I hate d movie
it ruin all story line
better read d book only
i've stop watching any movie that based on a novel as it usually different from d novel

p/s i love u make me cry while reading it
very2 sad n couldn't stop myself from reading it
should buy it or just download d e-books or borrow it from ur friends

Definitely the book itself is better than the movie.
Seriously Ahern rocks, I'm having her other three books as collection now. I wonder where can I get the e-book for ps i love you?

I didn't like the book, but I did enjoy the movie.
The book is sorta boring because Holly took forever to mope and mourn the loss of her husband.

Anybody Out There by Marian Keyes has a similar storyline but way WAY funnier and more interesting.

I didnt like the book too, charissp. I rarely throw books away but this is one of them. The husband's letters are very touching but I felt like shaking Holly every other page.

I just read Marian Keyes as well! She dealt with the issue with more feelings and understanding. There are moments of sadness, wallowing too, but interspersed with disbelief, regret, rallying etc.

i felt the book didn't live up to its hype...don't really like how the storyline developed either =.=

if im not mistaken i read this novel 2 years back?? kot...
i dunno why, but i prefer if they r not together..sorry..but still it's a good story..

the book is quite popular even till today. and the writer has come out with a new book - another bestseller too. am quite impressed