QUOTE(writesimply @ Jun 2 2010, 09:05 AM)
Your argument here cancels each other out. I wouldn't need an upgradeable because I have a ___ device yet I can't transfer any of the recordings from B.yond to my ____ device to free up the HDD space. Essentially, what I delete will be lost forever and I'm supposed to be happy with that.
Regardless of the percentage of customers that would require an upgradeable PVR, it is another feature that is user-friendly. Most people don't know or care that their DVD player can play DIVX content but at least it's there if/when they need it, just like most laptop owners don't burn lots of DVDs either even though their drives are perfectly capable.
I said that about my 20GB HDD. Then my 80GB HDD. Then my 1TB HDD. Those who have lots of CDs to rip or Tivo-ed content would always want a bigger drive.
I know they said that. They also said that 1) you can't open up the B.yond PVR and upgrade the HDD yourself and 2) you can buy your own WD AV HDD 320GB and activate the recording function. 1 discourages user participation while 2 encourages it, thereby sending conflicting signals. As I said, they should open it up so that users can add whichever HDD they want.
By the way, you can't remotely program your B.yond PVR or B.yond + HDD using the internet. That means if you forgot to do it at home, you better hope Astro repeats the broadcast. They should have put this feature in at launch.
fuad
Hi Fuad,
My points is do we 'techie' really need to keep all these recordings, we value a movie enough that we will buy the bluray or like everyone nowadays, just download unrated bluray rip from the net to be played using our media player. The Astro PVR I see it only as a temporary recording so I can watch later. Things like sports events or news or just several episodes of a series that I miss.
It's not designed to be the media player to keep everything. It would be hell to nagivate thru it. because you can't sort, you can't search and you obviously can't have folders to separate movies according to genre, or series or etc for the time being. Who knows what can Astro do in the future.
As for the External HDD argument, I totally agree with you that they should open it you have valid points however let's give Astro some time to get their act together, no one have done this before. LEt's give them some time yeah..I'm sure in a few weeks/monts they will add more HDD to the "Astro Compatible" list.
To other whi came in late.
1. B.yond with External HDD only works with WD My Passport AV 320GB currently. No other HDD will work with the B.yond Box at this juncture. It's not only about teh power stability but other criteria as well. For the time being, the B.yond Box is configured to only accept My Pass Port AV 320GB. no other brands or models from teh same brand.
2. B.yond PVR on teh other hand will only work with the HDD that it comes with, It's hardcoded already. It does have a USB port however the USB port will not be able to be used to connect another HDD.
Whether the above will change in teh future depends Astro. but I don't think anything will change in the near future except adding more HDD to be compatible with the existing B.yond Box.