Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

19 Pages « < 16 17 18 19 >Bottom

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 ASB loan, worth to get it???

views
     
buggie
post Apr 2 2020, 10:05 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(teen08 @ Apr 2 2020, 02:49 PM)
Need advise, IF I have the cash should I take the moratorium for housing loan and asb 1 and 2 or pay the loan. Car loan I’ll be taking since no further interest. But for this two not sure if I keep the money in asb3 would be better or just paying the loans. Asb3 profit would be much more lower next year. So I’m confused in what should I do. I hope sifus can help me. Thanks in advance.
*
Take the moratorium. The money you save put in ASB3 or other vehicles. Compound that by the remainder of your loan tenure and you will gain significantly higher than the interest you have to pay for that 6 months
buggie
post Apr 13 2020, 09:56 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(debonairs91 @ Apr 13 2020, 09:24 PM)
no one is saying asb is bad. all im saying and it's true is that asbf is bad. take the full 5% dividend for yourself. dont share with bank. of course you would make profit with loan, but you will make much more profit if you dont take loan smile.gif
*
This is wrong
buggie
post Apr 14 2020, 11:37 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(da_opera @ Apr 13 2020, 11:18 PM)
Bank could be your best friend. Why don’t u share? Sharing is caring  tongue.gif  tongue.gif

Or maybe you’re just playing devil’s advocate  rclxs0.gif

I.m not a banker.
As long as you do your due diligence, you’ll be fine. In any services, banking insurance property etc.

Using ASB financing is like leveraging in business. If someone could help u expand your business, to improve your sales, but at acceptable cost why don’t u take it?

To young fellas out there, this is my 2cents.

1. Practice delayed gratification. Applicable to people who are not from rich family. If you’re just about to start your life, don’t buy expensive cars, no latest gadgets please, and dont buy house yet. Rent first, it is ok, no matter what your friends say.

2. Then use ASB as your saving and investment tool.

3. Apply ASB financing. If possible max out 200k with the longest tenure and lowest monthly installment. Why 200k, to break your soft cap ASAP.

Why longest tenure and lowest installment? Because we want to improve your cashflow. Why?

So that you still afford to save for other investment, bagi duit bulan2 pada orang tua kat rumah and give sedeqah to the needy. Those are still investment, invaluable.

4. What if i.m not sure whether i could afford 200k installment.

It’s ok. Apply for 50k or 100k first. I know there are many uncertainties in our life. Once u can manage your cashflow every month, u may reconsider to change this. Please check your financial health every week.

5. Use compounding method. I’m against rolling method.

Lets say u can only afford to apply for 50k or 100k, it’s ok. Any extra cash, immediately put in the ASB. just leave something for your routine expense in your salary account. This will help u build the compounding effect.

6. Should I invest in stocks, unit trust etc..?

If you’re not pro in investment, i would suggest for u to fill up your ASB first. Take your time to learn stocks and other investment first. Learn to invest. If your just following tips here and there, that is speculating, for me akin to gambling. Do not do something that u do not understand.

7. Should u save for property, marriage, family etc? Put the cash in the ASB account. This is very liquid. Whenever u urgently need it u can immediately go to the bank, fill up a form and withdraw. In unit trust, stocks, price is fluctuating every day, and there is commision fees if u want to withdraw. None of this is in ASB.

8. Should u forgo other type of investment? Certainly not. Consider property. Learn it first, read a lot. Consider buy to rent. Do your due diligence. Real estate is good as a hedge agaisnt inflation.
9. If u take 3percent as inflation rate, u need an investment that could beat this figure. This also explains why I don’t like rolling method in ASB. U can only beat inflation by compounding method in ASB. And property can beat this. So use both please.
*
This is right
buggie
post Apr 19 2020, 07:35 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
More bickering... Zzzzzz

I always thought that this thread is for comparing whether u should use your own cash or utilise asb loan when investing in ASB. For me the answer is simple. ASBf trumps own cash every day and all day. Whatever the economic situation. So far at least until stats shows me otherwise.

Now if the discussion is about whether to invest in ASB or other places.... Thats a whole different story already. If you have the knowledge and know how and the capital, plenty of other places gets u more than the 5%, 8%, 15%, 20% that asb gives. But as we know different people are at different stages of their lives and at different economic standing.

For me ASB is represent a 'safe' investment. And part of many investment portfolios. One should always mix and if you're starting out in investing... Go for the safe first and play around with the rest using only your expandible wealth. The old saying still runs true. High risk high reward, low risk lower reward.

