QUOTE(kinwawa @ Jun 4 2008, 10:50 AM)
yeap...tat's wat i was thinking!
PS:
You cant fulfil everyone's wish n needs....in the end...there will b ppl complaining.....ie...subsidy for those earning 5k n below.....those earning 6k will complain they dun have xtra money also....cant finance their 1mil bungalow n 100k toyota cars etc
we need to 'adapt' to changes.........
wat i really wan to see is ppl be more conscious n realize about problem at hands...less wastage....follow European using more fuel-efficient cars.....more public transport (more environ friendly)
realistically.....i prefer
subsidy to be given based on salary range n quota (enuf to be used for working + weekends groceries shopping) ehhehehee
mind u.....nt all low-income group or those 'civil servant' have side income......
am i fair to say all remisier r millionaires n doesn't need subsidy??????
This is one topic that my friends and I have had a lot of debate. It comes to a point that I realized giving out subsidy based on salary range may not be the ideal way to move forward. Why? Well, simply because they are ppl who drive a BMW 7-series and yet earning only RM3K or less. These are those who own their own company and apply creative-accounting. Though not many are doing creative-accouting but those that benefited most from the current subsidy scheme probably falls under this category.
Well, one of the way to once-and-for-all put this subsidy issue to rest is abolish the whole darn subsidy scheme and as well as all taxes related to car - AP, road tax, road toll, etc. Let the petrol price float and let us to decide on our own if we want to drive a car. In this way, those that can afford will buy a cheaper/affordable car but yet pay the price of higher fuel cost. However, this is not possible in KL simply because the transportation system sucks big time.
So, why can't our government settle this matter amicably? Well, it is their own 'undoing'. They did not do a proper town planning for Malaysia cities and we the Rakyat have to suffer big time. Whatever scheme they are planning and did last time simply benefited a selected few. What kind of planning is that!!!
Anyway, the other method is through tax rebate though it is not perfect as they are still many earning RM3k or less but drive a big car (though it might be company car). Through tax rebate, you will be given the rebate based on your declared income. And you have to keep the petrol receipt to submit with your tax form (credit to my friend for this idea). For instance, total income of RM36k p.a. will give you $x rebate for $y of petrol. Of course, with lower tax means you can't afford to buy big car too. Mr. IRB will come to you if you can afford a BMW 7-series while earning RM3K. So even if you drive a big company car, unless you don't claim the petrol from your company, then you can submit the petrol receipt. Once you claim your company, then there will be no rebate or depends on the company tax.
Well, these are just some wishful-thinking ideas that I doubt even if the Government has the balls to suggest/recommend, many parties will lobby to stop it. This is Malaysia. The Government has balls to suggest but no balls to implement the right thing for its citizen.