I really need some black eyeliner. Both pencil and liquid. I want the black to be really thick and dramatic as I've had far too many experiences of so-called 'black' eyeliners that require me to literally poke my eyes out by drawing the lines over and over again. Are there any good and cheap brands to recommend? Preferably with a budget less than RM40.

gothic girl ?

Well, not really. But I do love gothic eyes. ^^

I personally don't buy makeup based on brands. whatever works fine works for me.
if I find something I was looking for, the brand doesn't matter.

This post has been edited by spunkberry: Apr 13 2008, 05:10 AM

True, brands don't matter. Maybe I just don't have the luck to come across the one I'm looking for.

Increase your budget by Rm10 and get the MAC eyeliner. You can go there and ask them to help you draw your eyes to see if you like the effect. If you like liquid eyeliner, i suggest this indian brand called lakme, i'm using it and the results are gorgeous!

Cas, is Lakme available here? I wouldn't mind trying it out!

i think follow me is ok too.
and its quite cheap.

hmm...i personally prefer pupa brand..but the price if not mistaken is bout RM40+ - RM45 . is real black for a pencil eyeliner range

Where do I get this lakme and pupa eyeliner?

Im using Shu Emura and Clinique eye liner.Its really nice.But the price is a lil expensive.I also had tried Mac before.It's not bad.But,for Mac's pencil eye liner,dun get the wet type.Get the dry type.Then it wont smear.

M.A.C. been using it for years. Never fails me

You can try kose which is only Rm15 - Rm16 if i m not mistaken. U can see around the Kose counter in Pakson, metrojaya, Jusco to look one for it.

u can try liner paste. The one where u need to mix with a little water to use. Those are dark and they last very long too.

Maybelline eyeliner is ok too...
it's soft and easy to apply
and really black...
can give the big eyes effect... very dramatic...
only RM19.90 at guardian, watson, sasa, etc...
if sale can get RM16++

hmm it's the skills that matter and not the brand.

I'm currently using elianto and I find it nice and reasonably priced and mostly importantly it does the same job like other branded eyeliners.

This is the one : http://www.elianto.biz/products/colour_makeup/EyeLiner.html

As for getting the dark and dramatic effect, I usually touch-up with eye-pencil after eyeliner. Of course volumize mascara play a big part too.

Also to share, I use this for removal - excellent to me as it's not harsh.
http://www.elianto.biz/products/skin_care/DeepSeaLip.html

has anyone tried?

yep, skill does matter
urm, regarding the eye make up remover, i used to use this brand too... yep, loved it coz it was perfect for removing eye make up... but i can't seem to find it anymore. the elianto workers said it's sold out. all they have left are the green tea ones... bring back deep sea eye and lip make up remover!!!

I swear by Fasio's liquid liner!!

i recently tried urban decay (pencil), and it's really dark o_o
it's good though!

Yeah I have the same problem. I bought it since CNY this year and my bottle is finishing soon. I have written to them to notify me once the stocks are in stores.

try skinfood eye liner...

just a tip; my colleague told me that if you don't want your lines to smudge, use eyebrow liner. she heard it from bobbi brown.

does most eyeliner usually smudge btw? i'm pretty much new user ^^;;;

yea i also like skin food's black bean eyeliner. Easy to apply.

where can get bobbi brown product at penang island???

i not sure what eyeliner brand the best but i can tell u..Elianto eyeliner sucks!

suigalgal: she doesn't mean bobbi brown's eyebrow pencil. any eyebrow pencil. have u ever seen eyebrows 'leaking' before? XD

my colleague uses elianto's eyebrow liner... works fine for her (if u dont like smudges type)

some magazine introduce bout bobbi brown gel eyeliner..
i think to try it but i dunno where can get it.

i am now using eye liner introduced by "lady first" taiwan.
it is not bad but got a bit leaking problem.
so i think to try bobbi brown gel eyeliner...

