QUOTE(Everdying @ May 5 2011, 11:41 AM)
umm...check the results properly.
hmc and pro 1d have the same score.
pro 1d is just placed 2nd cos its more expensive.
True, thats why its better. If you look at the image, seems the HMC has some slight edge too, especially the last pic test.
QUOTE(ifer @ May 5 2011, 11:44 AM)
all 20 pieces are a waste of money
heliopan which apparently have 16 layers of coating perform badly.
some even has the quality of a window glass lol
True, but if one insist on getting one for 'protection', seems like Hoya HMC is a better choice and bang for buck. Budden... I think another website posted the HMC doing poorly, maybe its fake HMC or? no idea, and there're also many versions like UV(0), etc.
Then again, most of the test were done as a test, when go for real shooting, any degration or effects from the filter, the person might not know. As for testing, the current website done a better test than the others tough.
QUOTE(@meno @ May 5 2011, 11:48 AM)
Both the Hoyas score better due to the effectiveness in cutting UV rays.
The ability to cut UV rays will not be as important on digital sensors as compared to the film days.
So i guess no matter how well the UV rays are blocked, it doesn't serve it's purpose.
I'd rather be looking at the amount of Visible light entering as a more accurate judge of which is the best.
Besides, other factors such as flaring has to be taken into consideration as well.
Apart from using it as a protection, i don't really see the need of UV filters.
Don't just see the score of UV rays, take a look at the sample images taken, its clear that why the HMC fared better. As for visible light transmission, sure its more important especially if we'fe talking about lowlight. BUT, if one were to use filter, he/she should know whatever filter he/she plans to use, it will anyhow affect the visible light transsson.
Added on May 5, 2011, 12:08 pmQUOTE(Irbean @ May 5 2011, 11:56 AM)
so which one do you prefer. Hoya MC / Pro1 D or BW XS-Pro
I hope you're not deciding your purchase based on what other prefers...
This post has been edited by Andy214: May 5 2011, 12:08 PM