You're most welcome. Just a sharing of experience. Just a stern "No" repetitively will do the trick without needing for punishment as for my MS, it works faster without punishment. Same goes for toilet training as I've tried punishing by hit on his buttock but he's still doing it. Hence I change my method to  rewarding him after he's successfully do his business in toilet by himself and within few days, he goes peep n poop in the toilet even if it's wet( I live in condo). Takes a lot of patience for first 6months at least to work out a routine and consistency. Hope you dun go too harsh on your pup. She's still learning by getting the right direction from you on her behavior. Good Luck!