In Parkson Gurney Plaza

Hey elianto has replied to my approaches. Deep Sea Water Lip & Eye Make-Up Remover will be at stores by June 2008. Further, they recommended Promegranate or Cucumber Lip & Eye make-up remover as an alternative. I may give it a try as I'm running out of remover.

This post has been edited by genuine: May 6 2008, 11:01 AM

how bout gel liner?
you can try M.A.C's fluidline. i'm not sure about the price but i think it's around 40 to 50-ish? the bottle looks small but it can last you for very long! it's very easy to use and control (by using brush)

This post has been edited by jamie.: May 6 2008, 04:45 PM

what do u mean by leaking problem?

i suppose, (for me) the only liner that doesnt smudge is water proof liquid liner. am using the one by fasio

how much is the fasio one??
im trying to look for a gd one that won smear...
and i oso am still noobie at using liquid eye liner
anyone care to teach more about how ??

im indian.
we thrive on eyeliner or kohl as we call it.

try the secret pearl pencil eyeliner in jet black.
doesn't smudge.
works like magic and its only 14 bucks.

to line your eyes, you can try jordana eyes liquid eyeliner.
it can be found at sasa for about 20 bucks, i think.

i saw bobbi brown outlet in midvalley. =)

---

Added on June 8, 2008, 11:53 pmi saw bobbi brown outlet in midvalley. =)

---

Added on June 9, 2008, 12:00 amamong pencil eyeliner, liquid liner & gel eyeliner, can i know which one of these has the best effect & doesn't smudge and last longer?

This post has been edited by alynnthe: Jun 9 2008, 12:00 AM

fasio liquid eye liner is the best! never used another brand. now on my 4th bottle

bobbi brown gel eye liner - the best

am using bobbi brown's gel eyeliner... works well for me and it doesn't smudge easily + long lasting i have inner double eyelids so smudging usually an issue

have you ever come across with this Jap brand Majorlica?
I got the liquid eyeliner from HK and the price is only around RM30+
It's easy to use and super long lasting!

The Bobby Brown Gel Eyeliner is the very good and Black gives you like very black ^__^ which is why i had to use the black brown colour cos my mum said I'd look like a panda when standing at the make up counter ^^;; Very easy to wear and doesn't smudge easily. You will need a brush to apply it. If the bobby brown one too expensive then hope to watson or guardian's for a lip brush. It's close enough And it lasts for a long time too without smudges and I have oily eyelids. But occasionally will have creases on the lids... just give it a gentle rub with your little finger while looking at the mirror and you are good to go again o.o-b
Kate has a powder gel version that looks good. Dunno much about it's staying power but review are promising. Clinique has a similar one too and Shiseido has it in many colours and with glitter if you are interested in the goth punk kinda look.

Kose liquid eyeliner. Really good. Smells really nice too

Sorry for the late reply. Yes it's available, you can get it from Brickfields or any stores in Masjid India

elianto works great on me, n affordable price~

im using kate liquid eyeliner...love it so much...

If I'm on budget, I buy elianto. If not, I use Bodyshop or Revlon.

I really don't like Bourjois Liner clubbing.. It's fine if i'm not wearing any eye shadow.. but when i do wear eye shadow, the colour doesn't seem to stick!!! grgrgrgrgr

i tried cybercolor and missha..both doesnt work for me.. i have inner double eyelid..so it smudge easily and the colour fade out easily...i think i have oily eyelid as well ...what kind of eyeliner i should use??

AH i hate those eyeliners where you have to draw very hard on it!! it hurts!!

i went to sasa and this lady there introduced me, it must be a japanese brand, it was good, just touch on it and the line is there... also another one i have is the clinique one, i am using it for everyday, very good too... slighly draw over, and it's BLACK BLACK!!

currently i am using lancome wan

very black and it dry faster den my clinique

Elianto's Frosted Liquid Eyeliner is good as well.
It was promoted in the SEVENTEEN magazine though.