I've personally been burned in stocks and other investments, but also made a killing on them too. But these were done with extra money that I was willing to risk. The risk is real and if you have responsibilities, those must always come first. You must also have the risk appetite. If you're the type that get stressed at losing a little bit than some forms of investments are not for you. Only you can decide that. Also before investing, knowledge is always key. Dont go in blind. So access your current finances and situation and do what u think is right.

But again, my postings on this thread has always been about the benefits of asbf vs cash injections. Not asbf vs stocks, property, funds, business, tabung haji, or bawah bantal.

So whether or not anyone can predict a pandemic coming does not matter the question now to discuss is in this current climate, is it still worth taking loan vs cash injection into asb.

This post has been edited by buggie: Apr 19 2020, 07:40 PM
buggie
post Apr 20 2020, 07:38 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Bora Prisoner @ Apr 20 2020, 02:01 PM)
I was able to take 330k loan, because my softcap had increased due to my compounded earnings over time. Did not manage 400k cause my ASB was (200k loan + 130k cash), I started late a bit.

Some people like @boogie were lucky enough to take 400k.

Those were back in the day, nowadays loan cap is 200k.
*
QUOTE(wild_card_my @ Apr 20 2020, 02:03 PM)
Okay so you are saying at some point, new investors were given 200k unit capping and 400k financing capping, but you can only take as much loans as your softcap has increased?
*
Yeah i've got 400k loan because my softcap at the time surpassed 400k. Good timing i guess. But I didn't know this could be done at the time.

Was there to refinance and the banker pitched it to my surprise. Jumped at the chance and the rest is history.

Btw, if you follow my post, i recently refinanced that 400k loan. They only recently banked in my ammortised capital of 75k into my ASD. There was some issue.

They initially asked me to withdraw 75k from my asb soft cap to make space so they can bank it in there. I argued because the 75k is supposed to be my principal from paying the loan. It had nothing to do with asb. All previous refinancing they had banked into my Maybank account. First, to withdraw i might lose some dividend. Second I have to wait to after mco to get it done. Tolak sini tolak sana back and forth they suggested to bank into asb3. I accepted to cut the story short. But it still don't make sense to me why they couldn't bank into my Maybank account but had to put the loan principal into asb

Oh well... At least there won't be temptation to spend it since its there and not in my bank 😅😅😅

This post has been edited by buggie: Apr 20 2020, 07:39 PM
buggie
post May 8 2020, 05:01 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(JaySd @ May 8 2020, 08:49 AM)
Hi all,

Would like to get some feedback. I have 2 ASBF loans for my ASB 1.

100K @ 3.8% (since 2017)
100K @ 3.65% (since 2018)

Should I refinance by scrapping both & make a new 1 ASBF for 200K?

Another Q is, i'm trying to understand abt the hard/softcap. The limit is 200k right? Any compounded dividedend will + to the 200k. So,

hardcap = 200k
Softcap = 200k + "reinvested dividend"

Is this right? I remembered having to transfer my cash feom ASB 1 to ASB 2 bcs the limit has to be ngam2 200K.
*
Now that When refinancing, you only need to transfer out the hard cap. Your softcap can remain
buggie
post May 13 2020, 05:21 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(wild_card_my @ May 13 2020, 11:15 AM)
Not at all, but you should kinda avoid the moratorium for ASBF and Mortgages

Moratorium Effects on your Mortgage and ASBF Accounts

The loan balance of your mortgage and ASBF accounts would still accrue interest during the six (6) months moratorium. This means that even though you are deferred from paying the installments, you are still being charged interest based on the loan balance as of the beginning of the moratorium

The accrued interest would accumulate each month and must be settled by October 2020. If you are unable to settle the due in one lump sum, it will be capitalized into your loan account thus increasing the loan balance

Due to the nature of reducing-balance interest calculation, the now-capitalized interest will be compounded over the years. This compounding of interest will be in effect till the full settlement of the loan balance.

As such one of the two things below will happen in terms of your mortgage and/or ASBF accounts. Please verify this with your own banks:

1. Starting October your installment will be increased to repay the increased loan balance while maintaining the original loan tenure

2. Alternatively, your installment will remain the same but the tenure will be extended for longer than six (6) months since the capitalized interest would be compounded as explained above
*
How about we choose alternative 2 (extend 6 months)
And terminate 6 months before maturity...?

Would that have an adverse effect?

