I have tried Lancome Eye Makeup Remover, Christian Dior Eye Makeup Remover, Simple Gentle Makeup Remover and Maybelline Eye Makeup Remover..my eyes felt uncomfortable after using them..sometimes stings too. I am currently using Ginvera Bio Pure Olive Oil..economical and removes waterproof makeup effectively..does not sting eyes..however it will leave some oily residue but it could be easily wiped off with water and cotton wool. It keeps skin moisturised too without leaving skin dry and taut, especially around the eye area. Try it!