Hi gals,

My website has just published.
Please let me know if you are interested in any products.

My Webpage (www.mykawaishop.com) NiuEr, Ladies first and other cosmetics

Thanks ya.

Kawaishop

This post has been edited by kawaishop.pg: Jun 30 2008, 12:55 PM

Hi dear,, i suggest to u..Avon Product. .i'm curently use the black colour eyeliner..very dark..
it's good and cheap some more..only RM10..Why not u try after this..

This post has been edited by yann_5692: Jul 1 2008, 09:37 AM

Are you sure it's just RM10?
How long would the eyeliner last?

Cybercolours Liquid Eyeliner bought so many times but after few hours it seems to smudge off or fade to a dark shade of blue (Navy Blue) and it looks weird so I just wash it off. :/ I think Kate is better but now they came out with a new packaging and the brush is harder to apply.

For Pencil Eyeliner - Skinfood, CyberColor
For Gel Eyeliner - KATE
For Liquid Eyeliner - Cybercolor

These are around RM40.

P/S: Always apply foundation or at least make up base before Eyeshadow & Eyeliner.
It will hold ur make up longer.


This post has been edited by yeanjeanie: Jul 8 2008, 01:28 AM

try red earth's pencil eyeliner.. i adore it.. i've been looking for the perfect eyeliner for god knows how long.. haha.. i cant use liquid ones cuz my hands tend to shake.. its super soft, super smooth n super black.. and on the other end, it has a brush for u do smudge it to create more natural looks.. its RM36 if not mistaken.. can get it at esprit or sasa

Lurrve Mac Powerpoint pencil!
it doesnt hurt my eyes, glides on easily, so easy i was shocked so must be carerful if not terlebih use hehe colours are very natural and looks natural on eyes too of course and won fade away even if u cry in the cinema! hehe sometimes i forgot and rub and its still there

anyone using MAC Gel Eyeliner?

Yeah I do. Dipdown (dark brown) is my daily staple. If I want black I use Blacktrack. I also have Brassy but I don't like it too much cos it's too light for me. I know alot of babes prefer Bobbi Brown's Gel Eye Liner but I still prefer MAC's Fluidline. I have a few BB's but I still keep going back to my MAC's. I really should sell off my BB's and MAC Brassy, hardly use them!

sounds good

Last time I used Elianto's Frosted Liquid Eyeliner.
But the eyeliner in the bottle seems thicker and stickier after some period used. (4moths only if I m not mistaken)
But Elianto's Frosted Liquid Eyeliner is long lasting thou,and water proof too.
I think try the tester once and apply the liquid eyeliner on the back of my hand.
Then i leave it dry, and didnt use makeup remover to remove it.
And guess wat..
The eyeliner stays on the back of my hand for around 10days!!
No matter how i rub it, it wont go off!
So if apply Elianto's Frosted Liquid Eyeliner, you must use eye make up remover to clean it.
If not, it will stay on your eyelid for days!

Has anyone tried Skin Food's Choco Eye Line Jam gel? Saw a write up about it in a blog. Packaging looks cute. Is it available here at all?

*someone's bored with her eye liners*

ive used maybelline & cyber colors eyeliner but they r so dissapointing..wear it oni 4 a few hours n the color melt already.been using silkygirl but it finished so fast.use per stick about 2 weeks.im also looking..hehe but my budget tight wor..

I tried these before:

BB Gel Liner (best)
Revlon Colorstay (smudge a bit)
Shu Uemura (thumbs up)
MAC Eye Kohl (disappointed, smudge like nobody business)
Kate Sharp Liner (quite like it but smudge a bit and stained my lids)
Majorlica Majorca (It doesn't smudge or stained my lids, will buy more next week for the price)

This post has been edited by berryshortcake: Oct 8 2008, 12:22 PM

how much is the BB gel liner dear...?

