QUOTE(Electric_Shaman @ Jul 7 2009, 01:56 AM)
Even if what gadiylim was doing in the first place was wrong, it's not his fault that a bug started the download free for him in his itunes (can't quite remember what the post said, it got deleted, but think it was something like that right?). And if there's no way he can reimburse Apple for the mistake, and he can't revert back to the old OS; then I don't think it's a case of piracy as he did not directly download the file, and claims to have been planning to purchase it. And since he payed for his i-pod, we can assume that he did intend to also pay for his new software.
Look. He got his firmware from his developer friend. Do you know what are the terms and condition that is tied to the developer license for you to use it? One of it is that access to the content within your developer login is
explicitly used by the licensee ONLY(meaning his developer friend only and only him), and for testing purposes only. I would also like to think that, since these developers HELP Apple beta-test the firmware build, that they WILL be given access to the final, finished version of the firmware once beta-testing is done. THAT is why the firmware file started downloading on his iTunes, because his firmware file is tied DRM-wise to a developer account signature and allows him to access via iTunes AppStore to get the final build, a.k.a the firmware 3.0 file that HE WAS SUPPOSED TO PAY FOR. The Developer's Kit costs USD99 for these exclusive access, don't tell me they dont get the final firmware build once they themselves have beta-tested it? Think, man think!

Also, if Apple can trace back the firmware DRM to his developer friend, imagine what they would do to his developer license? Just because he wants to "try out the OS3.0" without paying.
Again, all of you are trying to justify an already wrongful act. Just because I mistakenly get a Big Mac at McDonald's when I only redeem a free coupon for a Beef Burger,
does not make it right for me to gobble down on Big Mac and pretend nothing is wrong. The
ethical and the right thing to do is return the Big Mac to the counter, or pay for the extra cost. Don't spin this into "whatever falls off the shelf and nobody's seeing, it is okay to pick it up and put it in my pocket" thing.
With the attitude of freeloading Malaysians these day, I don't see it wrong to assume (as compared to how you have assumed his innocence) that "free is free, as long as it downloads for me" attitude is prevalent here. Have you not seen how many posts and threads DavidGary has deleted, invisibled and moderated in regards to piracy, and illegal acts of downloading here? And you still want me to assume the best for all the things happening around this part of the forum?

Unless he can prove me otherwise, or does his purchase legitmately, I stand by my statement. And I give people props and praise for their good work and good deeds as well, those who earned it, deserved it. The opposite goes to the "freeloaders".
This post has been edited by stringfellow: Jul 7 2009, 02:23 AM