This post has been edited by buggie: May 13 2020, 05:23 PM
buggie
post Jun 3 2020, 01:09 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(voncrane @ Jun 1 2020, 06:12 AM)
No mean to vroom . but Err... why is it now okay for you to respond like this and all the bigots who cussed me out for predicting this are now silent? I did ask for new projection numbers.. Still waiting on em..

Edit...oh by the way and just to be ahead of those who’ll inevitably spout rubbish comebacks... That question is completely rhetorical as I already know why.. Just pointing out the level of hypocrisy and groupthink in this here thread is over 9000!! Wankers.. smh  laugh.gif
*
You predicted a pandemic which caused the meltdown of the economy? Pergh....
buggie
post Jul 11 2020, 01:06 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Fiezannn @ Jul 8 2020, 09:19 PM)
Hi guys. I’m about to take asb loan. Will it be better if i maxed out year of tenure or 30 years will be good enough?
*
Always max out the tenure.

Remember, the main thing is to reduce your repayments to as low as possible. Settling the loan is never the objective.

This post has been edited by buggie: Jul 11 2020, 01:07 PM
buggie
post Sep 22 2020, 05:57 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(voncrane @ Sep 12 2020, 08:58 PM)
Another person that refused to read and comprehend my post before commenting. Bora Prisoner simply commented, consciously taking words out of context...Why? I don’t know.. But then, this thread has always been like that..

FYI, Maybank has a thing where you pay ahead and it’s factored into your remaining loan balance. Then every month, that balance is “increased” as “deductions” are made. Guess what? Since your loan balance is reduced, means you get charged lower interest too cuz you’ve technically paid off a sum owed... recalculated every month... How do I know this? Ayam doing it..  whistling.gif So NO! the interest amount doesn’t remain the same as if paying monthly.
*
from here it's so obvious you don't get it... after all these years. that's why you keep giving out wrong advice
buggie
post Sep 23 2020, 12:04 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(voncrane @ Sep 22 2020, 08:37 PM)
Oh i get it alright.. Don't worry... I didn't ask you to take my "wrong advice" either.. Please do you. here's what I know as fact..
Option 1.. Every single month, go queue at Maybank to withdraw RM1K from other ASNB funds, etc to deposit into loan linked SA so got fund to deduct when time comes..Hassle, traffic, jam, stress, no benefits beyond "savings" and maximizing. How much savings? IMO? Not worth the hassle.

Option 2. Don't do all that shizz above every month.. got spare cash.. withdraw once for say 6 months or a year and pay upfront. INSTANT interest amount reduction and more time and clear brain to make money elsewhere..

I will pick Option 2 any day any time. Why spend and hour or 2 chasing peanuts when the same amount of time can be used elsewhere for more worthwhile endeavors. End product? Still earn both places. Less stress and more happy. So yeah, you do you.  icon_rolleyes.gif
*
So wrong again... you're on a roll. Going for 3 for 3?

Thought of option 3?

This post has been edited by buggie: Sep 23 2020, 12:07 PM
buggie
post Sep 23 2020, 06:12 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(voncrane @ Sep 23 2020, 05:29 PM)
Yeah.. Just did...Options 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, & 8.. Would you like to list all of them? I'm afraid to list them. Lest they can't be fathomed.. laugh.gif
*
Ya, you better not list them. For sure it can't be fathomed when it doesn't make sense.
buggie
post Sep 27 2020, 10:54 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(voncrane @ Sep 26 2020, 09:26 AM)
lol.. you do you fam.. Just because you don’t understand or can’t comprehend statements doesn’t mean they are not fathomable.. It just means that you can’t. The Earth is round not flat yeah..  laugh.gif As always, it’s a pleasure to tease the smart-a**es out in this group..

P.S. I still love you all yeah.. Don’t sweat it.
*
Oh don't get me wrong... We understand and comprehend what you're saying. Its just that it doesn't make sense.

9/10 times your wrong. But kudos on the 1 time you do get things right. Must be an achievement for you

Yah... You do you and I do me. And we all love one another. Kumbayah....
buggie
post Sep 28 2020, 07:37 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Bora Prisoner @ Sep 27 2020, 05:22 PM)
Let him be lah, I do at times suspect he is just trolling because I refuse to believe that anyone can be that dense.

Anyway bro, wanted to thank you for the refinance-without-cancel-sijil tip. That helped shave a year off for me to reach my goals.
*
Haha... Yeah... No worries. I'm just having a bit of fun.