If I'm not mistaken its RM70

i am currently using OTTIE eyeliner (a product from korea) i bought during beauty expo. BUY ONE FREE ONE for only RM28 =)

waterproof and its easy to remove. Just rub once or twice with remover and its done! I love it!!! I have blue color too!!

Those who want branded eyeliner you can go for:
Shu Uemura liquid liner
CDior pencil liner
Make up forever cake liner (tho its a bit too much of work-non waterproof)

my friend told me Kate is not bad.. i bought RedEarth months ago.. regret

Try this babe.
It is the best seller in Japan & Taiwan now...

I love it too


Attached thumbnail(s)

Hihi any1 using Majolica Majorca? Can give review hehe, very tempting to buy

Hi,

I've been itching to try kate's gel eye liner. The price is a bit high, therefore i'd just want to make some careful research b4 getting it.
Can anyone please tell me your verdict on this product? Is it long lasting or smudges easily? Is it easy to use, cos there's a brush with it, so then will this be fine to use for someone who's normally rushing?
Thanks.

so far i have used the following :

bibo - smudge like mad -.-'
revlon - smudge a lil after 12 hours
kate liquid eyeliner - no smudge on me
maybelline liquid liner(the older packaging) - superb. i love this so much. easy application and it won't smudge. but i can't find it anymore
bb gel(curi use from my sis XD) - really good and if you could afford the price tag, don't bother searching for others. but if you're a new user then it might be a bit hard to draw the line nicely.

shu uemura.

This post has been edited by -jEssica-: Nov 28 2008, 03:36 PM

funny... i found it sunway pyramid outlet. maybe it's back :-)

i hav sell d famous product of taiwan a lot of there very cheap n nice
wanna more info call me 0166930600
msn ling_1238@hotmail.com

Review! Pricing is an estimate only(brain not quite as sharp ^^)

Bobbi Brown Gel Liner (RM80+ factor in a brush from Sasa)
It's good! No smudging or disappearing. Lasts the whole day. Decent colour collection. My favourite was Espresso ^^ Easy to apply but will dry a little after age.

Kate Gel Liner (RM 50)
Comes with its own brush. Smooth application. I didn't like the fact that it was powdery. Not quite gel in my opinion. It's like taking a wet brush to loose pigment eyeshadows. Smudges a little so don't try to run around with it too much. IF you keep in air-conditioned environments it will be fine

ZA pencil liner(RM 20+)
Strong colour! Black means black with only one application. Sadly it smudges with just the littlest twitch. Works well i guess if you have Benefit's She-laq to go with it but that costs and arm and a leg.

Shiseido PN Automatic Liner (RM 98)
SO nice *__* and also a little bit sparkle to it. Not angeldust sparkle but more like Mica sparkle. It should now be the Maquillage line. Nice colours. minimal smudging but has a bit of flaking.

SkinFood Black Bean Eyeliner (RM15)
Smudges alot. I like the smudge sponge they have on the other end tho. Good for lining under the eyes just a little for that smoky eye look.

KissMe HeroineMake Liquid eyeliner (RM40)
My favourite at the moment. Blacker than night. Smooth and quick application. Mistakes are easily soaked up with a wet cottonbud. The thin brush makes detailed work and colouring between lashes(or fake lashes) easy as pie. Doesn't smudge, doesn't streak, doesn't rub off (unless you rub awfully hard). Doesn't even come off if you cry! Even after all that, it washes off with warm water and regular face wash ^__^

Majolica Majorca Automatic Liner (RM45)
Wonderful! Second favourite this one simply because of it's wide range of colours. The brush is not as thin as the KissMe one but still can be handled well. It's a cheaper version of what Shiseido has(same company anyways). The sparkly black is a nice colour. I like it in brown ^^ Doesn't last as long as the KissMe one and is prone to flaking if not touched up every 4-6 hours or so.

bought the Kate gel eye liner. Bought black. It's so darn tricky having to use a brush. Feel like wanting to go back to using pen eyeliner. Heard that Shiseido's really good and have refills. but of course, expensive.

