this movie sucks...it just simply embarrass zhao yun.in fact he din lost in the battle but died of illness and guan xin and zhang bao never die in the battle field as well...it simply portrays the stupidity of zhu ge liang..kinda borin also...

uncle liu never done any mistakes at all..if u wanna blame..i would like to say that person is zhu ge liang if u really do the research..he causes shu to decline plus uncle liu's son liu shan was another idiot to destroy his own country..

do u know that it was zhu ge liang's mistake that caused guan yu's death?do u know that is just because of zhu ge liang fussy,shu got very few of general after liu bei's death?li yan was another fellow was highly rated by the historians ,zhu ge liang uses him to defend shu from hu's lu xun?u can imagine how good is he?is a shame for him to stay at the border ?jiang wei was good actually...but deng ai and chong hui was as good as him..so we cannot blame him...to me,zhu ge liang was not really a strategist but a fella who is really good in managing politics in his country..hav u seen his record of managing shu when there is a period he stopped battle?wat if liu feng din die and became the emperor?at least he is a better candidate..liu bei regretted killing him...zhu ge liang and jiang wei wasted shu's strength after so many battle with some lost and some really small win...liu bei know how to his officer reminding zhu ge liang that ma su was a cakap besar where he causes shu cannot atack smoothly anymore

nono...this is a true story...when zhu ge liang asked guan yu to launch an attack on wei..zhao yun and zhang fei guarding lang zhong,閬中...which is either very near or is just beside jing zhou only..if zhu ge liang asked either zhao yun or zhang fei to replace guan yu in guarding jing zhou and as a back up for guan yu...do u think guan yu will died so easily?

---

Added on April 16, 2008, 9:43 pmnono...this is a true story...when zhu ge liang asked guan yu to launch an attack on wei..zhao yun and zhang fei guarding lang zhong,閬中...which is either very near or is just beside jing zhou only..if zhu ge liang asked either zhao yun or zhang fei to replace guan yu in guarding jing zhou and as a back up for guan yu...do u think guan yu will died so easily?

This post has been edited by ivanau88: Apr 16 2008, 09:43 PM

zhu ge liang was described as a very careful person..the problem is jing zhou is very big...dont u feel that he should send someone to fill up the post that guan yu left behind?