QUOTE(viper88 @ Jan 11 2009, 12:02 PM)
At least he 's willing to show that he bought the counter recommended + the realized profit/lost made from his decision.
The passbook is to support his claim on the profit he had made from stock market since some TA guys keep saying he's making up stories and unrealistic profit gains.
Its up to individual to belief whether its true or not.
It is ok for someone that want or willing to share his portfolio, counters he/she bought and recommendation, that generally people would be appreciating it and use it as reference, comparison or whatever.The passbook is to support his claim on the profit he had made from stock market since some TA guys keep saying he's making up stories and unrealistic profit gains.
Its up to individual to belief whether its true or not.
But don't think need until passbook or whatever to support your claim or whatever. It proves nothing while I don't see what is the benefit of doing so.
If those claim and recommendation is good, then it is good, as simple as that.
Just like some analysts and investors (like Warren Buffett) are well respected in the market place because they are good, but they never shows how much they earns, right? As whatever stock recommendation prior before, its market price and result of gain and loss is known to everyone, without the need of origin recommendators to show to you.
If someone recommend 10 stocks prior before and after sometimes or long term, it does create wealth through the stocks, then it is good and well known already.
If one is good with his/her recommendation and foresight, soon and later people will know and being recognised by the market place.
Stock market or investment is not a race between people. A shows he/she gain 100K, B shows he/she gains 200K.
Then as a reader, you get no information or useful information out of it, but if put in proper analysis and recommendation for the future trend of specific in-depth of economy situation, stock market prospect, then it is benefitting to all.
Don't get me wrong, I fully respected to those blogger whom spent time to share view and put up good recommendation even bad one. Just I don't see the needs of showing up the passbook or one's wealth to claim that. If it is good, then it is good. If it is bad or bullshit, even showing up 100 millions also bad.
Just my 2 cents.
Jan 11 2009, 04:23 PM
Quote
0.0182sec
0.53
7 queries
GZIP Disabled