The majolica one, does that have refills?

I remembered testing out the Orma intense liquid eyeliner or something brand in watson. the color was really intense. for black, color is close to freshly painted chinese ink.
Is anyone using this?

KissMe HeroineMake Liquid eyeliner
tis sounds good to me...i love easy removal!

use Elianto Eyeliner..
very good on me...

MM doesn't have refills for the automatic liner ;_; It would be cool if they did but so far it's somewhat affordable for that wide a range of colour choice o.o-b quality is similar to that of shiseido ^^

i like Kate eyeliner gel^^

i m using kate eyeliner... is gel liner.... is a very good 1 coz it reali water proof stay so long.... price is rm49.90... can use for so long...

Why don't you try out KATE ? Its very famous in Japan. Good pricing too. Below RM40 can get . Now got Xmas package. Eyeliner, eyeshadow & foundation only for RM63. Available @ any KATE booths.

---

Added on December 16, 2008, 3:28 pmHAHA looks like alot people support KATE. I support KATE because Nakashima Mika is the ambassador LOL ! Look @ my siggy ~

This post has been edited by xMika: Dec 16 2008, 03:28 PM

i will recommand clinique gel eyeliner.. long lasting + waterproof+ easy to apply.. not like liquid has to wait..

Wow!! Where?

But I am broke now

try red earth too~ its super black n glides on easily... its a pencil eyeliner by the way with a smudge tip at the end to create smokey eyes or a more natural look... its around RM30+ if not mistaken... can get it at Sasa or selected Esprit stores... but if ur eyes are prone to smudging alot, i'd advise u to get a liquid 1 or gel 1... once they are in place, they wont budge... but it needs time n practice.. i personally cant use liquid ones... Also you can use a finishing powder to set ur pencil eyeliner after u have drawn da line to prevent some smudging too~!

i've been using MAC's crayon type i think... KOHL... very good.. doesn't smear...
but my friend is using stila... something in a pot....

Hi...


can i noe hw do I get KissMe HeroineMake Liquid eyeliner???
Thanks

try revlon colorstay..satisfaction guaranteed

or you can try the KATE eyeliner gel ..

i use benefit's cream eyeliner(towne car) and Skinfood's cream eyeliner
Both gives me very black lines, but i am crappy at drawing with brush.

So i bought liquid liner from Majorlica, :LOVED it!! They have many colours. It is my Fave.
And i found a Cheap china brand called Heng Fang, it's very black, very firm brush too. But i can't find it again.

Hi,

Maybe I can help you with this.
I have the SMOKY BAR-BACKSTAGE MAGIC EYE PENCIL(Made in Italy).
If you really wish to have the effect on smoky eye maybe you can try out the eye shadow from Stage.
I will forward both picture for you to survey.



Attached thumbnail(s)

I love Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner. No smudge. and WaterProof Double Thumb up for its Affordable price.

hey girl, i have lakme kajal eyeliner, are u still interested?

---

Added on May 12, 2009, 11:42 amhey girl, i have lakme kajal eyeliner, are u still interested?

---

Added on May 12, 2009, 11:46 amhey i have the lakme kajal eyeliner, r u still interested?

This post has been edited by pryncez_81: May 12 2009, 11:46 AM

skinfood black rice liquid eye liner is realy good. easy to apply too.
i think liquid ones are better than pencil cause pencil normally smudges

hihi there.im using elianto eyeliner pencil n also liquid.Elianto's Frosted Liquid Eyeliner is quite good n its reali reali black.but 1 thing i dislike,it is reali super duper waterproof until i must use oil type remover to remove it.if ur remover is liquid type,u will have difficulty to remove it.

i love rimmel and body shop liq.eyeliner