Anyone read this novel before? The plot seems nice to read...the write is only 28years old...

I hardly read novel in my life...is it nice? Maybe u can intro to us?

I am thinking to get the book...that's why asking forumers here if it is good

the movie is a sappy love fest.

get the book and some tissue too..

movie or book nicer? I need a good cry

Haha. I love both. I just sold my book for RM15.

Read the book first. Then watch.

Bet you can cry while reading and watching.

Hi tomato123 , I haven't watch the movie before.
But I read the novel already.
Very good novel , interesting and always make me don't wanna stop reading it.

aiks...if only i knew you earlier, then i can get from you..

---

Added on January 23, 2009, 8:11 pmplease offer me if anyone has it..

This post has been edited by tomato123: Jan 23 2009, 08:11 PM

I didnt read the book, but i did watch the movie.
Omg its soo touching. kinda sounds gay cuz i'm a guy, but it is.
Maybe i should start reading the book

read the book. its so much BETTER than the movie. The book is a very touching love story

exactly. If you want to watch, remember to read the book first! haha.

Its a very touching and romantic story. I am not a romance type of guy and I hate this. I was recommended by my friends to read it. As a guy , I find it quite dull and boring , but alas its a very touch story (my statement is an oxymoron , so just ignore that)

If you're into love/romance and you like a story with good ending , its a MUST-READ !

like what iced nyiur said....the book is so much better.
if u really get used with reading novels, then you should probably know how biased you would surely be over something written rather than a "moving" human being infront of you

as it does with any other cecellia ahern titles as well..kudos cecellia

hey i've read the book and seen the movie , but after reading the novel .. the movie was dull .. really boring try reading the book 1st b4 u watch the movie it was so touching that i cried at the ending of the novel good book highly recommend it

try "if you could see me now" as well

anyone wanna sell as 2nd hand???
i'm interested in grabbing one...since so many good reviews here..hmm..

i will consider to sell it off to you after i finished reading it
just got the book, it's 2in1 with another story from her..forgot what name...

And I'm the one who bought it. Heh.

Anyways, I kinda don't like Cecilia Ahern, she's kinda long-winded, but I'll always have a soft spot for Ps. I Love You cos it's such a bittersweet story.

Watched the movie, but I spent half the time jokingly inserting "THIS IS SPARTAAA!!!" with hubby throughout the movie.

yea..she's long winded...i just read about her families part...
the names really got me confused..
have to focus when read it

ahhhhhhh i love it!! very romantic... i went awww and *blow nose* on the movie from start till end....

anyone got the book can share??

i bought the novel ...yet to read...

Reading Kinsella's collections of shopaholic now...

seriously I read the book and I feel completely nothing. Maybe I'm numb or something but it just doesn't do it for me.

I skip the movie since the book didn't do it for me.

everytime i went to bookstore i saw this book, and everytime i pick it up and i put it back down because im not sure if i'm gonna like it, was afraid that it will turn up bad.

I am reading this book too, glad to know that there are people also reading this book now.

Definitely worth to read for me, it is the kind of book I interested.

Want to ask, any novel recommend after this book? I gonna finish this book soon, I guess it is time to look for new book

again, yesterday i went to mph, picked up the book, and put it back again, i can only buy 1 book at the time, with 3 books to choose from. in the end i decided the story is just too sad for me. haha. later maybe i'll buy it.

do what i do, buy 2nd hand ones! heheh..

read other cecilia ahern's books. thanks for the memories. if you could see me now.

I liked the book. But the movie kinda killed the book lah. Although the content of the letters were the same, the events were so SO different to the point that I beh tahan watch the ending.

the book was excellent. I couldn't put it down until I finished it. Be prepared with tissues though. The movie was quite dull in comparison..

But good book anyway. Worth reading!

just now also hahahah

yeah that's a really nice idea..

someone is selling the ebook for charity via lyn..
if anyone interested in ebook i will let the guy know

i have just finished reading mine...
it's nice read...you will never want to put it down once you start...

anyone interested to buy, pls PM me...

anyone interested in buying novels from borders.

pls get it from me.

coz i can get it for u at 15% discount.

for more information u can click on my signature thread below.

you should read the book! and prepare some tissue paper also. it's much more better than the movie!:)

I love her novels so much!!! xD
this is really great!!!

Hey,

interested. pm me the best price inclusive of postage?

thxs,
alice

dont hv time to read the book yet but the movie's really great!!!!

Cecelia Ahern rocks! I love her books! I have a collection of all her books. Hehe.

The movie isn't as good as the book, definitely.

Read the book then sourced for the movie...

So so touching! nevertheless, the book was better then the movie

I hate d movie
it ruin all story line
better read d book only
i've stop watching any movie that based on a novel as it usually different from d novel

p/s i love u make me cry while reading it
very2 sad n couldn't stop myself from reading it
should buy it or just download d e-books or borrow it from ur friends

Definitely the book itself is better than the movie.
Seriously Ahern rocks, I'm having her other three books as collection now. I wonder where can I get the e-book for ps i love you?

I didn't like the book, but I did enjoy the movie.
The book is sorta boring because Holly took forever to mope and mourn the loss of her husband.

Anybody Out There by Marian Keyes has a similar storyline but way WAY funnier and more interesting.

I didnt like the book too, charissp. I rarely throw books away but this is one of them. The husband's letters are very touching but I felt like shaking Holly every other page.

I just read Marian Keyes as well! She dealt with the issue with more feelings and understanding. There are moments of sadness, wallowing too, but interspersed with disbelief, regret, rallying etc.

i felt the book didn't live up to its hype...don't really like how the storyline developed either =.=

if im not mistaken i read this novel 2 years back?? kot...
i dunno why, but i prefer if they r not together..sorry..but still it's a good story..

the book is quite popular even till today. and the writer has come out with a new book - another bestseller too. am quite impressed