About the tip... No thanks necessary. That's what we are all here for. Well most of us anyway..
buggie
post Sep 29 2020, 06:01 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(voncrane @ Sep 29 2020, 05:21 PM)
I call BS.. You do mean offense. Kindly call out those 9 times out of 10 that I was wrong. And I'll point out 9 times out of 10 that I've been right, including accurately predicting the poor returns being experienced today, and that longer time will be required to break even, and also that you can indeed lose money if you simply sign dunno what and not plan.. That's just 3 things I've spoken about that is RIGHT.. So dunno where your 1/10 stats stem from.. Bias perhaps? Pls check it at the door... I dare you or anyone else here can pull out 9/10 verifiable records I was wrong and didn't admit it. See, it isn't the first time that I've been personally attacked. Cuz guess why? you can't fault any opinion or POV I put forth.. So take the easy way out and attack the person instead.. lol..
*
Oh testy testy... Lol. What happened? Where's that cool exterior? You disappoint me.

You can call BS or whatever it is you like. And I'm too lazy to call out everything you said wrong. Just look behind a few pages I already called you out then and there. Look back further and I've debunked everything you said with stats. The guys here the past few years know what I'm talking about. The noobs may not understand and they will eat up what u say. Pity them. Hope they know better now.

But to prove my point, even this post of yours I'm replying to is not without errors... Lol. 9/10 mentioned is the ratio la.. Not the literal count. So if you got 3 right then you have 27 other statements wrong. Don't ask me to list the other 27 ah... Don't be childish. If you keep at it you're gonna raise your ratio to 9.5/10 before long... So try to keep the ratio down ya.

And those 3 examples you listed... Lol... So general... Its like saying ... When it rains you're gonna get wet if you don't bring an umbrella. Even my 8 year old can tell you that.

And I won't check it at the door. Sorry. Will call BS when I see it. For the good of the many. That's just me doing me.

This post has been edited by buggie: Sep 29 2020, 06:02 PM
buggie
post Sep 30 2020, 06:05 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(voncrane @ Sep 29 2020, 11:19 PM)
Nah, nothing happened.. I simply asked you to back up your numbers and claims and as expected... no one could step up. Also, do you notice how you didn't say i was wrong about the 3 examples I gave?.. Which means I was right? Thanks for the repeated validation.... AGAIN.. So yeah, I'm justified to call you out about spouting BS. From this, I can quit this game d. You've categorically shown that I do know my stuff and you like the child you call me, sadly & expectedly....You can't back your talk up. I'd say that's conclusive proof right there. When you can? (and we both know you can't) No worries.. Just tag me and I'll pop up again. laugh.gif
Watch me actually resume contributing freely to the thread.
[attachmentid=10603534]
*
Your responses are getting more childish and insignificant. I'm getting bored. *yawn*

Anyways... When it comes to bad advice.. The old Malaysian adage comes to mind... "give free also dowan lah" lolx...
buggie
post Sep 30 2020, 09:25 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
Guys, let's revisit the stats to see if ASB is still a viable investment vehicle with stats in today's landscape. Especially for those 20 somethings thats just starting out

Some basics:
Loan Interest : 3.55%
Dividend : 5.5%
Loan Amount : 200,000.00
Tenure : 30 years

You pay for 3 years:
904 x 12months = 10,848.00 a year
10,848.00 x 3 years = 32,544.00 (after 3 years)

You get after 3 years:
Dividend: 34,848.00
Amortised: 11,834.00
= 46,682.00

ROI = 32,544.00 (paid) / 46,682.00 (got back)= 30.28% (modest returns)

This is just your returns in the first 3 years of this loan. With the power of compounding, your ROI will inevitably increase as you pay the same amount a year but your dividend grows exponentially.

Strategy:
If you're young, rinse and repeat. the 11,834 amortised kickback every 3 years (if the rates are lower or the same) put into ASB2/ASD to earn more dividend further increasing your ROI. Remember the power of compounding. Leave all your dividends in and don't touch them if possible.

If you're old like me, just sit back and look at your ASB/ASB2/ASD account every Jan/Apr/Jul.. biggrin.gif

Personally, I'd get this done. Set and forget. Then concentrate on your career/business and earn big money. Soon, as you progress in life... 1k odd a month to ASB will feel like nothing.

With the extra income and savings start to delve into other riskier investments that will earn you more returns. But remember you can also get burned and lose.

