Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 DVVT vs VVT-i vs VTEC vs i-DSI comparison

views
     
imperialrealcs
post Oct 14 2008, 01:54 AM

IMPERIAL DEATH STAR!
*******
Senior Member
6,724 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Seri Petaling



QUOTE(! Love Money @ Oct 13 2008, 06:20 PM)
mivec not in the list ? i know that the vtec comes first then mivec... and later all the vvt-i, dvvt, cvvt, vanos all pop up in the automotive industry
*
thats for japs.. the real vvt produced by FIAT 1st.. only honda made it better

QUOTE(ZeroSP @ Oct 13 2008, 09:17 PM)
Mine L15A VTEC... Small V only.. By the way, Vios and City VTEC almost same fuel consumption.... roughly 400-420 km. And VIOS has DOHC, yet hp is lower than CITY SOHC, and lose when City can engage 7 speed manually. Try out Moon's EK9 or all sorta VTEC in Civic club.. All monsters lolz...
*
typical malaysian with big V small V doh.gif
do u even know that ur vtec l15a works differently than those in b16a?
imperialrealcs
post Oct 14 2008, 02:47 AM

IMPERIAL DEATH STAR!
*******
Senior Member
6,724 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Seri Petaling



QUOTE(RoxyGal @ Oct 14 2008, 01:56 AM)
those vtec system in normal car...where got lifting system geh...

jz normal variable timing to save fuel lar
VTEC got lar....once open.....turbo pposster
*
if u mean it works like a VVT then no, u r wrong..
read below

QUOTE(ZeroSP @ Oct 14 2008, 02:08 AM)
Oh.. Seriously I don't quite know... But I understand mine is nothing but just a little thing. That's why I also eager to listen... Sorry if I offended you with my noob statement earlier... Paiseh...
*
get to know what u r driving 1st.. thats the most important part..
ur engine is something called SOHC VTEC-E if i remember correctly and these kind of vtec does not have high lift lobe on the camshaft.. instead, it varies the valve being used in combustion.. for instant: at low speed, only 12V was used to maximise fuel efficiency while 16V was used to maximise power nod.gif
i stand to be corrected
imperialrealcs
post Oct 14 2008, 04:25 AM

IMPERIAL DEATH STAR!
*******
Senior Member
6,724 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Seri Petaling



QUOTE(ZeroSP @ Oct 14 2008, 03:11 AM)
To Travies, about VTEC, I think I can, or most people will know it is the best N.A technology out there. Although some may argue Mivec but from much forum that I read, VTEC/i-VTEC>Mivec and all other N.A.

Yes.. the 12V on normal cruise I know, 16V only utilized when 4k rpm above, usually achieved in S mode, or 7 speed tip-tronic manually. In the city guide, it somehow says 4k is the VTEC power zone, it does have a louder sound but still ok la... It's not like the real VTEC out there, it just goes faster. In my notice, 1st gear can get to 65km/h if rev up to 5800rpm, which is the max HP level of my city. It's better than Vios and those 1.6 proton. And I heard that most people out there says that the ordinary VTEC kick in feelings is better than the i-VTEC?

Reference: http://asia.vtec.net/Reviews/VTECCityPrev/index.html
This shows some of my explanation, and much of yours correct points.
*
so u look down on other car without vtec eh?
besides, ivtec again, works differently than the conventional vtec.. ivtec is more like cvvt, juz like newer version of mivecs.. juz pray u dont use ur vtec L15A to race satria mivec out there or u shat brix lol
imperialrealcs
post Oct 14 2008, 05:21 PM

IMPERIAL DEATH STAR!
*******
Senior Member
6,724 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Seri Petaling



QUOTE(ZeroSP @ Oct 14 2008, 10:29 AM)
L15A still lose to D15B by the way, L15A 110PS D15B 130PS and B16B 175PS. Let's see what's in AVTEC in the coming 3 years.

Definitely... B16 is another story than L15... And Campro and CPS, even the Lotus Manager will tell it is 10 years back technology when my dad went for Lotus Exige S. And my brother knew the engineer of Campro and CPS, Campro is fixed cam profiling which the engineer said nothing much, while CPS it's like they modified it into 2 set of fixed valve timing to provide better low end torque, no lifting for CPS and Campro. And that engineer says, "CPS and Campro are old tech la, but still Ok if it is on Manual Transmission"
*
so how exactly the cps changed between "2 set of fixed valve timing" ?
via different 2 fixed cam lobe in a single camshaft?
how was that different than that in b16 VTEC?

