceptional credentials made it there. Similarly, most of the local Australians will never make it to this level in their lifetime.

QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 12 2012, 10:59 PM)
4) Low tax. - Aus Super high tax....as high at 30-40% of total package.
*
I don't know about Singapore but I'm all for social democratic policies. You pay your tax which in turn is invested in education, healthcare, infrastructure, social welfare and contribution to the community.

QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 12 2012, 10:59 PM)
5) Safety. - Aus not as safe as SG
*
I'm sure Singapore is a very safe country to live in. In regard to Australia, cities such as Melbourne/Sydney are also some of the safest places to live in. I don't think there are much differences there.

(Disclaimer: Crime does happen, no matter where you live, so individual experience may differ.)

QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 12 2012, 10:59 PM)
6) Career prospects. -Many Regional HQ are in SG - Aus, Not many only Aus based company has HQ in Australia.
*
Don't know about this one. Very much dependent on your field, your expertise and your expectations.

QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 12 2012, 10:59 PM)
So the question is why go to a place that don't welcome you in the first place? (especially if you are thinking of "finding" a job there and not a PR yet)
*
It is exactly this sort of mindset that has baffled me for a long time. If you think people out there are always discriminating you based on your race, then it makes you no different than a racist, actually. I've heard that Asian immigrants are even more racist than the white people, and now I tend to believe this may perhaps be true after all. "If I didn't get anything I want, then it must be because of my race!" (ironically applicable to Malaysia though, because racism is institutionalised and openly practised by the government) Sadly I've seen many immigrants playing this sort of victim mentality (inferiority complex?). Attitude like this actually reminds me of people that always lay the blame on other people, it's NEVER their fault or inadequacy.

Not to mention that your preconception about "people not welcoming you" is completely wrong. If they don't welcome you, probably because they see nothing valuable in you (no offence, some skills may have been saturated), but to say it's race just proves that you never have lived here and integrate with the local society.

Judging from your other posts here, you seem to have problem with white people... what's wrong with them actually? I actually find them more friendly than many Asians, who tend to give you some WTF look when you approach them.


This post has been edited by tester: Jan 13 2012, 06:15 PM
tester
post Jan 15 2012, 12:10 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
379 posts

Joined: Sep 2004


QUOTE(White Knight @ Jan 15 2012, 02:05 AM)
mercury8400, I have been absent for more than 2 months now. I just saw your reply to my comments. It seems that you cannot accept that whatever you post so far are all stupid post and baseless. I have provided you with the relevant links & comments which are more than sufficient to quash or invalidate all your posts. Go & read thru again all my previous comments & links. If you still come back with all your stupid comments to argue, then either your English is just too poor or you're completely a moron.
On the other hand if you want to upgrade yourself to become a Moron master, then you can post more comments with all the 'colourful' bad words like you always do. I am eagerly waiting for your reply with all your colourful bad words & we can celebrate your new status as Moron King. I wonder with your personality, you're just any small fries in your company with your employer has no confidence at all with your work. That's why this LYN is a right place for you to shout like a complete moron.

Hope I am not too long winded, go & read thru again all my previous posts & links. I have provided sufficient evidence to invalidate all your immature & stupid post.
*
I just read his earlier replies posted a few months back.

With this kind of attitude no wonder he always feel like he was being racially discriminated, and that he was not welcomed in Australia. It has nothing to do with his race, nobody likes an arsehole, period.

tester
post Jan 17 2012, 01:09 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
379 posts

Joined: Sep 2004


QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 16 2012, 05:38 PM)
I've studied in Aus for 3 years and worked for 3 in a very respectable Bank in Aus. I know what I saw and I know what i've been through. All the Asian in my batch has left due to similar reason.
*
I agree with Def on this: perhaps you could enlighten us on how you managed to work for 3 years in a very respectable bank without a PR?

I would take your "Australian experience" with a grain of salt before you offer a satisfying explanation.

QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 16 2012, 05:38 PM)
I'm just telling those who have NOT been to Aus to NOT be swayed by sweet talks of all the Pros of living in Aus. In other words I'm giving you an alternative view from all the non-sense some forumers spew without working in Aus or just because few were lucky enough to land a "good" job.
*
Somehow you conveniently ignored (even disagreed) with my point that you have to be VERY good to survive decently in Australia, which was the crux of my initial post. If you are more on the mediocre side and has nothing valuable to offer, then of course you are going to struggle.

tester
post Jan 17 2012, 04:12 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
379 posts

Joined: Sep 2004


Replies in blue.
QUOTE(mercury8400 @ Jan 17 2012, 09:46 AM)
I agree with Def on this: perhaps you could enlighten us on how you managed to work for 3 years in a very respectable bank without a PR?
What makes you think I don't have one?
What makes me think you don't have one?

Your lack of understanding and incorrect statements regarding Australian PR conditions and rights.
I find it hard to believe that someone who had been granted a PR can spill out so much nonsense.


I would take your "Australian experience" with a grain of salt before you offer a satisfying explanation.
Somehow you conveniently ignored (even disagreed) with my point that you have to be VERY good to survive decently in Australia, which was the crux of my initial post. If you are more on the mediocre side and has nothing valuable to offer, then of course you are going to struggle.
Why should I be explaining to you, who are so stubborn and absolutely refuse to accept any contradictory view? Like I said, if people like you think Aus is your "kingdom of heaven" and anyone who so much as passes a snide remark constitues a personal attack on you, then be my guest. I speak through my experience for the benefit of others, to give a contrarary view on your "kingdom of heaven"....which my not turn out to be any sort of heaven for some.....
Chill dude... go back to my previous posts and read carefully what I have written.

In fact, it will NOT be the heaven for most people, as I have repeated many times.

What I disagreed with you was your claim that you are not welcomed and being discriminated against because of your race, and your attempt to generalise your misfortune to everyone else.

Judging from your earlier posts and your attitude, sorry I have to be blunt: it's not that they do not welcome us, they just don't welcome you.


If you are the absolute BEST at what you do, nobody ever considers Australia a viable destination. Better to go to US.
There are many reasons actually. Pay is one of them, which is why so many Australians who have postdoc'ed in the US and UK came back.

I am GOOD ENOUGH to produce results which EXCEEDS the expectation of my bosses. Which is why he reocmmended me to a job in SG.
If you say so biggrin.gif
*
tester
post Jan 19 2012, 11:29 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
379 posts

Joined: Sep 2004


QUOTE(xander83 @ Jan 19 2012, 10:57 AM)
so if someone is on 457 visa yes the period depending on their contract employment i mean contract employment

so far i know that even a director of sales n food n beverage are on 457 visa sponsored by the companies working on contract basis so i believe that mercury8400 is on contract basis which it shows that he work in 3 different banks probably because he is visa expiring and can be sponsored by the other companies

i assumed that he is working the big 4 banks which my guess most probably he has worked in cba, anz n nab
*
Unlikely on a 457, since it is for the import of workers whose specialised skills cannot be found in Australia.

If he has graduated from an Australian institution, it simply means that Australia is already producing workers with the skills of interest, and therefore can hardly qualify for a 457.

tester
post Apr 19 2012, 05:04 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
379 posts

Joined: Sep 2004


I find it funny that some people think they somehow "deserve" to be hired, as if the employer in Australia has any obligation to hire them, and when that didn't happen, it must be their race that prevents them from getting the job.

To be honest, in a competitive environment, only those who are highly skilled deserve to be employed, and there are many skilled workers in Australia (which is why PR is usually given only to those skills in demand), not to mention that you are also competing with the locals, who have the advantage over you in that without a PR means you can't work for more than two years in the country.


Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0698sec    0.81    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 17th December 2025 - 01:03 PM