When you say, "Who will win?" - What do you mean by that? Vocally? Showmanship?

I used to love Mariah Carey but almost totally lost respect for her nowadays. Her music quality's gone downhill and she starts flaunting her body like every other bimbos in the market nowadays. It's really sad actually. Mariah had a very good voice and she don't have to slut herself just to get to the top again.

While some fans might like her new hit 'Touch My Body', I have to say I hated that song. It's such a long long way from her previous hits like Hero, and etc.

Madonna on the other hand - at least her voice's getting better/improving compared to her 'Like A Virgin' or 'Material Girl' days. Is Madonna a good singer? I honestly don't think so but if you see the progress of both MC and Madonna and compare them - I'd say the winner's Madonna.

Just because Mariah's getting her 18th hit doesn't mean she's improving. Take her new video for example - I wonder if the song will still be a hit if she's not dressed in her undies and singing about touching bodies.

This post has been edited by chibi_tenko: Apr 3 2008, 10:24 PM

My bad. Didn't read the first post.