I use Avon simplyPretty Eyeliner. No smudge and affordable

why not try lakme, its very intense and also it cheap...

if u want to prevent smudge, try dotting some black eyeshadow to the eyeliner, it help to stay put and less smudge. almost all the eyelines i used smudge as ur waterline is wet and it wont stay put there..

I would suggest Majorlica Majorca neo automatic liner. It's waterproof and i'm so in love with it. I've ever tried Dior liner waterproof crayon pencil, but it still smudge. MM neo auto liner is anyway cheaper than Dior's and it lasts long

MM's liquid liner doesn't smudge at all even after I SWIM and sweat for the whole day!

If you really really want pencil liner, try silky girl's funky eyelights pencil. There's no black in that range though... Don't buy silky girl's long-wearing liner because they smudge.

gel eyeliner is hardly drawn, won't?

---

Added on October 26, 2009, 3:59 pmI quite prefer with shisheido eyeliner. not bad. Try it. : )

This post has been edited by ally chai: Oct 26 2009, 03:59 PM

Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eye Pen, in Blackened Brown!
Easy to use, am still a newbie in using eyeliner and already drawing a beautiful cat's eyes flick! =)

RM34.90 at Guardian. It has a felt-tip, like a marker pen does.
Give it a try.

I want to get myself a Rimmel Flash Eye Pen, but no Rimmel here =(
But still, I love my Revlon Eye Pen, woohoo!!

hmm..
maybe you can try on etudy house's gel eyeliner. it's super black and long lasting + won't smudge. but i'm having hard time to remove it.. aiks..

Yeah Bobbi Brown not bad.... Relvon also quit good ....

but the best was Chanel Automatic Liiquid Eyeliner, extreme comfort when application... water based formula with long lasting lines n importantly with no running neh

Gel liner is definitely not the same as liquid eyeliner - gel liner comes in mini 'pots' and you'd need a fine brush to apply it onto ur eyes (try Coastal Scent's angled taklon eye liner, Etude House has one too for less than RM10 after discount) while liquid eyeliner comes in a small bottle and is in, well, liquid form! My favourite is Etude House's Oh My! coz it reallllly stays (limited colours tho). Liquid eyeliners help to create a 'sharper' eye make-up look whereas for gel liner, like Bobbi Brown's in Cappucino Ink (?) can be used for a more natural effect.

Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliners are among the best in the market - and the choice of colours are amazing! Good lasting power too but it's what, RM60? Coastal Scents also carry gel eyeliners for much less than that...

But I digress. Pencil eyeliners - the best for me are Urban Decay 24/7 and Tigi Bedhead Big Fat Fun (available in Sasa) pencils. Some other pencils that are easy on the eye are Chanel's. But both are pricey I was also recommended Almay's Amazing Lasting 16-hour pencils and ELF Minerals (smudges)

Like a friend once said.. It's almost impossible to find a pencil that is smudgeproof especially for us girls with oily lids. Your best bet is to use a primer beforehand. Some bloggers swear by Make Up Forever's Eye Seal to make pencils smudge-proof.