QUOTE(babygirl55 @ Sep 30 2009, 02:51 PM)
hi all
In options, there are 4 papers like P4, P5, P6 n P7.
So i choice 2 papers. Which papers is very useful or easy answer?
BPP vs Kaplan textbook, which is best practice for Professional Papers?
Thanks
For optional papers, usefulness of ANY textbook is very limited :
P4 : Examiner rarely use the textbook (implied by his statement in examiner's report).
P5 : Maybe 50 : 50.
P6 : Is there a textbook for MYS tax ? If there is, I don't even think its applicable considering we have to follow budget changes every year.
P7 : Working experience counts more on this paper.
Easy to answer :
P4 : Even if you study the whole textbook, there is even a possibility that it might not be tested at all. You really need to adapt & innovate. In finance there is something called the "branch". Everything you learn will have branches then overlap into another area.
P5 : They said that its syllabus borrows from F5 & P3 & the pass rates has been favourable these past few seatings but it started to get difficult.
P6 : Tax planning is a subject everyone will try to avoid in the past & present. I won't say its very difficult like finance but its very complicated since everything seems so similar but it is very different. What is the difference between unit trust, REIT, Investment holding, OHQ,.... all every similar but have different characteristics, many student tend to jumble up all of them. This paper had claimed many casualties in my seating.
P7 : According to a friend, you need working experience to easily tackle this paper bcos the absence of it will cause a much more difficult session.
Usefulness especially working in accounting / audit related line :
P4 : Almost any profession will touch something on finance. Ask any lecturer they will claim this is the most useful paper.
P5 : Unless you are in manufacturing industry or in managerial role (budgeting), very unlikely to utilise any knowledge gained.
P6 : If you want to do audit, tax comes hand in hand in MYS (exception in China : separation rule). Tax is very specialised so its either you have it or don't have it. If you are applying for audit firms, having tax knowledge is a bonus.
P7 : Audit is a very subjective field, since training will be given it is quite unlikely you need to study to gain entry to audit firms. So unless you have already joined one but without acca then you must take P6 & P7 since both are very relevant. You don't really learn much but you may benefit from applying work experience into exam papers (source from some who have taken P7 & passed).
Ask yourself this question, you study acca to learn or just to pass ?
Your answer may help greatly to determine your choice as it will clearly points to which one you will about to take.