QUOTE(StarGhazzer @ Sep 24 2008, 03:30 PM)
I've already mentioned that the mechas in Seed are rarely called gundams, it's more due to the OS. That's why we have to take the most appropriate description about being CE gundams, i.e. either shown to have GUNDAM OS or being called a gundam by bandai.
Note that I'm referring to M1 Astrays, and not the red/blue/gold/green frames which ARE referred as gundams by bandai. The M1 astray cannot be confirmed as a gundam as such, otherwise the murasame can be classified as a gundam as well. I do know that the M1 Astrays had Kira's modified OS, but since we didn't see any screen caps of GUNDAM showing up on the console screen, we'll have to use the other definition i.e. gunpla names.
That's why I'm reluctant to include M1 astrays (and murasames) into it... even if you do, we were only shown 3 specific M1 Astrays being present, but have no idea about the actual number of other M1 astrays around.
tanduk and red chicken chin is not a good criteria for being a gundam, because this would mean Calamity and Raider which don't have the red chin don't qualify.
I think the point is, "gundam" in early UC refers to the hero unit, or any specific prototype machines designed by EF. EF can call whatever unit "gundam" they want because they were the creators anyway. Late UC uses "gundam" as a symbol for psychological intimidation after realising the resemblance to the original white devil (F91 and V). W's "gundam" is any machine that uses gundanium alloy (but Vayete and Mercurius do too so maybe the face plays a role here), dunno about X, OO, or Turn A. CE is obviously the OS.
If we wanna go by the series' definition, only Kira Yamato and his gang call it gundams. No one else does because the term is coined only by him. I doubt even the ppl who came up with the original O.S calls it Gundam. Bear in mind the original Gundam O.S is damn lousy until it may not be possible to pilot them, until the coordinators reprogrammed them into something more user friendly. So using O.S as gauge of Gundam or not is kinda moot as well....since when Kira 1s saw the Destiny, he straight away say "GUNDAM?!" when he never see the O.S before. Its just the overall look and it stands out as a hero unit as you said.Note that I'm referring to M1 Astrays, and not the red/blue/gold/green frames which ARE referred as gundams by bandai. The M1 astray cannot be confirmed as a gundam as such, otherwise the murasame can be classified as a gundam as well. I do know that the M1 Astrays had Kira's modified OS, but since we didn't see any screen caps of GUNDAM showing up on the console screen, we'll have to use the other definition i.e. gunpla names.
That's why I'm reluctant to include M1 astrays (and murasames) into it... even if you do, we were only shown 3 specific M1 Astrays being present, but have no idea about the actual number of other M1 astrays around.
tanduk and red chicken chin is not a good criteria for being a gundam, because this would mean Calamity and Raider which don't have the red chin don't qualify.
I think the point is, "gundam" in early UC refers to the hero unit, or any specific prototype machines designed by EF. EF can call whatever unit "gundam" they want because they were the creators anyway. Late UC uses "gundam" as a symbol for psychological intimidation after realising the resemblance to the original white devil (F91 and V). W's "gundam" is any machine that uses gundanium alloy (but Vayete and Mercurius do too so maybe the face plays a role here), dunno about X, OO, or Turn A. CE is obviously the OS.
To me U.C Gundams are the "concept car" of Gundam world...prototypes before they become into mass production models called GMs.
Sep 24 2008, 03:42 PM
Quote
0.0495sec
0.47
7 queries
GZIP Disabled