No matter what the outcome whether you make a killing or get burned in your other investments, you have ASBf as part of your retirement plan with at very least 1M in your account after 30 years if not more to supplement your EPF/savings and not depend on your children for your daily living. If you die young then they benefit la.

This is for the average joe. With the uncertainty of life and the curveballs it throws at you and all the twists and turns... adjust accordingly.

This post has been edited by buggie: Sep 30 2020, 10:25 AM
buggie
post Oct 1 2020, 12:50 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Joshua_0718 @ Oct 1 2020, 12:43 PM)
By right, ASB or ASB2 has higher dividend rate?
*
Historically, ASB has always been higher than ASB2
buggie
post Oct 6 2020, 05:46 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(MrFay @ Oct 3 2020, 10:14 PM)
hope i summarize correctly from what i read so far in this thread, especially from successful persons like @wild_card, @buggie and @Bora Prisoner

1. Always maximize your loan tenure (longest right now is 40 years), it's not about to complete the tenure but rather to improve your monthly cashflow

2. Always refinance to get better rates and longer tenure (or if you're long enough in ASBF, you can negotiate with your Bank to revise the interest rate)

3. Do not take up Takaful to improve cashflow (there is no such thing as COMPULSORY Takaful)

4. Do not use your yearly dividen to pay for your monthly installment, let it compound, and you will see the 8th wonder of the world  tongue.gif

5. if you have spare money, DO NOT pay extra/additional to your ASBF account, it wont increase your principal/lower your interest charged, just put your extra money to ASB2 or ASB3 account

6. if for some reason, there's another moratorium offered by the banks, DO NOT opt for it if you can pay your ASBF, because interests will be charged during Moratorium and will take up your principals  rclxub.gif

anything i left out?
*
Sounds about right.

For no. 5, let me elaborate. While paying extra will reduce your principal, you shouldn't do it. Settling the loan is never on the agenda. This loan is not like housing loan or ANY other loan where you need to settle the principal amount to get out of the contract, as some people claim. If you don't feel like paying anymore for whatever the reason, just cancel/terminate the loan. No penalty whatsoever. Simple.

For this loan, up about the 10 year mark, you would have doubled your money. ie for a 200k loan, you would have earned a dividend of 200k cash by then. One could easily 'settle' the loan with the dividend earned. But you shouldn't.

Even if you had 200k cash in your ASB, I would take it out and put in ASB2 and take the loan. Which was what I did when I reached 400k ASB (although you can't do this now. And when ASB 2 opened up for loan, I took out the 200k and dump into ASD and took that loan.

As a result, as of now, I'm paying roughly 30k a year and earning roughly 55k from dividend for almost 100% ROI. Every 2 years adding 100k odd to the base for the interest to be compounded on.


buggie
post Oct 7 2020, 10:46 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
449 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
QUOTE(Bora Prisoner @ Oct 7 2020, 08:52 AM)
You so rajin layan him bro hehe.

Its also about opportunity cost. The fella claims his asbf interest rate is a low 3.4%, but at the same time concerned about paying more interests? So he suggests taking out of funds like ASB2/3 that give returns above 4%?

Simple maths also dunno. Later cover line and say it was about saving multiple trips to the bank!

Bet he takes out EPF money to reduce his home loan as well lol.
*
Haha.... I don't really come in here that often these days. When I do, I'm compelled to correct the BS that's been going around.

Yes Opportunity Costs. Trying to instill to the young'ens and start them young. They gotta realize every year that goes by is one year less to compound. We can only advise tho. I started at 25 and in hindsight, I should've started earlier. Came to this forum like everyone else, seeking info and now that I've been thru it, just wanna contribute my 2 cents back.

QUOTE(haziqnet @ Oct 7 2020, 09:40 AM)
I totally agree with bro buggie. Using compounding method only in 10 years you already double your money.
*
Actually in today's landscape, at 5.5% you'd only get RM150k. But that just reinforces how powerful compounding is. A slight change will dramatically alter the outcome.

But this, to me shouldn't discourage anyone to jump on this bandwagon as the economy is not gonna be always in the shithole it is now. It will pick up and dividend % will eventually move upwards. Heck maybe new products will emerge.

Even at 150k, translates to 15k a year and at 900 per month, you're looking at a 28% ROI per annum for a practically/NO RISK investment vehicle.

The key here is accumulating capital so you're ready to fly when the percentages improve.

This post has been edited by buggie: Oct 7 2020, 10:53 AM

19 Pages « < 16 17 18 19 >Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.2731sec    0.53    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 8th December 2025 - 07:51 AM