QUOTE(ZeroSP @ Oct 14 2008, 04:24 PM)
If only I heard wrong from the engineer than I may be wrong... Lotus is an engineering company, they don't have their own engine but they have all the research and technology. Such as the Lotus Exige S, Elise... They are using Toyota 1.8 VVT-i engine for Elise, and for Exige S, they supercharge it. And the ultra light weight and super handling Lotus chassis. So that indeed Campro and CPS they say only Cam Profile Switching, no lifting. Believe it or not, Proton claims that Waja CPS 125PS, but yet on the road they still lose to 110PS L15A.
*
what a backfire statement doh.gif
waja cps weights 1235KG and 125bhp while city weight only 1090KG and 110bhp doh.gif
even the super b16 VTEC claimed 160bhp lost to 122bhp lotus elise doh.gif

QUOTE(sphiroth @ Oct 14 2008, 04:51 PM)
Paultan already dyno a CPS Gen.2 at got about 109whp in a hot afternoon.  doh.gif
*
thats already on-crank bhp for honda city.. after all the transmission loss, i wonder how the L15A will win blush.gif
imperialrealcs
post Oct 15 2008, 02:31 AM

IMPERIAL DEATH STAR!
*******
Senior Member
6,724 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Seri Petaling



QUOTE(dstl1128 @ Oct 14 2008, 08:18 PM)
Exige (and Exige S) uses VVTL-i 2ZZGE Toyota engine with Lotus own ECU and settings.


Added on October 14, 2008, 8:20 pm
Probably 4spd auto Waja CPS vs L15A CVT?
*
but cvt transmission loss way much lesser than conventional autobox wo sweat.gif

QUOTE(ZeroSP @ Oct 15 2008, 12:25 AM)
Ok... Since I am making so much noob statement here... I just don't know how to explain then... Anyway, thanks sphiroth for the link. And to imperial, I have to respect whatever you say.. But what I test is just what I say bout the CPS vs L15, and City dun have that much transmission lost because don't have the torque converter... So forgive me everyone if you all cant take my noob statement.
*
its alright laugh.gif
juz dont say ur vtec is heaven and other was hell.. u will definitely spark flame from other owner..
try to do a neutral comparison next time, i love to flame fanboi tongue.gif
imperialrealcs
post Oct 15 2008, 06:13 PM

IMPERIAL DEATH STAR!
*******
Senior Member
6,724 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Seri Petaling



QUOTE(dstl1128 @ Oct 15 2008, 02:57 PM)
I though that's the reason L15A+CVT could possibly wins Waja Campro CPS auto.
*
aiyo boss, since cvt has much lesser power loss, thats y we are comparing with campro cps manual
but dyno figure tells that on wheel for cps already same as L15A VTEC on crank power.. so after all the transmission loss, how can the L15A VTEC win the cps?
imperialrealcs
post Oct 16 2008, 12:13 AM

IMPERIAL DEATH STAR!
*******
Senior Member
6,724 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Seri Petaling



QUOTE(dstl1128 @ Oct 15 2008, 08:41 PM)
How about car weight? Gear change latency?
*
city lighter by about 200kg.. but both shift as fast? or maybe the cvt would be slightly lower

QUOTE(Gouki @ Oct 15 2008, 08:57 PM)
Well, i suppose the Waja will still pull away from the 1st gen Jazz but by a small margin only. Coz like someone mentioned here, power to weight ratio and CVT can keep the power and torque at constant rpm while the manual in the Waja CPS will need to upshift, hence it cant hold forever at its peak power like how the CVT can do.

But i have tried real world test between the 1st gen Jazz with L15A VTEC against a Gen2 R3 MME from standstill drag on an empty land. The Jazz with L15A VTEC had a full HotBits 4-2-1 full straight flow exhaust system + K&N open pod with custom air-ram pipe on 17inch rolling stock, while the Gen2 R3 MME (without CPS) has stock R3 4-2-1 full straight flow exhaust system + R3 spark plug cables + K&N drop-in air filter on 16inch rolling stock. Manage to do few runs and the result is pretty constant which is both are on par neck-to-neck battle for about 600m drag where the Gen2 manage to hit 3rd gear and both still pulling side by side. smile.gif
*
the oldest campro was disaster.. fullstop

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0161sec    1.34    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 17th December 2025 - 04:18 PM