Here's my shoe care kit I put together last month.  I've had a chance to try out some of these products, and wow...I am impressed.
I've been using Kiwi Wax Polish and Meltonian Shoe Creams for years - they're not quite as good as the stuff I've got here. 
Kit contents:

4 x Saphir Pate de Luxe Médaille d'Or 1925 Paris Smooth Leather Shoe Polish
1 x Saphir Médaille d'Or 1925 Paris Renovateur Leather Conditioner
1 x Saphir Super Gommadin Suede/Nubuck Rubber Eraser
3 x Saphir 52x30cm Chamois Polishing Cloth
2 x Saphir 100% Boars Hair Hand Waxed Exotic Wood Large Spatula Brush
1 x Avel Regenerating Leather Cleaner Soap
2 x Bally Fine Leather Lotion
2 x Cole Haan Leather and Suede Protector
1 x Kiwi Rubber Suede Brush
2 x Allen Edmonds 100% Horsehair Shine Brush
4 x Allen Edmonds 100% Horsehair Dauber
2 x Allen Edmonds Cotton Flannel Polishing Cloth
Saphir is apparently the OE manufacturer of John Lobb creams and waxes - no wonder it is considered some of the best stuff on Earth!

Verdict:  Definitely more luster and shine than Kiwi or Meltonian, looks more like an oily shine than the waxy shine you get from Kiwi - but it is not oily at all.
The wax is very thick (not hard like Kiwi though), so a little bit goes a long way.  It's also considerably more difficult to buff out, especially on coated or patent leathers.
I am not sure I am sold on the price, considering the wax is 6x the price of Kiwi, but so far there isn't anything quite as good, so it's still the best I've tried.
The Saphir Chamois Polishing cloths have a lot of loose lint and need to be washed first before use, but they are quite soft.  I prefer the Allen Edmonds cloth.  In fact, the Allen Edmonds shoe care brushes are very good.  I am quite impressed with the quality (all made in USA) for the price. 

What is everyone else here using?
Alright, now it's time to go polish some Aldo shoes?